View more on these topics

Inside edge

Imagine the scene at a suburban breakfast table in early February. The husband passes a mailpack across the table to his wife, who is engrossed in the crossword.

“There&#39s another Isa offer here, darling. We have only lost 30 per cent on last year&#39s Isa and 55 per cent on the 2001 version. We really must hope for some growth out of that 2000 technology Isa, which is now down by 85 per cent.”

His wife replies: “Don&#39t you think this would be a great time to buy another one?”

This exchange is what the entire fund management industry is hoping will be a common occurrence over the next few months. But the chance of this happening in any significant numbers is as close to zero as it is possible to be.

During the bull market peak at the end of the 1990s, the only reason why a huge number of building society savers switched their hard-earned savings from deposit accounts into the stockmarket is because they thought it was a one-way bet and that they would make money. Despite all the health warnings, Isas have singularly failed to do what most people wanted them to do when they bought them – go up in value.

Using the Ronseal test, this would be rather like the paint that was supposed to dry in 20 minutes still being wet after three years. The Isa has not done what it said on the tin.

I believe there will not be an Isa season in 2003 – if, by Isa season, we mean direct mail and off-the-page cheques with coupons.

The only possible excuse for fund management companies and intermediaries doing mass mailshots is to pursue the one overriding theme for many investors in the next year – consolidation of Pep and Isa portfolios and selling out of funds that have let them down badly.

It is possible that 2003 could lead to several fund management companies having a sensational year, with a number of other groups struggling. Bizarrely, however, this could happen while overall fund industry assets decrease, with no new net savers being added to our products. For one group to prosper, another will have to suffer. It will be a switching year.

Over the past couple of years, the incredible rotation in fund managers from group to group has been very difficult to keep up with. Add to this the number of managers setting up their own boutiques and the landscape for investors to choose their funds from has become bewildering.

Many investors now own funds which have changed name two or three times and changed manager on more occasions than this.

Since the end of the technology boom, many investors have patiently waited for the value of their shrunken Isa to increase. They are generally waiting for that important day when their £7,000 is restored to its original invested amount. Of course, at that time they will sell it but at least psychologically they will not have done so at a loss. The industry is therefore left with two completely different sets of clients.

The first set of clients have taken out an Isa over the years following a face-to-face meeting with their financial adviser. They have long-term financial needs such as university education for their children and building up a pot of money for their daughter&#39s wedding. For them, equities and Isas have been a means to an end. They remain unhappy about the value of their holdings but understand why they bought them in the first place. Isas bought at current levels may in the long term prove to be their best investment yet.

The second set of clients have a similar understanding of equity markets as they do of the buy-to-let property market. They invest in things that go up. However, when they do not go up, they soon lose enthusiasm and do not return for several years.

The first set of clients will invest in their Isas throughout the year when they meet with their advisers. The second set of clients will throw our mailshots in the bin.

It is not a good time to own shares in the printing firms which serve the financial services industry.

Ian Chimes is managing director of Credit Suisse Asset Management


FSA in plea to public for alert on misleading ads

The FSA is calling on the public to be vigilant over financial advertisements they feel are misleading and has published a guide on its website to help them identify misleading ads.It wants consumers to send in examples of ads they do not believe are genuine.Consumer director Anna Bradley says in the run-up to the Isa […]

Bristol & West launches new fixed rate mortgages

Bristol & West is launching three fixed rate mortgages, one is a five year fixed product and the other two run for two years. The five year fix has a rate of 4.49 per cent, a loan to value of 95 per cent and an arrangement fee of £299. One two year fix with a […]

Incentives needed for low-paid savings

The majority of IFAs see more generous financial incentives as the best way to get the low-paid saving, says research from Axa.Increasing tax to pay for improved state pension provision was rejected by 68 per cent of IFAs, with 63 per cent saying the best way to address the pension funding crisis is to increase […]

Have your say on Green Paper

The Pensions Green Paper – week twoMoney Marketing and Taxbriefs are teaming up to invite readers to put their views on the Government&#39s new Pensions Green Paper and the Inland Revenue&#39s tax paper by answering the questions listed here on the right.Taxbriefs will then put your views to the Secretary of State for Work and […]

Who cares?

By Tracey Dickson, marketing consultant There are almost 7 million carers in the UK – that’s around 10 per cent of the population who provide unpaid care for a disabled, seriously ill or older loved one.1 But according to a report from the charity Carers UK, 20 per cent of people providing 50 hours or more of care […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm