View more on these topics

Govt still failing to address pensions for self-employed

The Government’s promise of “enhanced rights” for millions of UK workers does little to address the problem of pension provision for the self-employed, Steve Webb says.

In its response to the Taylor report published today, the Government says “major reforms” will give millions of workers new rights and these “are a vital part” of the country’s industrial strategy.

Last July the Royal Society of Arts chief executive Matthew Taylor released a Government commissioned report into modern work practices.

It said the self-employed should receive the same benefits as those that are employed and made policy recommendations to achieve this.

In some cases the Government says it plans to go further than the Taylor report’s proposals including enforcing vulnerable workers’ holiday and sick pay for the first time.

It will seek to protect workers’ rights by introducing a new naming scheme for employers who fail to pay employment tribunal awards and quadruple employment tribunal fines for employers showing malice to £20,000.

The Government also wants a list of day-one rights including holiday and sick pay entitlements and a new right to a payslip for all workers, including casual and zero-hour workers.

Although Royal London director of policy Steve Webb welcomes the proposals he worries they do not address the lack of pensions provision among the self-employed.

He says: “Despite Matthew Taylor’s recommendations, the Government response offers little hope for improving the pensions of the self-employed.”

Today the Office for National Statistics published data on trends in self-employment which shows 45 per cent of 35 to 54 year olds and 30 per cent of 55 year olds and above have no pension savings.

The number of self-employed has increased from 3.3 million in 2001 to 4.8 million 2017 which means the self-employed are now 15.1 per cent of the total labour force.

Webb adds: “The Government’s automatic enrolment review merely proposed some further research and testing on pensions and the self-employed, which is not up to the urgency of the problem.

“Pension membership amongst employed workers has soared because of automatic enrolment, but it remains shockingly low for the self-employed. It is very worrying that this issue has again been kicked ‘into the long grass’, meaning that millions of self-employed people face an insecure retirement’.

The Government will launch a number of consultations to inform what the future of the UK workforce looks like.

These include a consultation on enforcement of employment rights recommendations, one on agency workers recommendations, another on ways to increase transparency in the UK labour market and a final one on employment status.



TPR fines Now: Pensions £70,000 over admin failings

The Pensions Regulator has fined trustees at Now: Pensions £70,000 over administration failings and says these problems must be fixed by July 2018. It wants the master trust to resolve failings that have led to some scheme members’ savings not being collected from employers and invested over a number of years. A specific penalty of […]

Responsibility Matters

The latest issue of our quarterly responsible investment review, Responsibility Matters, is now available. Our review aims to highlight the issues and news items that are currently prominent within this investment sector. This issue includes a look at how we promote the aims of the Sustainable Development Goals. Read the review here Past performance is […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 4 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Why O Why do we listen to Product Provider Employees pontificating about the Government helping people to save, “O” yes I forgot the £4.63 Billion of HMRC contributions towards funding their policy charges, thus their remuneration. Its about time, 2018, we stopped relying on the nannie State, and looked after ourselves funding our own Income In Retirement assets without the undue interference of those employed by the Tax Insentivisation of the British Government.

    • Bless you! Perfectly put. Anyway dragooning the self-employed into the woebegone AE will make herding cats look easy. There are so many ways they are able to avoid imposts and are able to manipulate their figures, it will make any bureaucrat and product provider’s head spin.

  2. I’m surprised that someone of Steve Webb’s experience and knowledge seems to have completely forgotten the near 50% increase in State Pension given to the self-employed since the change to the new flat-rate State Pension.

  3. significantly missed from the article is that 49% of the self employed are classified as low paid (no links allowed here) and therefore cant afford to save. Average employed earnings £313 pw vs S/E £208 pw (ONS)

Leave a comment