View more on these topics

HMRC grilled by MPs on ‘completely unacceptable’ performance


HM Revenue & Customs officials have been told by MPs that their staff’s call handling remains “completely unacceptable”.

Earlier this week, a report from the Public Accounts Committee said the tax office was “worse than abysmal” on customer service.

The report was published following an oral evidence session in which HMRC chief executive Lin Homer told MPs that roughly half of calls to HMRC were being answered between April and July.

Speaking to the Treasury Committee today, Homer said that call answering rates had climbed from roughly 50 per cent to 76 per cent.

However, committee member Mark Garnier stressed that such performance remains intolerable.

He said: “Anybody would agree that 24 per cent of calls not being answered is completely unacceptable. If that was a commercial service it would go bust.”

Homer said HMRC has changed staffing arrangements to bolster numbers outside of normal working hours and is installing new phone systems to allow calls to be answered at any HMRC call centre in the UK.

She said: “We’re very apologetic for that period of poor service.”

However, when pressed by Garnier on what level of calls being answered would provide satisfaction to HMRC, Homer noted that roughly one in four calls to HMRC are on routine issues, and that the tax office was hoping to allow people to access those services online.

She said: “What good would look like is giving people more choice about how they can contact us.”

Committee chair Andrew Tyrie also questioned the role of morale in the performance of HMRC, noting that a December 2014 survey of civil servants found that just 28 per cent of staff approved of the tax office’s senior management and their ability to handle change.

The score ranked HMRC at the bottom of all government departments taking part, although Homer played down its impact on the effectiveness of the department.

Despite Tyrie describing the viewpoint as “counterintuitive”, Homer argued HMRC staff are “uniquely productive and uniquely disengaged”.

She said: “There is definitely something in the HMRC psyche that means they are not as engaged with the public service as other government departments.

“But there is no evidence that they are less productive or less committed to the jobs that they do.”

Tyrie also called on HMRC to review how it publishes figures on the tax gap, arguing the figures are misunderstood by the public as “a synonym for nasty tax evaders”.

Tyrie said: “They [the public] don’t know that error is in the tax gap.

“I think it is important that we get some better information out there, and possibly consider using another number, that can be used and better understood by the public for what they think they’re seeing, which is an amount that people are doing their best to avoid paying.”

HMRC tax assurance commissioner Edward Troup admitted that HMRC could to a better job to publicise “what the tax gap is and what it is not”.



HMRC withholds data on pension freedoms fines

HMRC is refusing to say how many people have broken new pensions reporting rules or how much it has collected in fines. A Freedom of Information request lodged with the tax office – and seen by Money Marketing – was blocked because the information “could be used by opportunistic individuals to undermine HMRC’s processes in […]


HMRC still failing taxpayers, say MPs

HM Revenue & Customs is failing UK taxpayers through poor customer service and “inadequate” action on tax evasion, say MPs. In a damning report published today, the Public Accounts Committee describes HMRC’s customer service as “worse than abysmal” and a genuine threat to tax collection. In March 2013, the committee said HMRC had an “abysmal […]

FCA logo new 3 620x430

FCA and HMRC to gain new powers under ‘snoopers’ charter’

New powers to be unveiled this week will see the FCA and HM Revenue and Customs gain access to the public’s internet search history and social media activity. The Telegraph reports technology firms will have to keep records of the websites and app people have used and details of when they accessed them for 12 […]

HMRC delays pension protection applications

Pension savers who want to be apply for transitional protection as the lifetime allowance on pensions drops to £1m will have to wait for at least seven months, HMRC has confirmed. A HMRC newsletter, published yesterday, says it will “not be possible” for members to apply for fixed or individual protection until after April 2016. […]

Creating opportunity out of change

By Denise Wond, marketing manager The buy-to-let market has recently been the subject of a raft of tax changes, all of which make it a less profitable and less appealing proposition for investors. In response, we’ve seen a dip in demand for BTL mortgages and that’s bad news for many advisers who will now be looking […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 4 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Pure flim flam.

    If you are going to give someone a rollicking do so with a loaded gun.

    MPs don’t even have blanks. What are they going to do? Sack HMRC personnel? They are already severely understaffed. Anyone who is any good just stays long enough to learn the ropes and then goes to the private sector to forge a decent career.

    Somas usual MPs blow hot air.

  2. Have a read of her CV on Wikepedia. Critised when in local government for performance as returning officer, left to join civil service, oversaw shambles in Border Agency, moved to dept of transport and again critised for performance, then to HMRC and what happens? Surprise Surprise. Who appoints these people to important jobs? Don’t they bother to check on their past record?

  3. @ Graham,
    All these jobs are sorted out well in advance and only the chosen few get a look in.
    This has never changed.

  4. A friend of mine does his own SA tax returns and he has a 1st in maths so it’s no great challenge for him to work out what his bill should be. About a third of what HMRC tells him he has to pay are correct. About a third are higher than they should be so he challenges them and gets them corrected. About a third are lower than they should be so he says nothing and underpays. Draw your own conclusions.

Leave a comment