View more on these topics

HMRC loses Supreme Court appeal on film partnership press briefing


Film partnership firm Ingenious has won a Supreme Court appeal against HM Revenue and Customs which ruled HMRC unlawfully disclosed confidential information in an “off the record” press briefing.

The briefing took place in June 2012 and was between then-permanent secretary of HMRC David Hartnett and two journalists.

Ingenious says HMRC justified the briefing because it wanted to foster good relationships with the press to publicise its views on elaborate tax avoidance schemes.

An Ingenious spokesman says the appeal was not brought with the intention of restricting HMRC’s ability to collect taxes or prevent the press from investigating public interest stories.

The spokesman says: “Consistent with HMRC’s own guidelines, this was simply about upholding the basic legal principle that HMRC owes a duty of confidentiality to each and every taxpayer and their affairs should not form the subject of ‘off the record’ background briefings to the media.”

According to Ingenious, the information disclosed was only “tangentially” related to the current case before the First Tier Tax Tribunal and the film production schemes that Ingenious operated. It says the briefing took place before Ingenious decided to bring the legal proceedings at the tribunal.

In a statement, Ingenious explains the unanimous Supreme Court decision said HMRC officials supplying confidential information about individuals to the media on a non-attributable basis is – or should be – a matter of serious concern.

The statement adds: “The five judges of the Supreme Court unanimously decided that the arguments put forward by HMRC could not possibly justify a senior official, or any other official of HMRC, discussing the affairs of individual tax payers with journalists.  Neither did the judges accept HMRC’s defence that because Hartnett did not expect his comments to be reported that he was justified in making them.”

HMRC says it is “disappointed” with the decision.

A spokesman says: “HMRC defended this case because it considered that the disclosure made by Mr Hartnett was lawful. However, the Supreme Court has decided otherwise and we will examine the judgment in detail.”

He adds: “It is important to clarify that this judgment has no bearing on the three Ingenious film partnerships considered by the first tier tribunal, where HMRC was successful. This protected around £400m in revenues for the Exchequer.”

Both Ingenious and HMRC are thought to be considering appealing the tribunal decision which, at the time it was released, both sides claimed to have won.



Ingenious hits back at ‘false’ HMRC claims in film partnership case

Film partnership firm Ingenious has hit back at HMRC for “deliberately confusing” the scheme with proven tax avoidance schemes. Ingenious chief executive Neil Forster has accused HMRC of making assertions that are “factually wrong” and for incorrectly linking it to tax avoidance scheme Icebreaker. The comments come after both HM Revenue and Customs and Ingenious film partnerships […]


Coutts sued over film partnerships advice

Coutts, the private banking and wealth management arm of Royal Bank of Scotland, could be on the hook for hundreds of thousands of pounds in redress following client claims they were given bad advice to invest in film schemes. According to the Times, 220 clients have filed a lawsuit against Coutts, UBS and other advisers […]

Legal wrangling set to continue over HMRC film partnership case

Investors in a film scheme that is part of a long-running tax avoidance battle now face large bills for interest and legal fees as well as £434m in unpaid tax. Both HM Revenue and Customs and Ingenious film partnerships have claimed to have “won” the First Tier tax tribunal decision released yesterday. The hearing involved […]

Healthcare regulation amalgamation predicted for Gulf states

While Dubai is leading the way in terms of legislating for expat healthcare in the Gulf, Qatar, Abu Dhabi and others are watching and learning – that’s according to Jelf International’s director of international services, Doug Rice. He believes the pace of change in the Gulf states will continue and that some level of unified healthcare system will be introduced across the region.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm