View more on these topics

Ian McKenna: Why UK robos look more valuable than US peers

Ian McKennaWith Asia’s emerging middle class providing huge growth opportunities, firms based in countries part of the ‘global sandbox’ appear very attractive

The recent announcement that Goldman Sachs has become a strategic investor in Nutmeg and that the funds will be used to facilitate the digital wealth manager’s international expansion has fascinating connotations.

The £45m deal also suggests a significant premium is being paid when compared with leading US robo-advisers. Does this represent a regulatory premium as a consequence of the FCA’s role in establishing a global framework for personal finance regulation?

Nutmeg sells stake to Goldman Sachs in £45m funding round

A recent report by Standard Chartered predicts that China will overtake the US in 2020 as the world’s number-one economy and that India will surpass the US by 2030. This means the big prizes in the future of advice may be as likely to be found in the East as the West.

The UK advice community could be ideally placed to export its expertise, as an increasing number of regulators around the world collaborate on practice and thinking.

Indeed, the FCA deserves significant credit for playing an active role in the formation of the Global Financial Innovation Network – or the global sandbox – bringing together 12 regulators and related organisations from around the world, including the Middle East and Asia, but not the US.

An investment on this scale is a huge endorsement of Nutmeg’s strategy and is evidence that, while it may currently be racking up some relatively hefty losses, these should be considered in a far wider context.

Contrary to what some people in the traditional advice market might like to think, the business is well-placed for the future.

It is also notable that, in addition to Goldman Sachs, Hong Kong-based advice firm Convoy, already an existing investor, has participated further in this capital raising round.

New Jersey-based Wealth Consulting Partners’ Gavin Spitzner, one of the best US advice tech analysts I know, quickly identified that the injection of £45m implies a valuation of £247m on assets of £1.5bn, producing revenue of around £7-8m.

Compared with Wealthfront’s $11bn assets under management and $23-35m revenue, which is generally seen as having a valuation estimate of $500-600m, and Betterment’s $15bn AUM, $40-50m revenue and an estimated $800-900m valuation, the numbers suggest Nutmeg has a value double that of the US players per pound/dollar AUM.

Can Nutmeg conquer advice?

While it can be argued the above have done a great deal to deliver innovative automated solutions, they still only operate in the US.

America is a huge market and it is understandable that US companies would want to focus on domestic opportunities.

However, as a rapidly emerging middle class in Asia provides huge growth opportunities, firms based in countries that are part of the GFIN seem very attractive.

The benefits of such transparency cut both ways. In recent months, firms like Singapore-headquartered Bambu, Toronto-based Wealth Simple and South Africa’s CybiWealth have all set up UK operations.

If the GFIN now opens up the potential for global passport-style arrangements in advice, where firms regulated in one jurisdiction could easily and cost-effectively extend their operations into other member states, this might enable businesses to access vastly larger markets, and reuse skills and technology on a wider scale.

The extent of regulatory innovation and collaboration is far greater in GFIN countries than it is in America or, for that matter, Europe.

Indeed, there are serious questions over the ability of the European Union to bring forward financial regulation at the speed necessary to be a winner in the digital economy.

Even as an ardent remainer, I have to acknowledge the severe constraints that France, especially, puts on all things digital in the EU.

The recent €50m (£44m) fine imposed on Google by the French data protection watchdog for activities relating to the first day GDPR came into force sends a very negative message to anyone trying to innovate in the EU.

Ian McKenna: How 2018 transformed the advice market

That advice firms can take new ideas to the regulator and work with it is a huge benefit of the UK fintech sector.

It is in stark contrast to the ways previous regulators approached innovation and, over the coming months, we can expect to see an increasing number of new services come to market that have been incubated in this way. That this approach is now beginning to be embraced internationally is a very positive step in uncertain times.

As for Nutmeg, while it must be congratulated on its success in raising funds, it would be wonderful if it could be as groundbreaking in its charging structure and investments as it appears to be in its expansion plans. Then it might really be on
to something.

Ian McKenna is director of the Finance & Technology Research Centre



‘Dog funds’ at record high

Investors have more money in under-performing funds than ever before, according to Tilney’s latest list of “dog funds”. The latest edition of the bi-annual list of under-performing funds features the highest number of dogs in its history. The 111 funds featured hold a combined £54.6bn in assets – the highest number recorded since the list […]


Lloyds plans 700-strong adviser recruitment drive

Lloyds will reportedly look to hire 700 financial advisers as part of its wealth and investment tie-up with Schroders. The Financial Times reports the bank’s internal documents show an initial 300 advisers will come on board for the joint venture later this year, with more set to join in due course. There are also plans […]


Which firms are winning the race on wealth management?

Traditional wealth managers have proved themselves to be scalable and profitable businesses despite the hype caused by robo-advice models, analysts say. Wealth managers have also been shown to be more robust than pure asset managers amid mounting pressure on fund performance and fees. While Hargreaves Lansdown and St James’s Place continue to make the headlines […]

The investment clock

While Trump blazes blond in the political foreground, it’s easy to overlook the economic background to the new political dimension of 2017. Political risk will be a feature of the year: the unpredictable and untested Trump administration has already created uncertainty, which is unlikely to diminish, especially if protectionist rhetoric starts to outweigh promises of […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm