View more on these topics

Inside EDGE

Not many people have yet signed up to stakeholder pensions and many of

those who have will be too young to write.

It is proving to be a tax-efficient savings vehicle for the wealthy. Not

quite what the Government had in mind. But it still has the potential to be

the product around which our salvation from poverty in old age can be


For this to happen, though, the Government will have to bite the bullet of

compulsion. This will have to come sooner rather than later as,

eventually, the political implications of tax increases to support the

elderly or the social effects of poverty will seem even worse than


The reason why compulsion is the only way is that no amount of education

or tax incentive will make the majority of young people invest as much in

their future as they should at the time when it has the greatest

opportunity for growth. Apart from a few anoraks, most young people are

rightly more interested in sex, drugs and rock and roll.

So, instead of trying to convince them, which will fail, they will have to

be compelled, which will succeed. The trick is to compel them without

causing them to stop voting for you in even greater numbers than at present.

There is a way. It has never been thought of before. Probably because it

is so simple.

The current workforce is being asked to pay for the pensions of our

predecessors and to provide our own, too. If it works, the next generation

will then only have to pay for their own pensions. If this takes full

effect, the tax burden will reduce.

So, the answer is to spread the cost of paying for our pensions across

several generations and to defer some tax reductions in the future as a

longer-term project works its way through. This will work because people

will not miss what they have never had (lower taxes).

In practice, this means that the Government would borrow money today (not

raise taxes) to make modest contributions on behalf of every worker to

their own choice of stakeholder pension. The level of contribution would be

calculated as sufficient to provide a 21year-old with a pension big enough

to keep them off inc-ome support at 65. Individuals and employers would be

all-owed to top this up with the current types of tax incentives.

Over the next 45 years, Government spending requirements would fall as the

proportion of fully funded people reached 65. But these savings would be

applied to repaying the debt accumulated in the early years. Eventually,

all the debt would be repaid and taxes reduced permanently thanks to the

state effectively funding pensions at the start rather than at the end.

So, the Government will give individuals a “free” stakeholder pension.

This might actually make them more popular. Once they have their own

account, they will be more likely to take an interest and to invest more

money earlier than they might otherwise have done. There is a drawback. The

Government would have to accept that it was going to borrow a massive

amount of money over a very long period but it would be able to see how and

when the money would be repaid.

At the moment, society seems to be opting for telling people that they

face poverty if they do not make their own provision. Although scaring

people helps, it is not the answer because people tend to be easier to

scare once they get a bit older. I know this.

What we would really need to do is to scare them sufficiently in their

early 20s but this is just not realistic in most cases. Compulsion is

therefore the only answer.

This solution spreads the costs of the transformation to universal funded

pensions across the generations that will benefit from the change. In doing

so, it enables the transformation to happen without any generation of

taxpayers regarding the solution as a burden on them.

Daniel Godfrey is director general of the AITC


Berkeley Morgan bids for further growth

Financial and insurance services company Berkeley Morgan Group, whichincludes Berkeley Morgan IFA, has appointed Ray Kuhler, 41, as an executivedirector. Kuhler&#39s appointment is to assist continued growth following thegroup&#39s recent acquisition of IFAs Moneyhill and Gee & Co. He was previously a director of business developments at Skandia, where hespent 14 years. Kuhler will be […]

IFAs warned as Welsh reveal LTC proposals

IFAs must be wary when advising clients on their long-term care insuranceneeds because of the differences in funding plans in the UK, providers havewarned. The warning comes after the Welsh Assembly said it plans to join Scotlandand Northern Ireland in splitting from Westminster over funding for care. The Welsh plans, which will not come into […]

PIA throws out IFA who forged signature

The PIA has terminated the individual registration of Christopher DavidCundell, a director with IFA Wilman & Lodge Financial Services of 12 OtleyStreet, Skipton, North Yorkshire. The regulator says Cundell forged the signature of a client on a documenthe submitted to the PIA ombudsman. He did so without the client&#39s knowledgeand with the ultimate objective of […]

Equitable deal could see lower payouts to GAR holders

Equitable Life is only weeks away from issuing a compromise deal whichcould save the society from spiralling uncertainty but payoffs toguaranteed annuity rate holders could be lower than expected. The deal should be published to policyholders in mid-September followingan “open and constructive” meeting between policyholder action grouprepresentatives and Equitable&#39s board last week. Any proposals will […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm