View more on these topics

Gravy train hits buffers

Claim-chasers are coming to the end of the line after wreaking havoc

The gravy train is drying up. The claim-mongers, which have recently adopted the more fragrant description of “claim management companies”, are out looking for new targets.

Endowment business has been overfarmed and, in many instances, the complaints will be time-barred. With-profits bonds are gradually recovering so there is less scope there and the much-hyped contracting-out “scandal” is looking less scandalous and more sensible by the minute as Government interference continues to undermine our retirement plans.

What can a grief-stricken claim-monger do? What is left to complain about? The answer appears to be very little, so it is a case of if you can’t fleece them, join them.

The new big thing is for the CMCs to push into providing financial advice, possibly on the dubious basis that previously successful complainant clients will flock to them in droves.

How can this be? The answer is very simple – that terrible IFAs have been giving such frightfully bad advice that the claim-monger, empowered by his previous sorties, is able to ride in triumphantly, resplendent like a knight in shining armour.

By way of explanation, the Claims Standards Council advises that many of these heroes were brokers or insurers in their previous lives which, of course, raises further questions, such as, why did they leave if they were that good and what, if anything, has changed in the intervening period?

My experiences expose many claim-mongers as inveterate liars who believe that collating a list of outrageous defamations and dressing them up as a valid complaint somehow entitles them to a fee of 25 per cent plus VAT. Many firms leaflet-drop or cold-call door to door or via the phone. Others have arranged for stands inside shopping malls where their insidious leaflets are distributed by attractive young women.

Insurers tend to be easy prey, seemingly throwing in the towel and paying redress in a reckless manner. Typically, they fail to retain robust files and they also deem it financially prudent to meet small claims rather than fund the cost of fully investigating them.

IFAs are a tougher proposition as they tend to retain client files beyond the regulator’s required timescale and they also defend their position more avidly than providers.

The Financial Ombudsman Service confirms that using these companies does not improve the likelihood of the complaint being upheld. To me, this is not surprising because, far from adding value, they actually detract from the complaint by levelling accusations that can easily be disproved, thereby weakening the remaining arguments.

From any rational perspective, it would be good news for everybody if these organisations withered on the vine or moved on to other arenas where their tactics offer less opportunity for deception.

From an adviser’s view-point, every complaint lodged, whether valid, vexatious or fraudulent takes away hours of manpower with the associated cost of investigating the claim. It additionally raises the prospect for numerous FOS case fees which, at 360 a time, are levied without recourse to the merits of the complaint.

The consumer wastes 29.375 per cent of any redress paid, which means that any valid complainant is not actually placed back in a position relevant to having a repayment mortgage.

The ombudsman’s postbag would also be lighter, with a resultant reduction in ongoing costs. Perhaps more important, the newspaper consumer pages would be able to focus on more positive issues than the latest musings of a collection of self-interested parasites.

Alan Lakey is a partner at Highclere Financial Services


Altmann’s trunk call shows commitment

Some people are frighteningly committed to their jobs. Even while on the Masai Mara plains in Kenya, kids in tow and with a herd of elephants grazing nearby, pensions expert Ros Altmann managed to return Money Marketing’s call.Speaking in hushed tones to avoid disturbing the neighbouring wildlife, Altmann still managed to rant at length about […]

Cash in on the US

There is little doubt that the US unit trust market is probably the poorest across all the unit trust sectors. In fact, in all the time that I have been reviewing and recommending funds, it has always been the poorest.This has been perceived by investors who have always been underweight in the biggest economy and […]

Synaptic MD Herring quits

Synaptic Solutions managing director Selwyn Herring is leaving thefirm in the summer. Capita, which bought the company last November, says he will stay on until June to oversee the integration of Synaptic into the Enabler proposition.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm