View more on these topics


It is time for a reality check. Why do people go into business? Why did you become an IFA? We all have the same reason – to make money for yourself an your family.

If you are in business for yourself, why would you take the commercial risks if not to offer the prospect of achieving greater rewards? Any business exists to generate profits – that is the first rule of commerce. If you think differently then you are either so wealthy that your business is a plaything or you are not facing reality.

We are not in business to advise clients. The advice is the vehicle which facilitates the true purpose of the business – to make profit. If we are not profitable then we will fail.

Why, then, have pension providers decided to spend millions on promoting a pension plan that they know cannot make a profit for more than 10 years? And have these companies discussed this proposition with their shareholders?

The decision to market stakeholder plans is all about gaining market share and not about being profitable. But not everyone can win as there is only so much market share available. There will be a number of spectacular losers in the years ahead.

Chasing volume is a dangerous game – far better to chase profit. The problem with going for volume is that you have costs which reduce the available profit. In the case of stakeholder, the costs will exceed the revenue and result in losses. How clever is that? Far better to take these costs and improve on why you have to offer a higher value alternative, do you not think?

Stakeholder will be a spectacular flop. Of course, the Government will change whatever needs to be changed to try to ensure a result but they have overlooked the obvious – people do not buy pensions, they have to be sold them.

Think about it – if people bought pensions, invested appropriate amounts , had sufficient life assurance, critical illness and income protection, etc, then financial advisers would have no place in financial planning. The reality is that people do not have enough invested in pension, savings are poor and life and health assurance cover inadequate.

The Government has decided cost is the overriding consideration and there is no place for advice in the pension planning process – at least no place for paid advice. It expects that we will not only give client advice on stakeholder pension but actually do so at a loss.

The high and mighty are happy to roll out the old chestnut that the financial services profession has been ripping off clients for years, flogging high commission products with no regard to the client&#39s position.

Any business relationship should be based on a win-win principle so both parties benefit. The IFA sector is populated by hard working, decent people who try to do the best for their clients and make a profit at the same.

We are being forced to become unprofitable because if we sell pensions other than stakeholder we shall be deemed to be doing so just for the commission – and therefore for our own selfish reasons.

There is a solution to this dilemma – either do not give pension advice or if you do make sure it is profitable. For many small IFAs, pension business is a valuable source of income, so how can we make this business profitable?

Discuss with your clients the commercial reality of the stakeholder position in terms of your inability to give advice on unprofitable business.

If they value your advice and planning skills they will want a win-win position – if not, show them the door. Reach an agreement that you must both win from the business you transact – reasonable people want you to benefit as well themselves. Discuss with the client whether they wish to pay fees only or to consider using a non-stakeholder commission paying plan to meet the costs of your advice.

If they prefer to use a stakeholder plan and pay fees, get them to sign an agreement for the fees payable for your advice, implementation of the plan and agree a retainer payment for ongoing advice.

Better still, get paid in advance to prevent a client taking your advice and transacting the business direct.

Everything has a price. You get nothing for nothing is this life. The public says it wants organic food but will not pay a little more for it, it wants improved public services but would shun any rise in taxes – and such is the case with professional services.

Over 100 years ago John Ruskin was right when he commented on the reality of business balance and the fact that you cannot get the best of anything at the lowest price.

As far as the price chasers are concerned – other distribution channels can have them.


Aifa warns of overlap on Myners-style review

Aifa chairman Lord Hunt has written to Chancellor Gordon Brown voicing concerns about the proposed Myners-style review of the retail personal finance market. The review, announced by Brown in his Budget speech, will look at adviser remuneration, with-profits, unit trusts and investment trusts as well as the investment skills base of advisers. Hunt wants Brown […]

Johnson says no advice is needed for stakeholder

The Treasury has taken its toughest line yet against advice with a letter to Conservative MP John Randall from economic secretary Melanie Johnson saying stakeholder does not need advice. It has provoked a furious response from the industry who warn there is a risk of widespread misbuying. The move comes as the Treasury is about […]

LIA offers fee-free deal

The LIA is allowing former Prudential, Sun Life Financial of Canada and Britannic salesmen to suspend their membership subscriptions for up to six months following recent redundancies. The LIA is writing to members, confirming they can suspend subscription fees for six months or until they find new employment without affecting their membership. Up to 5,000 […]

Take your partners by the hand

We are not in the business of just surviving. At Axa, we are committed to building a business which both embraces the changes and thrives in the new world being ushered in by stakeholder pensions. To achieve that aim, we are making big changes to our business, not just in terms of our internal systems […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm