View more on these topics

Huge contrasts in way life firms back up WP

Life offices publishing results under the realistic reporting regime are revealing huge differences in the way they back up their with-profits business, according to research by consultant Ernst & Young.

The way that Friends Provident&#39s business model is structured means it has no realistic free assets but relies on risk capital margin and external assets to achieve a 9 per cent solvency cushion on its with-profits book, according to E&Y&#39s UK life insurance companies capital and solvency review of 2003.

Legal & General has only 1 per cent realistic free assets but an overall solvency cushion of 25 per cent, which is higher than all the other major life offices but backed by risk capital margin and external assets not ringfenced within the with-profits fund. E&Y says this is because L&G uses shareholder capital rather than free assets to back its with-profits business.

The average realistic free assets across with-profits prov-iders surveyed in E&Y&#39s report stood at 5.9 per cent of with-profits liabilities. Wesleyan Assurance operates its with-profits business on realistic free assets of 26 per cent.

The figures – covering the 18 with-profits providers which produced realistic accounts relating to 2003 – show total with-profits assets of £258bn and realistic free assets of £14bn after meeting a risk capital margin of £8bn.

E&Y head of life actuarial practice Tim Roff says: “In highlighting their realistic position, some life offices have included additional capital in the shareholder fund and external assets which are not formally allocated to the with-profits fund but which, in extreme con-ditions, could provide fur-ther support to the withprofits business.

“When including these assets in the realistic results, it should be understood that there are usually no restrictions on taking these assets out of the company.”

Friends Provident director (corporate development) Rocco Sepe says: “Our demutualisation agreement with the FSA means equity that we raised to back the fund is protected for the benefit of policyholders.”

Legal & General spokesman John Morgan says: “L&G has said that it remains its firm intention to operate the with-profits part of its long-term fund without the need for external capital support. We are no different from any other insurer as all assets of L&G Assurance Society are there to meet its liabilities.”

•Comment, p30

Thirteen life offices got waivers relaxing valuation regulations for their with-profits funds – called Tiner waivers – when filing accounts under the FSA&#39s new realistic reporting regime.

The FSA introduced Tiner waivers in 2003 as markets were in freefall because it believed statutory solvency rules for with-profits funds did not show sufficient flexibility to deal with sudden shocks in equity prices.

The waivers enabled life offices to weather market troughs without having to offload equities at the bottom of the market.

Of the 13 companies that had waivers at the end of last year, only L&G and Friends Provident chose not to use them.

The waivers relate to the relaxing of five different FSA rules relating to the use of gross premiums, conditions for equity yields, reinvestment rules, interpretation of when profits can be used and the nature of assets. Only Norwich Union&#39s CGNU Life and CU Life funds obtained waivers on all five rules.

Life offices expect the need for waivers to disappear under the new realistic reporting regime. The existing waivers were last awarded in June 2003 and will remain valid until December 2004, when new waivers will need to be sought.

E&Y head of life actuarial practice Tim Roff says: “Most companies with Tiner waivers were permitted to use the waivers to reduce their regulatory liabilities.”

Norwich Union head of with-profits management David Riddington says: “Tiner waivers were a temporary measure as we move towards the new realistic reporting regime. Some companies that did not apply for waivers would not have done so because they were not geared up to do the sort of arithmetic needed to get a waiver in the first place.”


Mid-year bonus cuts by Widows

Scottish Widows has cut bonus rates for with-profits policies in its mid-year review. Bonus rates fall by 0.5 per cent for its flexible investment bonds, Jersey-based with-profits bonds and investments in the flexible options bond income fund made in 2002. The rate for investments in the flexible options bond income fund made in the first […]

Conversion charge fear on property vehicles

The Consumers&#39 Association is considering tailoring its new code of ethics to fit IFAs. Last week, the CA started consulting with the industry on its code which it hopes will improve corporate governance and business ethics by moving the industry away from commission towards more performance-related bonuses. The code is aimed at product providers but […]

Offshore sales get bond boost

Offshore investment business surged by 20 per cent to £199m in annual premium equivalent in the first quarter of this year from £165m for the same period last year. Single-premium business saw the biggest increase, up by 30 per cent to £1.4bn from £1.07bn, according to the Association of International Life Offices. Total new regular-premium […]

2.4m homeowners potentially liable to IHT says Halifax

The number of homes in the UK valued at more than the inheritance tax threshold increased by more than 500,000 in the first half of 2004 according to Halifax financial services. As a result, 2.4m homeowners are potentially liable to IHT. The 12 per cent increase in house prices in the first half of the […]

The fifteen-year itch

By Neil Jones Technical support manager with Canada Life’s ican Technical Services Team. Canada Life offers a range of wealth management solutions, including retirement income planning, estate planning and investment solutions from a choice of jurisdictions, including the UK, Isle of Man and Republic of Ireland. The treatment of non-UK domiciles that are resident in […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm