View more on these topics

Govt interference means IFAs are now a dying breed

I have been in the financial services industry for 37 years, mostly as an employed IFA but since January 1996 as a partner in a provincial IFA in Kidderminster. I feel that I can no longer contain my anger and frustration as to how Governments of all political colours have interfered with our business over the years, particularly in the area of occupational and personal pensions.

In the 1960s, smaller employers copied bigger firms in establishing final-salary schemes, as employees knew they would be able to retire on a known percentage of their final earnings. Year after year, the Government insisted that improvements were made to these schemes, particularly for the early leaver. This added considerably to scheme costs.

The Government also made the mistake of removing the compulsion of employees to join occupational schemes after they had satisfied a service qualification. When inflation took off in the 1980s, these schemes were abandoned in large numbers in favour of inferior defined-contribution schemes, as employers could not stand the costs of inflation plus the costs of regulation and statutory improvements, which were difficult to share with employees.

The Government then encouraged everyone to contract out of Serps by means of appropriate personal pensions, then blamed IFAs 10 years later for advising people to do so. Also, those who advised clients to take out buyout policies have been penalised as they could not foresee further legislation improving deferred pensions.

Despite the representations of the IFA community over stakeholder pensions, since April 6, 2001 we have been lumbered with the 1 per cent maximum annual management charge, which has to cover the costs of both insurer and IFA.

While employers have been compelled to set up stakeholder schemes or acceptable alternatives, there is no compulsion for employers to contribute. It would not have taken a wizard to predict that these employer stakeholders would be a flop without employer contributions.

Despite Government efforts of persuasion, the public still believe that: “The state will look after me in my retirement and why should I pay into a pension when, even if I do save, my additional pension will be taxed at 40 per cent?”

As a result of Government intervention, our remuneration on regular pension contributions has been cut by two-thirds and the 1 per cent world is slowly spreading to other areas of pension advice, particularly in the executive pension sector.

It appears the Government believes that Joe Public is just waiting to pay fees in place of our lost commission. This is obviously not the case. Fee-based advice is good in theory but there is resistance by the public to pay fees. Where they can be charged, fees are generally considerably less than initial plus renewal commission. I am talking here about financial advice in general, not just pensions.

Certain people may consider that some commission levels paid in the past have been excessive but I believe that, when knowledge and experience plus the costs of research, admin and compliance are taken into account, this commission is well earned. With heavily reduced commission, we are at the same time burdened with increased compliance costs, which we are unable to pass on.

The charges of insurers on some contracts have been too high and charging structures themselves confusing. But we are now in the situation where matters have gone completely in favour of the consumer. We, as a reputable, highly experienced, award-winning firm and, with a partner with the AFPC, have always tried to take the same level of commission from each provider, rebating excess commission into client contracts.

If things continue as they are, independent advice will only be available to high-net-worth clients and businesses.

There are no new people being trained as IFAs due to the burden of compliance and the lack of a future in the IFA sector while current policies and attitudes exist. I would not encourage any youngster to train as an IFA at present. I am now the average age of an IFA – nearly 55. How many IFAs will there be in five years time, when I and many of my peers have retired?

Dixon Sheppard

Partner, BBI Independent Financial Advisers,Kidderminster, Worcs


Rolling on to AFPC success

There are now only 12 weeks to the next sitting of the Advanced Financial Planning Certificate examinations.If you are one of the many people who are planning on taking an exam in April (tables 1-3) then you will become either one of the 38 per cent or so of candidates who pass their exam or […]

Bidding war fear over better than best rule

The FSA&#39s scrapping of the better than best rule will spark a bidding war among providers desperate to ensure they are not left behind in the dash for distribution, claim IFAs.The FSA says it abolished the rule, which effectively limited provider investment in adviser firms to 10 per cent, so commission-based IFAs wanting to retain […]

Genesis Home Loans 2-year discount

Genesis Home Loans, discounted mortgageDiscounted term: 2 yearsDiscount: 1.25%Payable rate: 4.75%Minimum loan: £40,000Maximum loan: £250,000Income multiples: 3.25 +1, 2.75 x jointArrangement fee: £325Redemption fee: 6 months interest at SVR during discount periodConditions: max 80% LTV for first time buyersIntroducer&#39s fee: refer to packagerTel: 01832 275 044

Ownership move by Brain sparks competition fears

Mortgage Brain&#39s move to hand its ownership to a limited number of lenders has stoked fears that it could restrict competition in the market.The platform, which is also set to announce its new chief executive in “days or weeks rather than months”, says in two years the consortium of lenders will own 100 per cent […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm