View more on these topics

Funds with performance fees under fire


Funds that charge performance fees have come in for criticism after it has emerged they are failing to beat trackers and underperform funds without performance fees.

The Financial Times reports research from Architas which found out of 121 UK funds with performance fees, 97 per cent failed to beat a passive fund tracking the MSCI World index over three years.

The research spanned equity, absolute return and property funds.

Separate analysis by the FT of Morningstar data found the largest European funds with performance fees underperformed those without over one, three and five years.

Architas investment director Adrian Lowcock says: “The presence of a performance fee can convince retail investors they are buying into something or someone special, who will do better because the manager’s motives are aligned with theirs. In reality, nothing outstanding happens.”

Hargreaves Lansdown head of research Mark Dampier says: “In a year the fund performs well, you could find yourself paying 4 per cent to 5 per cent in total charges.

“If the next year is bad and the manager loses your money, you don’t get back what you paid him in the good year. There is no alignment of interests here. It is simply lining of pockets.”



Paul Lewis: Why aren’t advisers paid on results?

One per cent. It does not sound much does it? Every year an adviser takes 1 per cent of my money and for that small fee, manages it. So I entrust my adviser with £100,000 and pay them £1,000 a year to invest my money and strike a balance between risk and reward. If at […]


Taskforce reveals 300 charges in bid to cut ‘hidden’ fund costs

An industry taskforce has identified more than 300 different costs associated with investments and pensions, and up to £120bn in hidden fees taken by asset managers a year. Transparency Task Force has created a template listing the costs, which will be presented to the FCA and other organisations. The template found more than 300 lines of costs and charges on […]

Reforming India: just the beginning

By Kunal Desai, Neptune India Fund

As global investors continue to scour emerging markets through the lens of reform potential, India shines bright. Indeed, we think it can sparkle even brighter. We anticipate India’s self-imposed 10-year ‘policy holiday’ to turn into one of the most pro-growth and pro-investment policy calendars seen in Asia in years. The Indian electorate has engineered a historic verdict. We now have the strongest Indian government since 1984, with the pro-market Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) achieving an absolute majority for the first time in the party’s history.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Performance fees are acceptable only if they’re balanced with under-performance rebates.

Leave a comment