View more on these topics

investment view

Smaller-cap stocks are at last returning to favour. Perhaps this is because the FTSE 100 now offers poor value. But the widening gap in the performance between small companies and the FTSE 100 has been a cause of considerable concern. In the US, where the penetration achieved by tracker funds is considerably greater than here, the underperformance of smaller companies has continued for several years. If the same divide remains here, we could see some of our best known names consigned to also rans. For the time being, though, we have seen both the 250 and Small Cap indices move into new high ground.

The active versus passive management argument has never been greater. The spat (if that is the right word) between Perpetual&#39s Roger Cornick and Virgin&#39s Richard Branson was well reported. In truth, active fund managers are feeling rather embattled at the moment. Not only is it extremely difficult to beat an index where there are no expenses and which remains fully invested at a time when share prices have done nothing but rise, but the flow of funds into vehicles designed expressly to track that index creates a demand which results in outperformance.

The problem is not confined to the retail market. The UK&#39s leading pension fund managers – the big four, as they are known – have been steadily losing business to smaller boutiques. While SocGen Asset Management&#39s Nicola Horlick has hardly had time to steal the odd mandate or two, it does go some way to explaining the attractions of setting up a new pension fund management operation when you learn that, since 1993, the big four&#39s share of segregated schemes has fallen by 15 per cent to 38 per cent of the total.

Part of the reason for losing ground is that their performance has failed to sparkle in recent years. Trustees are more canny, diverting ever bigger proportions of their portfolios into index-tracking funds, a move justified by cost as well as performance.

Of course, active managers will be bailed out by a market setback. But Warren Buffett, in his letter to Berkeley Hathaway shareholders, announced that US stocks are not necessarily overvalued. Mind you, this view has not stopped him diversifying his portfolio into bonds and silver – a case of hedging both ends of the inflation equation if ever I saw one.

If the market is not too high, why bother with second-liners? The answer has to be total return. It is now very difficult to achieve much in the way of dividend income from the UK&#39s biggest companies, yet there are plenty of well known smaller firms giving yields greater than inflation, even after knocking off the tax that is becoming increasingly difficult to reclaim. If this turns out to be a correct strategy, then once again it will favour the smaller managers which can be more nimble in less liquid stocks.

Supporting bigger companies has always been a popular pastime for private-client brokers. The Aunt Agathas of this world like to own shares in companies they have heard of and visit, like Marks & Spencer. Stockbrokers themselves, on the other hand, often feel that it is the smaller companies that will deliver the biggest rewards. Needless to say, this has not resulted in superior performance for many portfolios in the last few years, leading to a return to the "you never got fired for buying IBM" syndrome.

When you look at the ground IBM has lost recently, you might wonder whether the "big is beautiful" argument should be adopted when it comes to constructing investment portfolios.

Personally, I fear that the die is now cast and smaller-cap shares are likely to enjoy relatively brief attention while managers rebalance their portfolios or seek value following a market surge. Of course, when we all start drawing our pensions, resulting in the enforced liquidation of those portfolios being put together busily today, the story could be very different.

For the quote of the week, I must return to Warren Buffett. The letter he sent to shareholders – distributed on the internet – included an immortal phrase that seems to owe more to Zen Buddhism than a disciplined and thoughtful investment process: "In a bull market, one must avoid the error of the preening duck that quacks boastfully after a torrential rainstorm, thinking that its paddling skills have caused it to rise in the world. Our appraisal of 1997&#39s performance, then: quack."

Recommended

Financial Options will self-regulate drawdown

IFA network Financial Options is to self-regulate members conducting deferred annuity and income-drawdown business to prevent a possible misselling scandal. The network, which has over 300 member firms and 600 registered individuals, fears many IFAs are unaware of how to give best advice on the complex issue. It is concerned that this could lead to […]

Critical decisions to be made over income drawdown

Some pension experts are warning of yet another glitch in income drawdown. The latest doubt is another spin on critical yields. In the past six months, some gurus have warned that high upfront commission could mean critical yields of 14 per cent or higher will be needed to ensure that the client is not worse […]

New Thing comes to the UK.

With the introduction of a new Thing from the USA the import company Things for you (TFY) expect a high level of investment. &#39The arrival of the Thing is going to be the biggest event since the last bank holiday&#39 predicted the man we stopped on the corner.

CII bans candidate over exam cheating

A Chartered Insurance Institute examination candidate who sneaked in notes written on a handkerchief has been banned from taking any CII exams until October 2000. Pauline Jennifer Wood was disciplined after admitting the attempted cheat. The CII disciplinary committee also found Atul Patel guilty of changing a certificate to indicate a pass had been obtained […]

InFocus - thumbnail

In Focus — February 2015

Jelf Employee Benefits looks at the issue of paying anaesthetist fees when the patient had no chance to discuss or agree to them prior to care; and provides recommendations for avoiding this scenario.

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment