View more on these topics

Govt rules out ditching pension freedoms advice requirement

Ros Altmann

Pensions minister Baroness Ros Altmann says it would be “ridiculous” to scrap rules that force people with guaranteed benefits to take regulated advice before accessing their savings using the retirement freedoms.

The Government has mandated that savers with safeguarded benefits worth more than £30,000 get regulated advice before taking their pot as cash. This includes both defined benefit pensions and policies with guarantees attached.

However, providers have faced criticism from national newspapers for blocking people from accessing their money, with “expensive” advice costing up to £1,000 listed as one of the barriers facing consumers.

On the back of this, the Personal Finance Society called on the Government to ditch the advice requirement.

But speaking to Money Marketing, Altmann says: “If you have got guaranteed benefits, you have got to have some kind of advice.

“It is ridiculous to suggest that people should just have some kind of free-for-all, but then it depends what kind of advice, who needs to give it, how people receive it and when they receive it.

“We certainly haven’t considered the idea of just getting rid of the advice requirement; there is no way we would consider that.”

PFS chief executive Keith Richards says the trade body has reversed its position following talks with the pensions minister but is looking for concessions in return.

He says: “Government reforms have provided the opportunity to use pension pots to address short-term objectives as much as their original intention to support a standard of living in retirement.

“The risk of short-term gain leading to long-term pain is an obvious unintended consequence that must be addressed.

“The inclusion of guaranteed benefits adds both complexity and risk, which means professional advice is essential. There is, however, an urgent need to amend process, expectations and future treatment of such mandated advice to better meet needs of consumers who might not want advice but have been forced to seek and pay for it.”



Osborne defends tougher accountability rules for advisers

Chancellor George Osborne has promised tough new rules which shift responsibility from the FCA to firms’ senior managers will be applied proportionality to advisers. Last week, the Treasury announced the senior managers regime will be extended to all regulated firms at some stage during 2018. This means individual businesses, rather than the FCA, will be […]


Phil Young: How platforms come to die

The much vaunted consolidation of platforms is unlikely to happen in the way most imagined. There is little appetite for traditional merger and acquisition activity, as the process of integrating two platforms is technically too difficult. Every major insurance company already has a platform, and is only likely to want another to replatform by acquisition […]


Call for pension freedoms to be reversed

The pension freedoms reforms should be reversed to make sure part of the pension pot is used to provide a steady stream of income, according to research. The Melbourne Mercer Global Pension Index ranks the pension systems of 25 countries. In its latest report Denmark and the Netherlands came first, followed by Australia. The UK […]

How to balance bottom-up with top-down research in constructing multi-asset credit portfolios

In this short video, Azhar Hussain, head of global high yield at Royal London Asset Management, explains how his team balance bottom-up with top-down research in constructing multi-asset credit portfolios. Watch the video in full The value of investments and the income from them is not guaranteed and may go down as well as up […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 2 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. If the £30k with guarantees makes up a significant part of a client’s funds it would seem sensible to ensure the guarantee is not given up lightly, so advice seems reasonable. I realise there has to be a cut-off point but it is bizzare that a client with less by a penny than £30,000 worth of guaranteed benefits may do what they wish.

  2. I agree that people need advice- but we also need to be freed from the myths about what that advice should be. A great example is the FCA consulting on removing the premise that transfers of FS schemes at 55 are unsuitable. Thank goodness for that- now maybe advisors will start to feel more confident in giving advice properly and that is helping customers balance out all of their assets and savings against all of their priorities and long-term income needs and we can get past this point. Knowing a customer, knowing all of their needs and working with them to meet them is an invaluable service when done correctly- sadly many customers have missed out on this value and had networks and advisors turn their backs on them already for fear of future liability and repercussions.

Leave a comment