View more on these topics

Hector Sants urges Govt to strip FCA fining powers

Hector-Sants-smiles-at-the-podium-in-2011 700.jpg

A review of Britain’s banking industry by former FSA chief executive Sir Hector Sants has called for the regulator to be stripped of its power to set penalties and redress for misconduct.

The recommendation is one of 23 made by Sants, who headed up the financial watchdog from 2007 to 2012, in a report on UK banking competitiveness published by the British Bankers Association. Sants now works for consultants Oliver Wyman.

The report says the Government should consider establishing “a new independent body responsible for penalty and redress decision-making” outside the FCA.

Sants also suggests policymakers examine the case for increasing operational separation of the FCA’s supervision and enforcement divisions.

The report says: “The current remit of regulators covers supervision, penalty and redress.

“This can distort incentives and create the potential for regulatory moral hazard and political influence.

“Many contributors believed that an independent body responsible for redress would result in better outcomes, not only for banks but also for their customers in ensuring rigorous alignment alignment of redress amounts with the cost of the misdeed.”

The report also warns the existing rules “place a disproportionately large burden on smaller banks that are less able to absorb the cost of the increasing complexity of the regulatory environment”.

The recommendations comes after a series of huge fines issued by the regulator to major banks in recent years, primarily in relation to Libor fixing and payment protection insurance misselling.

Lloyds Banking Group was clobbered with a £117m penalty for failing to handle PPI complaints fairly in June, while Barclays, Deutsche Bank and Clydesdale Bank have also been hit with huge fines in 2015.



HMRC withholds data on pension freedoms fines

HMRC is refusing to say how many people have broken new pensions reporting rules or how much it has collected in fines. A Freedom of Information request lodged with the tax office – and seen by Money Marketing – was blocked because the information “could be used by opportunistic individuals to undermine HMRC’s processes in […]


Treasury holds industry talks over cash for annuities reform

Providers are in talks with the Treasury over how to advance plans for a secondary annuities market. The reforms, which will allow people to cash in their annuity, were due to be implemented in 2016. However, in the July Budget the deadline was pushed back to 2017 amid concerns about the impact of rushing the reforms onto […]


Malcolm McLean: Get ready for contracting-out fallout

Bringing in big changes to pensions is often not quite as easy as it first seems. Rarely is it possible to make a complete break with the past in setting the direction for the future, and there are usually complicated transitional stages to get through before the old is fully replaced by the new. That […]

FCA interior logo 620x430

FCA raises non-advised drawdown concerns

The FCA says it will consider “stepping in to break the link” between providers and retirement decisions if there is evidence consumers are not shopping around for drawdown products. Speaking at the Westminster Employment Forum in London last week, FCA director of competition Mary Starks said: “We’re very conscious that if we see a significant […]

UK policy: Kate Moss and short-termism

“Nothing tastes as good as skinny feels,” said supermodel Kate Moss, who is not often credited for her insights into policy making. Perhaps she should be. In politics, as in matters of diet, the course of action that is the best over the long term is often not the most desirable course of action in the short term. Add the instant gratification of the democratic electoral cycle and, instead of good policy making, you sometimes get the equivalent to a midnight binge in front of the fridge.

Read more

Important information

Investment risks

The value of an investment and any income from it can fall as well as rise and you may not get back the amount originally invested. Forecasts and past performance are not a guide to future performance. Some information and statistical data herein has been obtained from sources we believe to be reliable but in no way are warranted by us as to their accuracy or completeness. These are Neptune’s views and as such this document is deemed to be impartial research. We do not undertake to advise you of any change to our views.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 12 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. The report says the Government should consider establishing “a new independent body responsible for penalty and redress decision-making” outside the FCA, so more city fattest can join the gravy train we have to fund!!

  2. How odd that he never thought of this when he was at the regulator.

    Can he really be so naive / arrogant / dumb (delete as you feel appropriate) to believe that there is anyone in the land who won’t see this for the naked self-interest that it so clearly is?

  3. No can’t have your old job back…. go away!

  4. Would he be angling for another highly paid unaccountable job? Personally I think the fines should be imposed by FSCS as ultimately it’s their decision that stands when providing compensation to consumers. It might even help bring down the levy.

  5. No he just paying lip service to his masters at the treasury. Someone said to me when he was asked to stay on at the FSA He knew where the skeletons were. Despite what we all think of him he plays the power game well and appears to be winning.

  6. His arrogance and hypocrisy seem to have no limits!

  7. Conflict of interest glaringly bright. If that’s representative of the overall report, it’s been a waste of money and effort. However, you’d expect the Bankers Assoc to give it a try so can’t blame them for that.

    Just hope everyone’s alert in not granting their wish.

  8. This from the man who said we should “Be afraid – be very afraid” of him when he was the regulator. Gamekeeper turned poacher. Hilarious!!!

  9. Trevor Harrington 13th November 2015 at 10:04 am

    Hector’s house ?

  10. Can I make a suggestion; reading between the lines is this open statement or list of recommendations, is a veiled attempt to win back favour within the banking community ?

    We have evidence that the RDR completely killed banking advice (which IMHO, Hectors plan was for it to increase banking advice and market share) Also he failed to contain (be able to hide) the extent of disasters that banks were having, which led to the huge fines, for which he had no control over any more, Barclays must have been giving him a real hard time that he had to go on sick leave, the banking community from top to bottom must hate him more than we do !

    Now he is bouncing around the fringes in exile in crappy consulting roles; his Elba if you will !

  11. Does this rather strange and surprising proposal from Mr Sants relate solely to the FCA’s powers over the banks or would it apply to its powers over all FCA-regulated entities? It has to be the latter, otherwise the playing field would be skewed even further than it already is.

    I cannot help but think that a better approach, instead of removing and reallocating to a separate body (at yet more cost) certain of the FCA’s powers, would be to give the TSC the powers it clearly needs to supervise and regulate the activities of the FCA on a wide range of issues, with real powers of enforcement and redress and/or fines for failures to comply. One thing of which the FCA should be stripped is its licence to award huge pay-offs for employees forced to resign as a result of acknowledged failures in the discharge of their responsibilities.

    The basis of such powers should be the Statutory Code of Practice for Regulators ( Therein lies the framework of how the FCA (like all other regulatory bodies) is supposed to conduct itself and treat those it regulates. For example:-

    “Regulators should avoid imposing unnecessary regulatory burdens through their regulatory activities and should assess whether similar social, environmental and economic outcomes could be achieved by less burdensome means. Regulators should choose proportionate approaches to those they regulate, based on relevant factors including, for example, business size and capacity.”

    Why is no one seeking to address the FCA’s unilateral opt out from the Code?

  12. Get someone in who has steel balls and the will to unravel the complete mess that Victor and his cronies have created over the last 10 years. There are sooooo many quality people now not working in FS tgat would willing come back and in turn bring back hundreds of thousands of clients that have been lost …….. and before any smart comments about their lack of knowledge is dealt out and the industry is a better place without these advisors start I would ask you to take a few deep breaths and consider where we were before RDR and where we are now. Oh, and try to think of the clients that now don’t receive any advice at all …. and not yourselves!

Leave a comment