View more on these topics

IA launches consultation on ETF sector classification

The Investment Association has launched a consultation on including exchange-traded funds in its IA sector classifications.

The IA sector system is meant to make it easier for investors to compare fund, including on performance and charges.

The consultation on including ETFs in sectors has invited industry figures to give their take on it potential advantages or disadvantages this could have.

In line with the IA’s current approach to other fund types, only UK domiciled ETFs, or EU UCITs with HMRC reporting fund status would be included. The consultation will close on 1 February 2019.

Each IA sector has “a clear definition”, which sets out the criteria that funds must fulfill.

IA sectors are mostly based on asset classes, such as equities and fixed income, and may also have a geographic focus, for example Japan or North America. A handful of sectors also focus on investment strategy – like targeted absolute return and volatility managed.

Commenting on the decision to launch the consultation, IA director of investment and capital markets Galina Dimitrova says: “We are continually monitoring the fund market to ensure that the IA sectors reflect the wide range of products the asset management industry has to offer savers.

Investment Association launches new fintech project

“The primary purpose of the IA sectors is to serve the needs of consumers and their advisers and the addition of ETFs must be done in their best interests.”

ETF industry figures have welcomed the trade body’s move, arguing it could lead to greater transparency.

According to the UCITS ETF platform HANetf co-chief executive Hector McNeill the move shows “a great deal of foresight”.

McNeill says: “The fact is most investors have a variety of both active and passive strategies in their portfolios, including ETFs, and by including them in comparison tables, it will enable investors to gain a better understanding of how their portfolios are performing.

“Improving transparency in this way can surely only be a good thing for end investors, and we hope the scope of ETFs included can also be widened over time. The next generation of ETFs, such as thematic, smart beta and eventually active products, will sit very well in this initiative.”

McNeill adds: “These new ETFs will be much more focused on after fee performance rather than just being judged on how low the fees are, so to have them alongside active funds makes a lot of sense.”

The reports of a consultation on the inclusion of ETFs in IA sectors prompted some to caution against what they see as potential drawbacks, however, warning against confusion for investors and advisers when comparing funds.

Chelsea Financial Services managing director Darius McDermott says: “My view is that if it is a standard ETF, for example one that invests in UK equities, then it would be fine to add to the UK All Companies sector.

“ETFs are gaining popularity and are being more widely used, so it would seem a sensible and useful outcome.

“My objection would be if it has leverage, for example, as this would not be a like for like comparison, do the IA will need to make sure that the ETFs go into the appropriate sectors. What this may result in is a number of less-standard ETFs going into the unclassified or specialist sectors, which are already over-populated.

“This wouldn’t actually help advisers or investors make sensible comparisons and choices, so the IA may need to consider more specialist ETFs in more detail.”

AJ Bell head of active portfolios Ryan Hughes notes that ETFs are “an investment structure, they are not a way of investing”, and is also concerned about unclear comparisons.

Hughes says: “If what you’re doing is saying let’s have one sector for all funds, then it should include ETFs, funds and investment trusts, and surely that’s what they are saying here. If the IA are doing this for the sake of adding a load of passive funds to sectors then that just adds more confusion for investors.

“The inclusion of passive funds will mean that where you have got lots of passive funds in a sector they will occupy the bottom of the second quartile and the top of the third quartile, and active funds will sit above and below that – and that feels like a move that will create confusion for investors.”



FCA deepens preparations for no-deal Brexit

The FCA has published a second consultation paper on how it will ensure continuity in the regulatory regime regardless of the outcome of Brexit. In the event the UK leaves the EU without a deal, the FCA says, the Treasury would treat EU member states in the same way it treats non-EU member states. However, […]


Intrinsic scores director hire from Sesame

Advice network Intrinsic has poached Sesame Bankhall Group operations director Stuart Davies for its management team. Davies is joining as adviser services and compliance operations director in January, and part of his role will be to help develop planning and compliance technology for the Quilter-owned network. Davies’ move follows that of ex-Sesame Bankhall colleague Stephen […]

SJP chairman takes non-exec role at building society

St James’s Place chairman Iain Cornish has taken up a role as a non-executive director at Leeds Building Society. A stock exchange notice shows that Cornish was appointed to the position on Friday. Last month, SJP announced that current chair Sarah Bates would be stepping down with Cornish, who chaired the firm’s risk committee, taking […]


Scott Gallacher: Consider the firm’s fate before taking its clients

A perennial question for advice firms is how best to attract clients. That can then lead to the related question of who actually “owns” the clients. To avoid reliance on individual advisers prospecting, some firms create their own brands. This can certainly help attract clients but, as all good advisers know, there is more to it […]

Gail Counihan

Is the hype around electric vehicles justified?

In order to muscle conventional vehicles off the road and become the dominant technology, electric vehicles need to be able to hold their own in three important ways: performance, practicality and affordability. Gail Counihan, Responsible Investment Analyst at Royal London Asset Management, takes a closer look at these three areas. Read the article here Past […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm