View more on these topics

HMRC wins £26m film partnership legal battle


HM Revenue & Customs has won a tax avoidance case against two film partnership schemes worth £26m of taxpayer money.

The Court of Appeal has dismissed appeals from Proteus Film Partnership and Samarkand Film Partnership, which acquired interests in films such as The Queen and the Roman Polanski remake of Oliver Twist.

The court has upheld a previous judgement that the schemes were not trading and no tax relief was due.

The investments were sold to high-net-worth individuals, many of whom were resident but not domiciled in the UK. The schemes worked by granting investors upfront repayments on tax relief and avoiding tax on income generated.

HMRC says the ruling could impact on other cases worth a total of £286m.

HMRC director general of customer compliance Jennie Granger says: “This scheme deliberately sought to exploit the tax reliefs put in place to help boost the British film industry, but it didn’t pay off.

“We’re delighted with the win which means we’ve protected £26m of taxpayers’ money.”


Andrew Tyrie Tory conf 2013.jpg

HMRC urged to soften stance on film partnership schemes

The chair of the influential Treasury select committee has criticised HM Revenue and Customs for its handling of legal disputes against film partnership tax avoidance schemes, saying they have led to “very severe” financial distress for some investors. In a letter to HMRC, select committee chair Andrew Tyrie says he was made aware that the […]

HMRC loses Supreme Court appeal on film partnership press briefing

Film partnership firm Ingenious has won a Supreme Court appeal against HM Revenue and Customs which ruled HMRC unlawfully disclosed confidential information in an “off the record” press briefing. The briefing took place in June 2012 and was between then-permanent secretary of HMRC David Hartnett and two journalists. Ingenious says HMRC justified the briefing because it wanted […]


Coutts sued over film partnerships advice

Coutts, the private banking and wealth management arm of Royal Bank of Scotland, could be on the hook for hundreds of thousands of pounds in redress following client claims they were given bad advice to invest in film schemes. According to the Times, 220 clients have filed a lawsuit against Coutts, UBS and other advisers […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. You have to be very careful who you kick on the way up, lest they kick you when you are on the way down, even if you are HMRC

Leave a comment