View more on these topics


The truth is out at last. When Treasury economic secretary Melanie Johnson stated that stakeholder does not need advice, it confirmed a long-held belief that the Government does not see a place in its world view for IFAs.

The fact that it does not know the difference between independent and tied advice and lays most of the blame for misselling with IFAs demonstrates a level of ignorance about our industry that needs to be addressed urgently.

If taken to the extreme, Johnson&#39s statement about stakeholder holds true for many service industries. But does she not realise that most people do not have the time, inclination or confidence to adopt the DIY approach to financial planning?

Recent research by clearing house Bacs, showing that around 75 per cent of adults have not even heard of stakeholder, only strengthens the argument for advice.

But perhaps Johnson has spent too much time away from the real world, being flattered by the attentions of big business, to understand the needs of ordinary people.

The disproportionate ministerial ear-time given to the powerful and wealthy is not new, nor is it the affliction of just a handful of ministers. However, it does make it more difficult for the rest of us to get a fair hearing.

But Chancellor Gordon Brown&#39s full endorsement in his Budget speech of the recommendations made in the Myners report – meaning yet another review of the retail personal finance market – could be the opportunity we have been waiting for.

This could not only influence the future of our industry but could also educate ministers that we are not all the predatory, commission-hungry sharks they seem to think.

I say “could” because, as yet, nothing has been decided as to who will be carrying out the review, the terms of reference and how much, if any, public consultation there will be. Aifa has been in touch with the Treasury on all these issues and hopes to get a response in the near future.

It will also be making a great deal of fuss on our behalf to ensure there will be full transparency and high levels of consultation with all who will be affected by the review, including consumers.

We as individuals can also play our part. The original Myners report was a review of institutional investment. Aifa chairman Lord Hunt expressed surprise when the final report made reference to personal finance.

However, in the foreword of the consultation paper published in May 2000, Paul Myners states: “I wish to focus on whether there are factors distorting decision making by institutional investors…Such distortions could arise from many sources… from the incentive structures for each participant in the industry including professional advisers.”

We all lead busy lives and know our areas of specialisation. It is unlikely that many of us would pay much attention to a review of institutional investment – I know I did not until after the findings were announced. But if I had taken the time to read the Myners consultation paper when it was first published, I might have responded to it.

Now, with the benefit of hindsight, I do not intend to sit back and remain silent when this latest review finally gets under way. I hope everyone else in the industry also makes his or her views known.

I cannot see this review being different from any other. It is, therefore, more than likely that full opportunity will be given to respond.

But do not expect the Treasury to publicise the fact widely or to send you any information. We will have to rely on our usual channels to keep us informed of when the consultation paper is finally drawn up and published.

If at that stage you want to put forward your views, approach the Treasury directly. Fortunately, thanks to the internet, it is very easy. Full details of the review will, no doubt, be put on the Treasury website at in due course.

When the consultation paper is finally posted on the website, download, print, read and digest it. Details for responding to the review will also be given – normally a contact name, address, telephone number and email address as well as the deadline for putting forward your views.

Do not ignore this opportunity, after all, it is your livelihood that could be at stake. Otherwise a career change to pension scheme trustee might prove appealing.

Donna Bradshaw is communications director at Fiona Price & Partners


&#39Stakeholder will be half of IFA pension business&#39

Stakeholder pensions will account for half of IFAs&#39 pension business after its launch in April, according to a survey conducted at Royal & Sun Alliance&#39s recent IFA corporate business roadshows.Almost two-thirds of the 300 IFAs who attended the roadshows predicted that stakeholder would account for half of their pension sales in the future but traditional […]

AMP set to acquire Towry Law

EXCLUSIVE Money Marketing understands insurance group AMP is set to acquire national IFA Towry Law as part of its UK expansion strategy.The move follows the announcement on February 23 that Towry Law suspended its shares pending a stockmarket announcement.AMP spokesman Ken McKay says: “We do not comment on rumours.”Towry Law marketing director Mike Bowman says […]

Stakeholder waiver of premium rules &#39are a hornets&#39 nest&#39

The General Insurance Standards Council says rules forcing it to regulate IFAs on sales of waiver of premium for stakeholder are a “hornets&#39 nest of complication”.IFAs must submit to two regulators if they sell waiver of premium with stakeholder after September. Advisers have been aware for a number of years that failure to offer waiver […]

Moneyquest launches mortgage telenet site is launching a mortgage website aiming to steer browsers to its telephone consultants.The Moneyquest website advises browsers not to buy online, instead recommending they speak to a trained salesperson who then applies on the customer&#39s behalf through the IFonline portal. It will not charge an arrangement fee for the service.Moneyquest operations director Paul Reynolds […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm