View more on these topics

Investment insight: Are you clear how your ATR tool works?

The regulator says advisers need to know how tools work, but many lack confidence and knowledge

In the post-RDR world, advisory business models are evolving and continual improvements are being made to their financial planning processes.

Increasingly, Square Mile observes that many advisers have designed centralised investment propositions centered around third-party strategic asset allocation tools.

The FCA continues to stress that advisers have a responsibility to understand how such tools work. We have met with several advisers who do not seem to be as fully conversant with these tools as they should be. Worryingly, this could lead to unsuitable advice and potentially bad outcomes for investors.

Risk tools

Advisers will be familiar with the concept of the non-linear pay off between investment risk and reward. Initially, adopting a little more risk can materially enhance returns for a portfolio, however, as more risk is adopted the incremental return benefits become less.

Several risk tools, for example Distribution Technology, are calibrated so that risk bands are determined by equal amounts of volatility. The non-linear relationship between risk and return ensures that the incremental expected return benefit of moving from risk class 2 to 3 is normally greater than say moving from 8 to 9 (see chart 1). The curvature of this line depends upon the risk and return assumptions for each asset class within the model.

Other risk systems, such as EValue, do not apportion risk ratings in equal volatility bands. EValue widens the volatility bands as you move up the risk scale and this results in a more linear progression in the expected return profile.

Chart 2 demonstrates this in a stylised manner and note the significant jump in the volatility range moving from risk grade 8 to 9, relative to moving from 2 to 3. The regulatory required fund SRRI number is also calibrated in similar fashion.

Perils of mismatches

Square Mile does not argue that one approach is right and the other is wrong. However, this subtle difference in approach taken by different models raises some interesting questions. How are clients to be appropriately placed into the correct risk band?

Advisers must use care to ensure that the output from the attitude to risk tool is correctly calibrated with the risk grading scale used within the strategic asset allocation model. This is not so much of a worry when advisers stick with tools from a single suite such as DT’s Dynamic Planner or EValue’s Advisa Centa. But it is a concern when advisers use a more modular approach.

It is very clear that advisers need to take great care in calibrating risk bands across their planning process

A more modular approach allows advisers to cherry-pick what they see as the best ATR tool, the best SAA modelling for example, within their planning process. However, it is very clear that advisers need to take great care in calibrating risk bands across their planning process. Mismatches can easily be overlooked and only become apparent once clients suffer unexpected losses.

More worryingly, we have found some advisers who have taken the recommended asset allocation positions from different modelling to arrive at an average allocation. The various approaches to risk banding by the different systems makes them incompatible. The idea that by taking an average somehow presents a more robust output is just nonsense given the fundamental differences in the way that the risk bands are calibrated.

As it happens, DT’s model currently produces a relatively linear pay off between risk and return (we suspect this is due to the strong return potential of emerging market equities), so the potential issue is not as great as it could be.

However, advisers taking a mishmash of output from multiple tools to build their strategic allocation could easily end up with problems.

Financial planning tools such as ATR systems and SAA tools are complex systems. Advisers should be aware of any limitations and weaknesses in the tools that they use.

Correctly employed, such tools can be used to produce a robust financial planning process fitted around a centralised investment proposition.

Jason Broomer is head of investment at Square Mile Investment Consulting & Research



How much are advisers charging for pension transfers?

Defined benefit pension transfer charges are being put under the microscope again as the regulator turns over more potential conflicts of interest. With the British Steel Pension Scheme the latest to dominate headlines and the FCA ready to interrogate further as it extends its review to include all firms authorised to give pension transfer advice, […]


Pay for top pensions regulator and ombudsman staff revealed

The annual accounts of the Pensions Regulator and The Pensions Ombudsman have revealed salary levels for top staff. Outgoing TPR chief executive Lesley Titcomb’s salary was between £220,000 and £225,000 for 2017/18, with a bonus payment of between £15,000 and £20,000 on top of that. Both amounts were unchanged from 2016/17, and the chief executive’s […]

File image of Welders at work in steel forge

Second British Steel IFA goes into liquidation

A second advice firm involved in the British Steel saga has gone into liquidation, according to an insolvency notice published by The Gazette. An update published on The Gazette’s website shows Retirement & Pension Planning Services, based in Barnsley, appointed liquidators on 25 June. It says this is a solvent liquidation and all known creditors […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm