View more on these topics

Iain Anderson: The secret to successful pensions policymaking

iain-anderson.Pensions minister Guy Opperman has been meticulously planning for the introduction of a Pensions Bill in this year’s Queen’s Speech. He has consulted extensively, laying out plans for collective defined contribution schemes, defined benefit reform and consolidation, as well as the pensions dashboard. At a time of little domestic policymaking, the pensions industry appears to have a major package of reform on the horizon. The only problem is, when are we going to have a Queen’s Speech?

It has already been almost two years since the Queen last attended the state opening of parliament. It seems the delay in the Brexit timetable means we will need to wait until at least the autumn for that gold carriage to roll in to Westminster again. Then there is the matter of what form the legislation will take when it arrives.

The government now has a working majority of just three. Defeats on key votes have become commonplace and the whips have rarely appeared to have less sway over a restless party.

In this climate, the temptation will be to bring forward legislative proposals as uncontentious as possible. So will the Pensions Bill still be the bold and comprehensive package we’d been led to expect? Pensions policymaking has always been at its best when developed on the basis of cross-party consensus.

One only needs to look at the success of auto-enrolment for evidence. It was the result of long preparation and legislation passed by successive governments, with a view to building a policy that would last for the long term.

The pension freedoms took a rather different tack. Announced without warning, these reforms marked a departure from the consensus-building approach we had come to expect from pensions policymaking. 

Meanwhile, the Women Against State Pension Inequality campaign serves as a high-profile example of the disagreements that characterise the main parties’ approaches to rises in the state pension age.

The good news is that much of the bill planned by Opperman appears to bring us back to a more collegiate approach. He regularly mentions in his speeches the constructive relationship he enjoys with his Labour opposite, Jack Dromey.

The two have been united in their public support for the introduction of CDC pensions.

Similarly, the pensions dashboard enjoys the support of Labour and others in opposition.

When rumours surfaced last summer that the then work and pensions secretary Esther McVey may have been rethinking it, Dromey was quick to remind the government it remains a project that enjoys widespread cross-party – and cross-industry – support.

And on reforms to strengthen the powers of The Pensions Regulator in respect of DB schemes, as well as wider measures to protect DB savers, Labour is broadly supportive of the government’s reform agenda.

The government should feel confident in pressing ahead with its planned Pensions Bill, knowing that, even at a time when consensus across (and within) parties is in short supply, the pensions reform agenda can be a model of collegiate policymaking that can overcome this most fractured parliament.

Iain Anderson is executive chairman at Cicero


Lloyds profits fall flat as it takes a hit for Standard Aberdeen dispute

Lloyds Banking Group profits have fallen below market expectations, as the bank took a hit of some £339m for cutting its contract short with Standard Life Aberdeen, a quarterly update today shows. Earlier this year, SLA won a dispute with Lloyds over a £109bn investment mandate deal, from which the bank withdrew abruptly last year. […]

Baillie Gifford transfers £1.3bn to Hargreaves Lansdown

Baillie Gifford is set to transfer its investment trust savings scheme to Hargreaves Lansdown. The scheme, which includes its Isa, Share Plan and Children’s Savings Plan, is being moved as Baillie Gifford says the long-term interests of the plan holders will be “best serviced” by a transfer of investments to the the direct-to-consumer platform. More […]


Martin Bamford: Advisers can’t keep outsiders on the outside

I often ponder to what extent we overcomplicate things as financial planners. A few years ago, I was pulled up sharply by a prospective client, midway through a pitch for our estate planning service. “But I don’t have an estate,” they interjected. That service was swiftly renamed “inheritance tax planning”, with the desire to do […]


Quilter Cheviot poaches from Brooks Macdonald and Charles Stanley for investment management team

Discretionary fund manager Quilter Cheviot has hired a further four investment managers across its regional offices. The DFM has looked to rivals in its market for the hires, as Richard Wayne-Wynne joins from Brooks Macdonald in London, and Daniel Schieber joins from Charles Stanley in Salisbury. Quilter Cheviot has also hired WH Ireland’s former head […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm