View more on these topics

Ian McKenna: Are UK providers falling behind in the tech race?


Until recently it was reasonable to assume the RDR would be the most substantial change in the financial advice arena that we would see in our lifetimes. 

Two months ago the Chancellor changed that. 

We are nearing the dawn of a retirement revolution that will transform our industry like nothing before. That the RDR is already in place puts advisers in a strong position to meet these new challenges.

One of the significant side-effects of the RDR was that it diverted most financial organisations’ attention away from the digital revolution that was taking place at the same time in the wider world. A key lesson to learn from the RDR must be the importance of not becoming similarly side-tracked while reinventing retirement products.

In fact, pension providers can only effectively reinvent themselves in the brave new world by putting digital at the heart of their new propositions. I am already regularly seeing evidence that major players are going down the wrong track.

Since the Budget we have seen three of the most significant deals in the last two decades take place with virtually no mainstream industry reaction. This does not bode well. One of the key components needed to build a next generation, consumer-facing proposition must be a holistic service to give customers a single view of all their assets.

For the last two years On Trees had been building such capability and its acquisition by shows the aggregator is looking to broaden and deepen its financial relationships with consumers.

To my knowledge no UK life office or platform has a similar current capability. Given how effective has been in building strong relationships with consumers in the personal lines market, is it wise for our industry to give them a couple of years’ head start when it comes to aggregation?

Money Hub is now emerging as a significant play in this sector. That it has been acquired by South African insurer Momentum indicates great insight by the acquirer but also throws down a major challenge to the established UK pension provider community. Money Hub has a compelling technology proposition for advisers and pension providers alike. Founder Toby Hughes tells me that the acquisition will give the business the resources to accelerate its plans to deliver leading-edge technology to facilitate closer engagement with customers through effective use of technology.

While I will take a more detailed look at Money Hub shortly, to achieve its full potential it will be important for Momentum to convince potential customers that it is not a threat to established UK providers. Companies rarely buy key technology from organisations who may be future competitors.

The acquisition by Aon of Lorica and its exceptional Bigblue technology should not be underestimated. This is another case of a key technology asset being quickly taken off the table by a very smart acquirer.

While historic assets may generate three times the profit achieved from new business and the terms imposed 20 years ago may have been reasonable then, after paying such charges for 20 years, isn’t there a case for rewarding such customers for their loyalty with a better deal?

Any business model which relies upon locking such customers in to obsolete charging structures is well and truly broken. I am frequently hearing established providers ask how they defend their current assets. That the question is even couched in such terms identifies these organisations are not being radical enough in their thinking.

To succeed in the brave new world, pension providers are going to need a new and entirely customer-centric operating model. In delivering this they need to walk the walk, not just talk the talk. This will require a fundamental change in the underlying culture of such organisations.

Successful long-term savings businesses in the 21st-century will make delivering good value to customers their most important goal, any who fail to do so will struggle to survive. Customer propositions need to evolve so that the companies consumers deal with are ones they can genuinely trust to protect their best interests.

Such services can only be achieved through deploying an outstanding customer focused digital proposition. That the leaders in this area are being so quickly snapped up should be a concern for established players. Any not already acting in this area must be at significant risk of not making the transition to the new world. They need to find the right partners quickly to deliver such change.

Ian McKenna is director of the Finance & Technology Research Centre



Treasury targets foreign exchange clampdown

Chancellor George Osborne is set to announce tougher regulations of foreign exchange dealing, according to the FT. Osborne is expected to reveal new measures to tackle the manipulation of forex benchmarks in his Mansion House speech on 12 June. The FT says one option under consideration would see forex benchmarks brought into the scope of […]


FOS accused of ignoring adviser evidence in rulings

The Financial Ombudsman Service is failing to take adviser evidence into account in around a third of cases, according to Apfa research. Responding to a survey carried out by the trade body, 34 per cent of advisers that have had a complaint referred to the FOS said the ruling did not take their evidence into […]

Can UK companies satisfy global appetites?

By Mark Martin, Manager of Neptune UK Mid Cap Fund

Rapid economic and income growth is leading to a dramatic shift in diet towards protein products right around the globe. UK companies such as Genus, the world’s largest livestock breeder, are benefiting from this increasing demand. Mark Martin, manager of the Neptune UK Mid Cap Fund, discusses this investment theme.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. good day for golf 2nd June 2014 at 9:50 am

    Interactive Brokers platform is the best out there for holding funds and managing BUT its promoted as a trading platform – however it does not mean to say you can’t hold shares/etf’s and IT’s indefinitely on the account.
    The platform does not use 3rd party brokers the trades go straight through their systems.
    Charges $2.50 on fx NOT 1.7% – 2% as some unnamed major providers do in the UK.

    Big problem as I see it taking 2 not unusual cases as an example.
    I put a lump sum in IB and charged the client a small DM fee.
    I got him to do a regular saving into an investment account.
    When he needed funds he found (as previously explained to him) he can not have them from the regular savings so he closed the no penalty IB account and took all the cash. 5 years later he still has the regular savings account- so the one with all the commission and charges and lock ins is effectively rewarded.
    Second case I set up an IB account for a prospect who had had enough of regular savings and had already cashed in so we put the funds with IB and he said with the intention of topping up a year later. The funds were doing well and a year later I emailed him and he said he could not top up since he was saving the money monthly with a new provider and advisor. It turns out on investigation he had taken out a new $2000 a month 20 year plan!

    Both the above are high earners.

    In the comfy offices and in the intellectual debate areas it all seems right to disclose and break down everything but in the real world of dealing with clients its a very different ball game.

  2. Agreed. Its not only product providers who should consider access to aggregation technology. For advisory firms looking to differentiate, aggregation tech can empower them to become the service provider and not just an intermediary. This type of technology enables them to deliver holistic financial reporting even though they do not manage all the assets the clients want to see in one place.

    Sammedia’s moneyinfo technology supports Lorica’s Big Blue portal and allowed them to redefine the role of product providers to product administrators whilst themselves becoming the true service provider in the client’s eyes.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm