View more on these topics

Great name, great style from Skandia

Skandia Investment Management

UK Best Ideas Fund

Type: Multi-manager Oeic

Aim: Income and growth by investing globally in equities using a manager of managers approach

Minimum investment: Lump sum £1,000, monthly £50

Investment split: 100% in UK equities

Isa link: Yes

Pep transfers: Yes

Charges: Initial 5%, annual 1.5%

Commission: Initial 3.5%, renewal 0.5%

Tel: 020 7220 3531

Skandia Investment Management’s UK best ideas fund is the second in its best ideas range. It employs 10 fund managers from different groups to choose their 10 best stock ideas, thereby taking a manager of managers approach.

Arch Financial Planning director Arthur Childs thinks the UK best ideas fund has a great name and a great story behind it. “It is a concept that hardly has to be sold because it is intrinsically appealing. We all want the best and although our clients may like the sound of the cautious managed funds we have been placing them in, they may soon get fed up with what they will perceive as sluggish performance compared to their expectations of investing in the stock market,” he says.

In Childs’ view, Skandia’s new fund is a multi-manager product with a difference and that difference is seen both in the mandates given to the 10 underlying managers and the managers themselves. “The list of managers reads like a ‘Who’s Who’ of the investment management world – Ashton Bradbury, Anthony Nutt, Carl Stick, George Luckraft, Mark Tyndall, Stephen Whittaker, Roger Whiteoak and so on. In this respect it is effectively a manager of manager approach rather than a fund of funds, where the individual managers have few constraints apart from the FSA regulations. They are able to change the stocks within their portfolios as they see fit. It is as if Skandia has asked each of them to pick a handful of stocks into which they would invest their own money,” says Childs.

Childs explains that each manager will pick the 10 stocks that he believes will produce the best overall return and Skandia will bring them together in one fund. “An individual manager can, for example, have up to 25 per cent in any one stock and hold up to 20 per cent of his small portfolio in cash. Skandia will control the overall asset allocation, initially by allocating a higher percentage to some managers than others to stop the fund from being too heavily into small caps, and then by means of the cash flow to the various managers. The maximum that the fund can invest in any one stock is 8 per cent and Skandia will closely monitor this – although there are no sector maximums,” says Childs.

Childs points out that the managers have been chosen for their blend of styles so that all sectors of the UK market are covered. “Skandia estimates that there will initially be around 44 per cent invested in FTSE 100 stocks, 35 per cent in FTSE 250 and the balance in small caps including around 12 per cent in Aim. Although this is a UK fund, each manager has been given the ability to invest up to 20 per cent outside of the UK if they find the right opportunities. There is bound to be some informal competition between this group of managers which could give the fund a real edge,” says Childs.

Childs notes that the forerunner to this fund, the global best ideas fund launched in June, has already attracted more than 10,000 clients, taken £150 million and added around 14 per cent investment growth in less than four months. He believes this makes it likely that Skandia’s hopes to raise £30-£50 million for the UK fund within the first six months will be achieved.

“This is an exciting product because it seems clear that the fund managers themselves are enthusiastic about using their skills in this highly concentrated way. Some of the largest IFAs have warmed to this concept and are already asking Skandia to devise similar funds in other market sectors,” says Childs.

Although the annual management charge and total expense ratio are higher than many multi manager offerings, Childs believes this is justified. “Clients will have to accept that they are choosing to invest in a high octane sports vehicle rather than a family saloon. The initial commission is 3.5 per cent, but it hardly seems necessary to provide more than 3 per cent. I would have preferred to see a slightly lower initial charge than the extra 0.5 per cent commission.”

Looking at the potential drawbacks of the fund Childs says: “All the press comment that I have read has been very positive and a number of high profile IFAs are clearly excited about this fund. The lesson of history is that in view of this, a rather more cautious approach is to be recommended. I seem to remember the same kind of excitement when themed funds were launched in the late 1990s. How many of us got excited about funds such as Framlington new leaders, Aberdeen global champions or Merrill Lynch global titans, all of which will have disappointed our clients.”

Childs’ main concern is that the fund is appealing to the speculator rather than the long-term investor. “ I am concerned about the tendency towards short termism that may affect the fund in due course. Imagine the ignominy of being the first of the 10 managers to be dropped from the fund. This will surely put pressure on the managers to choose stocks which have already started to shine rather than those which are expected to come good in one, two or even three years’ time. For example, I cannot see M&G’s Tom Dobell being included in such a fund, yet the recovery fund he runs seems to have everything that any investor could ask for. It just takes patience to achieve.”
In terms of likely competition, Childs regards the fund as unique. He thinks competition will come from the whole universe of already highly successful multi manager products because IFAs have bought into the concept of asset allocation as being more important than simply choosing the best funds. “Groups such as 7IM, MLC – which has a manager of managers approach – and Cazenove’s excellent diversity fund will easily undercut the Skandia TER. That fact, together with their diversity of asset classes, will still be a priority for many investors,” he says.

Childs concludes: “It is difficult not to feel supportive of this fund because by intention or not it is bound to be a standard bearer for active management. While trackers have their place, I am sure that IFAs put most of their own money with active fund managers so none of us will want to see this fund fail. But we do need to warn our clients that this is an aggressive fund which at times will be well out of line with UK markets generally, so they will need to be prepared to stick with it for the long term.”


Suitability to market: Good
Investment strategy: Good
Charges: Average
Adviser remuneration: Good

Overall 9/10


‘Be proud to be an insurance salesman’

Financial advisers should be proud to be insurance salesmen and protection products should at the forefront of their minds, says Caversham Buchanan director Ian Green. Speaking at the Personal Finance Society annual conference last week in Birmingham, Green said protection is a key product for consumers and advisers are best placed to help close the […]

Close plans mortgage deal to mitigate IHT

Close Mortgages is planning a mortgage which can be used to mitigate inheritance tax. The firm is gauging demand for the product, which would enable homeowners to borrow the difference between the IHT threshold and the value of their property and put the funds into a tax-free investment vehicle so that IHT is avoided. Close […]

IFAs replace the vicar as someone people can turn to

Consumers will pay a premium for IFAs who focus on leadership, relationship building and creativity, according to business consultant Dan Sullivan. At the PFS conference in Birmingham, the motivational speaker said if IFAs are to get the most out of their clients, they need to focus less on product sales and more on relationships. He […]

GMAC and CML in talks over lender league table changes

GMAC is liaising with the Council of Mortgage Lenders to revise the trade body’s methods used to calculate its lender league table. The problem GMAC has highlighted is that majority of lenders in the 30 listed have figures calculated on a calendar year basis but there are seven lenders with different financial year-ends, so they […]

‘How to…audit your auto-enrolment scheme compliance’

Avoid pension penalties with our auto-enrolment checklist

According to the Pensions Regulator’s annual commentary and analysis report released this month, 785 potential non-compliance cases were referred for investigation, with 23 auto-enrolment compliance notices issued. And they predict that the use of their statutory powers is only going to increase.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm