View more on these topics

Independent view – Harry Katz

Tony Byrne voiced what is probably the view of the majority in his criticism of Europe. I am pleased to have been given the opportunity to put a contrary view.

It is not so much that life outside the EU would be that much worse but inside it we have the chance to be so much better. If you do not like something it can only effectively be changed from within.

Compared with our immediate European neighbours,we work longer hours, have fewer holidays and on average live in smaller dwellings. In 2000, the average hours worked per day in the UK was 8.7 compared with 7.7 in Italy and 7.9 in France. Spain was nearest at 8.1.

We had 28 days holiday per year compared with France with 47 and Germany (with the least) at 41.

As far as cost of living is concerned, France was 7 per cent lower, Germany 8 per cent, Spain 26 per cent less and Italy 23 per cent lower.

In 2001, by standard measure of wealth (GDP in PPS per inhabitant), we came in at eighth place out of 15.

Our stockmarket was the poorest performer between 2000 and 2004. When taking indexation into account, the stockmarket actually went backwards. Success?

Compared with our immediate neighbours, our quality of life still lags well behind.I would rather use the French health service or the German railways.

We are 11th out of the 15 in terms of spending on social protection per head – not much to be proud of.

Set that against income and wealth taxes, social contributions and other transfers in the UK are 32 per cent of total household income (2002 figure – probably more now). In France, it is 25 per cent, in Germany 33 per cent, in Spain and Italy 29 per cent. We have the second-highest loss of total gross income. What do we get for our money?

But we are European champions in spending. We spend 95 per cent of disposable household income. In France it is 84.2 per cent, Germany 84.9 per cent, Spain 88.4 per cent and Italy 89.8 per cent.

These are savings ratios of between double and triple ours. They have a better standard of living and still manage to save. I&#39ll have a piece of that.

Over the past 25 years, the UK has had a lower economic growth than any of its major competitors. (purchasing power income per head). One of the most startling statistics from the OECD was that at the current rate of growth Poland will overtake us in 15 years time. How sad.

A change in political, economic and constitutional power cannot be any worse than the clots we have got.

Pro-Europeans are obviously men of vision who look further forward than the next election. It is nothing to do with empire building, just economic survival. And it is working. The EU&#39s share of the world&#39s total trade in services is ahead of the US by some 20 per cent in 2001 and only slightly behind in goods.

What is the immediate advantage to financial services and the public at large?

I agree with Tony Byrne that the UK financial services industry is more advanced than that of our EU partners. But that is a case for opting in. Unit trusts have been converted into OEICs and ICVCs. This is wasted effort with a currency differential. Who wants to buy term insurance denominated in sterling if you live in Belgium? Then, of course, there is the complete wiping out of currency risk – that has to be a worthwhile goal.

I also have sympathy with the matter concerning interpreters. I propose that the official EU language is Italian.It will stop all the squabbling with France. Italian is the most mellifluous and beautiful language in the world. It was the original European language (in its older form). Learning a language is a good discipline and Italian is the least spoken of the five principal tongues. Best of all, we will all be able to follow the opera.

Remember, we have a German Queen and Austrian Prince, born in Greece. Our history abounds with our European links from Caesar to Albert of Saxe Coburg.

History tells us we are European. We are denying our heritage as well as our future by not embracing the opportunities that await us.

Forza Europa!

Harry Katz is managing director of Norwest Consulting


Cash deposit account at 1 per cent above the base rate

The Government has announced the charge caps for its cash deposit accounts. The rate of interest payable has been set at 1 per cent within the base rate. This is a reduction from the currnet 2 per cent margin for cash ISAs.

Genesis Home Loans – Minerals: Galena

Type: Discounted rate adverse credit mortgage Discounted term: Until November 30, 2005 Discount: 1.75% Payable rate: 6.5% Minimum loan: £25,001 Maximum loan: Up to 95% of valuation subject to a maximum of £300,000 Income multiples: Up to 3.5 times principal income plus second or three times joint Conditions: House purchase only, maximum £3,000 in CCJs […]

ABI says rise not generous enough

The ABI says the Government has not been generous enough in raising the price cap to 1.5 per cent though it describes the move as a step in the right direction. ABI director general Mary Francis says: “The decision is a step in the right direction. The Government has recognised that the one per cent […]

Kirwan quitting Abbey for Widows

Nick Kirwan has resigned as head of marketing and product development at Abbey for Intermediaries after nine years and is set to join Scottish Widows. Kirwan, who is well known for his work with Scottish Provident and ABI working parties, is joining Widows in the early autumn as its marketing director, protection, as part of […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm