View more on these topics

Inside Edge – Tony Kempster

In a Saturday FT article a couple of weeks ago, Stuart Fowler exhorted Ron Sandler to force the closure of all with-profits funds and insist those clients move their cash into other investment vehicles where they can see what exactly is happening to their money. He thinks this would be good for investor education and good for competition.

Of all the mad things I have heard or read about with-profits recently that is just about the maddest. The fact that Mr Fowler&#39s article is thoughtful and well reasoned does not take away from the madness of his conclusion.

It is a bit like sky diving with two parachutes and chucking away the second one because the first one did not work and therefore probably the second one will not work either.

It is typical of the more irrational conclusions doing the rounds on with-profits which then obscure some real truths that many IFAs and the more forward thinking product prov-iders might well sign up for.

For example, that the prov-iders need to work much harder at improving the transparency of their products or that the general level of investment expertise within the IFA community needs to continue to rise.

Fowler&#39s efforts to ridicule the work of the FSA to drive these kind of improvements across the industry serve to undermine the genuine efforts being made by many product providers to address the legitimate concerns of policyholders and advisers. Prudential has been working hard and we are already providing clearer explanations of the smoothing mechanism, developing transparent fund charging structures and ensuring clearer disclosure to customers about what they have been advised to buy. You might be surprised to learn that we might well sign up for a third-party review of how we manage clients&#39 money invested in the with-profits fund. At the core of this debate is the key issue of whether the with-profits smoothing mechanism meets the real needs of real customers. What is missing from much of the criticism is an understanding of those needs.

It is clear that in a low-interest, low-inflation environment, even risk-averse customers will seek to find ways other than simply putting their money on deposit to secure higher ret-urns. However, the volatility of share price movements in recent years has leapt dramatically and the vast majority of such customers have no app-etite for exposing all their life savings to the rollercoaster movements of equities.

Having a major financial institution smooth out the peaks and troughs in exposed investment returns is an attractive option for many of them. Hence, the growing market share of with-profits investment vehicles and the continuing high level of sales despite the usually ill-informed negative publicity we see so much of.

There is no doubt that many advisers appreciate the role that with-profits can play in their overall financial planning for clients but that they also recognise the need to understand at a deeper level how with-profits operates.

We need to tackle the objections and negativity used to talk down with-profits and work together to restore confidence in the market. One of the most useful things we can do bet-ween us is to dispel the myth that those who promote with-profits do so to the exclusion of all else. With-profits is a potentially important element within a balanced portfolio. In these turbulent and increasingly volatile times it&#39s likely to be a more important element in future, not less important.

Tony Kempster is director of Prudential UK Intermediaries


Cemap registrations exceed 2,000 per month

Statistics from the Institute of Financial Services show new registrations for the Certificate in Mortgage Advice and Practice exceeded 2,000 in each of the last four consecutive months. The IFS says it expected this bulge in registrations in the approach to the December deadline as advisers realise time is running out. Head of the regulatory […]

Britannial International – The Deferred Interest Account

Tuesday, 21 May 2002 Type: Offshore high interest account Aim: Income Minimum investment: Lump sum £25,000 Place of registration: Isle of Man Yield: 4.75% gross a year Isa link: No Charges: None Commission: None Tel: 01624 681100

&#39Ageing population will be boost to CI market&#39

More people are considering taking out critical-illness cover because of increased longevity and the higher chance of succumbing to medical problems, according to consumer analyst Mintel.A survey of 2,160 adults found that 11 per cent already have critical cover while a further 11 per cent find the idea appealing. Mintel found that most policies are […]

NCC wants taskforce on advice for lower-earners

The FSA should implement the defined-payment system but only when it has sorted out extending access to advice to lower-earners, says the National Consumer Council.The call comes in the same week as the body representing IFAs within the FSA, the Small Business Practitioner Panel, says the regulator should drop the depolarisation proposals affecting IFAs.The panel […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm