View more on these topics

Investors may regret switching

I have just read the letter from Ian Thomas from Skandia regarding its new high-charge bond, which it euphemistically calls its enhanced allocation bond (Money Marketing, May 6).

When I saw Danny Cox&#39s review at the back of Money Marketing the week before, I could have thought it was me rather than Danny. However, if Danny (who has incidentally been IFA of the Year a couple of times) is critical, you can rest assured the product has its shortcomings.

Let me recap what the Skandia product does. It takes somebody out of with-profits and substitutes a temporary market value adjuster for a permanent MVA (at least permanent for 10 years) and moves from a low-risk albeit low-potential product into a high-risk unit-linked product.

If you were to read Thomas&#39s letter, you would believe that there is such a thing as a free lunch. I do not think anyone in this industry is naive enough to believe that Skandia is not going to get its 20 per cent back one way or another.

I wonder how many investors would rue the day they made this move when, in a couple of years time, the MVA is removed from their with-profits bonds?

I cannot argue that the asset mix of with-profits bonds is as advantageous for recovering their reserves but who says the stockmarket is going up from here? It would be a very brave IFA who switched someone from with-profits, incurred the MVA and put them in a unit-linked product with very high charges, when actually the market might be going south rather than north.

Peter Hargreaves

Hargreaves Lansdown,



Magian warning on non-reg business

Magian Mutual says it will be very wary of offering professional indemnity cover to intermediaries which have carried out a significant amount of nonregulated business. The statement comes after leading broker Direct Life & Pensions revealed in Money Marketing last week that it was told by its PI broker it would have to disclose any […]

Government u-turn on Equitable – Tories

Shadow Financial Secretary Andrew Tyrie says he has received a letter from Financial Secretary Ruth Kelly saying she would consider a request from the Parliamentary Ombudsman to bring the Government Actuary&#39s Department within her jurisdiction. Previously Kelly said she remained confident that the Penrose report does not provide evidence proving that any of the relevant […]

Scarborough Building Society – Offset-Flexible Base Rate Tracker

Type: Offset tracker mortgage Tracker term: Lifetime of loan Tracker rate:0.99% above Bank of England base rate Payable rate: 5.24% Minimum loan: £25,000 Maximum loan: Up to 95% of valuation subject to a maximum of £200,000, up to 90% of valuation subject to a maximum of £400,000, up to 80% of valuation subject to a […]

AMI says reversion workable definition next challenge

The Association of Mortgage Intermediaries has welcomed the Treasury decision to bring home reversion schemes under FSA regulation. AMI policy advisor Ben Stafford says: “AMI lobbied hard for this and welcomes the decision. Consumers in this market are amongst the most vulnerable in society and need to receive professional advice from qualified and regulated mortgage […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment