View more on these topics

Incoming FCA chairman reveals investment in film tax-avoidance scheme

The incoming chair of the FCA, former lawyer Charles Randell, has revealed to MPs he invested in a film partnership scheme that has been at the centre of a battle with HM Revenue & Customs.

The news represents a fresh blow to the regulator, which has been facing questions over its refusal to publish a report that condemned the treatment of thousands of small-business customers  by the Royal Bank of Scotland’s Global Restructuring Group after the financial crisis.

Randell, who appeared before MPs on the influential Treasury committee this week,  was grilled over what he called an “error of judgement” that saw him embroiled in an Ingenious scheme promoted by his financial adviser in 2006.

The Ingenious scheme was at the centre of a long battle with HM Revenue & Customs over hundreds of millions of pounds in tax and interest charges. In 2016, the tax tribunal decided that Randell could claim for tax relief at a much lower rates than those the scheme promoted.

Randell said: “It’s clear to me now that far from taking any comfort from that [assurance], I should have seen it as a warning signal.”

Randell disclosed his involvement in the scheme before he was appointed at the FCA, the FT reports. He repaid HMRC £114,000 plus interest, stopped his investment and ceased using his financial adviser.

In a letter dated 19 February and addressed to the chair of the select committee Nicky Morgan, the Treasury’s permanent secretary Tom Scholar said Randell disclosed his investment into the scheme at his interview for the FCA role.

In the letter, Scholar confirmed that the assessment panel for the position at the regulator “was content that Mr Randell had taken appropriate action, and concluded that this should not prevent him from being appointed to the roles”.

At the committee hearing, Randell signalled his intention to address the watchdog’s communication strategy, saying investigating matters such as the FCA’s work on the RBS scandal would be his “first priority”.

Randell said the relationship between the regulator and the Treasury had traditionally been “difficult but successful” and confirmed his intention to conduct a personal assessment into the background behind the strain between public expectations, the Treasury committee, and what the FCA felt itself able to offer.

He said: “The first side of it is how well the FCA communicates and what it can and cannot do and the timetables for doing what it does. We need to look at some of these situations that have caused the tensions. I hope my role as the chair of the FCA is not to come here and defend the FCA, but to hold account of what the FCA does.”

Randell, who is currently an external member of the Prudential Regulation Committee of the Bank of England, as well as a non-executive director of the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy will succeed John Griffith-Jones as FCA chairman on 1 April.



Another British Steel adviser loses pension transfer permissions

An IFA firm that was critical of the media’s coverage of the British Steel pension scandal has stopped advising on pension transfers, following intervention from the regulator. The firm, County Capital Wealth Management – which also trades as The Pension Review Service – says it has voluntary suspended its pension transfer permissions, but expects this […]


Aviva replatforming issues delay adviser payments

Problems with Aviva’s platform upgrade have meant some payments to advisers have failed to go through. Advisers have also complained to Money Marketing that there have been delays to income payments due to clients. Aviva has been beset with problems since it launched its new FNZ-powered platform on 23 January. This launch followed five-days of […]

Peeling back the layers: The Mifid II effect on fund of fund fees

Firms that offer multi-manager funds have defended their strategies following mounting pressure on the industry in light of new cost disclosure rules. Concerns exist that multi-manager funds, which are by nature more expensive than single strategy funds, would have even higher costs when transaction fees are put under the spotlight.Money Marketing has analysed some of […]


HMRC wins landmark case against BBC presenter over self-employed tax

The taxman’s treatment of the self-employed has been thrust into the spotlight again as a former BBC presenter has been told to pay back hundreds of thousands of pounds to HMRC. Former Look North host Christa Ackroyd has lost a court battle for backdated tax against HMRC over her use of a so-called personal service […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment