View more on these topics

IFA clashes with watchdog over &#39frivolous&#39 claims

A Devon IFA claims the Financial Ombudsman Service uses unfair criteria to decide whether a complaint against an IFA is frivolous or vexatious.

Philip G Milton & Co managing director Philip Milton has been the subject of three complaints to the FOS, which have either been withdrawn or rejected because there was no case to answer. But he has still had to pay a fee of £360 for each case.

One case was dismissed because the complainant had miscalculated the amount of money to which he thought he was entitled. A second case was withdrawn by the complainant when he accepted the claim was insignificant. The third was withdrawn when the FOS realised that the value of the claim was around £35.

Milton asked for the fees to be waived but says FOS staff told him that while the cases may have been found to be frivolous or vexatious, they did not appear so when they were filed, so the fee remains payable.

He says: “The FOS is effectively saying it accepts the case was frivolous but it did not know that at the beginning so it cannot let me off the fee. If a monitoring officer allocates a case to a case officer, it is adjudged to be not frivolous or vexatious.”

But the FOS says many cases that seem frivolous or vexatious would never have come before it if firms were better at dealing with clients&#39 complaints. Spokeswoman Alison Hoyland says: “Firms are often bad at explaining to consumers what has gone wrong. Had they been better at that, the consumer might not have complained.”


Questions on strength and trust

The Abacus consultancy director David Ferguson questioned the stated cost of smoothing, which Pru chief executive Mark Wood admitted is around a 0.75 per cent annual management charge. Ferguson queried where the fund&#39s capital for new investment and offers such as extra allocations came from. He said, with returns under pressure, costs such as this […]

Obesity will not weigh on all premiums

Protection IFAs believe rapidly rising obesity in the UK will affect prices for obese people on all health insurance policies that involve underwriting but is unlikely to push up costs for everyone in the near future. The comments follow reinsurer Swiss Re&#39s call for the life insurance industry to tackle the issues associated with increases […]

Happy returns

With the advent of mortgage regulation, general insurance regulation and depolarisation, even the most dedicated compliance officer could probably be excused for allowing the FSA&#39s proposal for electronic reporting to slip down their priority list in recent months. This may be understandable but it may yet turn out to be a painful oversight if plans […]

Exchange adds quotes to cover special risks

The Exchange is adding a special risks section to portal ExWeb to offer intermediaries protection business quotes. The special risks centre will provide intermediaries with guidance on what constitutes a special risk and help them get the best rate for clients through a special underwriting process. The Exchange&#39s research shows that 62 per cent of […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment