View more on these topics

Can Gars break out of its slump?

Global Absolute Return Strategies fundStandard Life Aberdeen’s flagship fund and behemoth of the absolute return sector, Standard Life Investments Global Absolute Return Strategies fund, gained popularity with IFAs and DFMs when it launched in 2008.

But the fund has fallen from its £26bn peak, and stands at around £17bn now. It missed its objective of return of cash plus five per cent per annum over a three-year period for three consecutive years. Over the past year, the fund has returned -3.2 per cent; and -5.0 per cent over three years, compared to the IA Targeted Absolute Return sector’s average returns of -0.4 per cent and 4.2 per cent for the same period.

Signs of a slowdown in gross inflows three years ago inspired further investor redemptions. Nervousness escalated in February 2018, when the fund reported record outflows that jumped from £4.3bn two years before to £10.7bn.

According to Charles Stanley pension and investment analyst Rob Morgan negative performance was caused by some key poor calls made by the management, led by Guy Stern, starting in 2015.

Morgan says: “They were premature in calling the end of the equity bull market while predictions of higher interest rates and inflation, the basis of certain relative trading strategies, were detrimental.

“More recently, the portfolio’s emerging market equity and debt positions have been affected by a stronger US dollar.”

Standard Life Aberdeen outflows top £31bn as Gars continues to struggle

An Aberdeen Standard Investments spokeswoman says the company admits it made mistakes in predicting the end of the cycle as well as the negative impact of other “strategy-specific issues”, but remains committed to reducing redemptions over time.

Gars employs different strategies to maximise returns while keeping volatility low, intending to provide positive returns in all market conditions, but some see this as unrealistic.

gbi2 managing director Graham Bentley warns about the opaqueness of absolute return funds’ investment techniques. He says: “The more complex the strategies are, the less predictable the results.”

Moreover, using multiple strategies to minimise overall volatility of a portfolio may have a downside: “If you are using a variety of tools to dampen risk, almost by definition, you are dampening down the returns as well,” Bentley says.

Chelsea Financial Services managing director Darius McDermott, on the other hand, continues to favour the fund’s mix-and-match approach: “We still like the concept of SLI Gars: the multi-strategy approach in a multi-asset fund.

“In down markets it has also done its job: falling far less than the stock market in 2008 and later in 2016. However, it has been disappointing and underperformed over the past three consecutive years and has not met its cash-plus target in that time.

“While we supported it for many years, we have since downgraded it to a generic switch rating.”

Fund research company Square Mile portfolio manager Charles Hovenden says that periods of negative performance come with the territory in the absolute return sector. The research firm continues to recommend Gars to investors, as the fund remains in the Square Mile Academy of Funds. Hovenden says that Square Mile will continue to monitor the fund.

Speaking to Money Marketing, the ASI spokeswoman says: “The strong performance of other asset classes and low market volatility in recent years has undoubtedly made investors look away from the volatility managed absolute return sector. We know that such a benign market environment won’t last forever and when this happens, Gars and other volatility managed products should do well.”

When Gars first started out, it was the only fund of its kind, but later faced an exodus of senior staff, who started copycat funds at competitors. In 2012, senior manager trio David Millar, Dave Jubb and Richard Batty joined Invesco Perpetual to launch a similar fund. In 2014, one of the lead managers, Euan Munro, went to Aviva and introduced his version of an absolute return fund there.

The £12.7bn Invesco Perpetual Global Targeted Returns and the £5.2bn Aviva Investors Multi-Strategy Target Return fund have provided one and three-year returns of -1.6 and 4.2 per cent; and -1.3 and -1.1 per cent respectively.

The ASI spokeswoman says that the company’s advice arm 1825 has three holdings in the absolute return multi-asset sector, including Gars, which comprises around five per cent of the total portfolio fund allocations.

Gars’ downgrades

After months of review and processing each of the underlying trade ideas since inception, Fundhouse rates SLI Gars negatively when it seemed to be at the height of its powers, and despite the fact that fund was doing well at the time and achieving its goals. “In our opinion, the market had provided disproportionate tailwinds and so we thought the returns were achieved in an environment that was atypical,” says managing director Rory Maguire.

Hargreaves Lansdown senior analyst Laith Khalaf removed Gars from its Wealth 150 list of top funds it recommends to investors following the departure of one of the fund’s architects, Euan Munro, to launch a similar fund at Aviva.

FE downgraded Gars’ rating to one FE crown. The fund research and rating agency saw red flags in the large number of people working on the fund and wondered how efficiently the 60-strong team could communicate. Moreover, FE felt there was a risk that the management was falling behind and the investment approach was not dynamic enough for a macro strategy, according to FE research manager Charles Younes.



Zurich rolls out new protection platform

Zurich has launched a new life protection platform giving clients more flexibility on policies and making it easier for the company to develop new products. The company said its old platform was actually six systems working together which was less efficient and made it more expensive to innovate. According to market management head Peter Hamilton […]


Sesame and Openwork top latest FOS complaints table

Well-known names in the advice market like Sesame, Openwork and St James’s Place have once again topped the latest complaints data as the number of complaints against financial planners has ticked up. However, the proportion of upheld complaints against the most complained about advice firms fell in the first half of the year, according to […]


Hargreaves Lansdown launches delayed cash product

Hargreaves Lansdown has rolled out a cash service tool after more than two years of delays. The new service, Active Savings, will let users save money in cash alongside an Isa, Sipp or in general investments. According to a Financial Times report, the launch follows a series of delays for the product which was initially […]

How important are risk ratings?

By Andrew Morris, Sales Manager, Canada Life Investments In the past we’ve looked at the importance of diversification in investigating what place multi-asset funds had in today’s low cost, tracker-dominated world. We believe that it is imperative that appropriate, suitable multi-asset products are available for clients, to ensure that their risk requirements and appetite are fully […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. According to Investopedia:-

    As an investment vehicle, an absolute return fund seeks to make positive returns by employing investment management techniques that differ from traditional mutual funds. Absolute return investment techniques include using short selling, futures, options, derivatives, arbitrage, leverage and unconventional assets. Absolute returns are examined separately from any other performance measures, so only gains or losses on the investment in question are considered.

    Given the use of all those techniques, it’s hard not to surmise that the prospects of any AR fund NOT achieving its objectives are considerably greater than it doing so. One wonders how many advisers who recommended AR funds to their clients actually took a good look at how they’re supposed to work before doing so.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm