View more on these topics

Insurance is answer to ailing system

Paying for healthcare in the UK obliquely through taxation does not provide a sufficient inc-entive to make consumers act responsibly.

I applaud the Government&#39s efforts to improve the NHS but we also support the Doctors For Reform for challenging the notion that NHS improvement simply requires bigger doses of the same medicine.

It may be a worthwhile aspiration but free healthcare is not a fundamental right. It is apparent that the emphasis on trying to make healthcare free for everyone can easily obscure the reality that with “rights” come responsibilities.

Those who argue more for rights might be satisfied with a simple invoice given to a patient stating the cost of treatment that the Government picked up on the individual&#39s behalf. At the other end of the spectrum, those that argue for responsibility might like to see the patient paying for most of the care themselves.

Both extremes have limitations, the first creating an exp-ensive paper factory, the latter excluding those without sufficient financial reserves. We believe that a form of insurance offers a suitable middle ground and we see no reason why a welfare system should not benefit from the efficiencies learnt from a competitive market.

Shared costs, co-payment, even to a certain extent, the excess system of traditional insurers, have merits in obligating the customer to appreciate the costs of care. Insurance companies should not hesitate to offer their private market experience to the public domain, nor should the Government baulk at looking for market solutions.

A healthcare system should not simply be a means of dem-onstrating one&#39s ideological or political beliefs. It is about providing a system that offers appropriate medical care in a sustainable way.

At a time when many people in this country do not believe that the NHS can or will del-iver a satisfactory standard of healthcare in its current form, it is time for a fundamental rethink, to which the insurance market has much to contribute.

Dr Thom Van Every is chief medical officer at Patient Choice

Recommended

Chattel Drive

On December 11, 2003, the Inland Revenue published a consultation document entitled, Tax Treatment of Pre-Owned Assets, in which it outlined how an annual income tax charge will be levied from April 6, 2005 on the benefit that people enjoy when they have arranged free continuing use of major capital assets that they once owned. […]

Actuaries tap into projection odds

Projection rates could be presented in the form of odds which would mean more to the UK public, suggests The Actuarial Profession&#39s input into the FSA review of projections. TAP says simple percentages appear to cause confusion in the minds of a big number of consumers, arguing that succinctness, clarity and relevance in the computation […]

Aifa says menu has become complex

Aifa has criticised the FSA&#39s proposed menu saying it has become overly complex and is in danger of losing its key message in its response to CP04/3: Reforming Polarisation: a menu for being open with consumers. Aifa says an overly complex menu will not be read by consumers, also criticising it for having a disproportionate […]

Mortgage Intelligence offers free network membership

Mortgage Intelligence has announced it is offering mortgage intermediaries free membership to its network. The offer applies until October 31 and applies to both its Spirit solution for appointed representatives and Vantage for directly authorised intermediaries. It will also include a free, face-to-face compliance health check for all new Vantage members. MI will also continue […]

Newsletter

News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up

Comments

    Leave a comment