View more on these topics

FSA will soon be losing its powers to Europe

Although much discussion continues about the activities of the FSA, it

appears that some people are still slow to understand how financial

services will be regulated in the near future.

When the UK signed the Maastricht agreement which codified many details of

the single European market, it also passed many powers of government to the

EU authorities.

Importantly, it allowed for subsequent incremental legislation to follow in

the future.

Thus, we now see our own regulator, the FSA, being usurped within one year

of its own existence.

The FSA publicly acknowledged recently that all UK mortgages could be

regulated by the European Commission as soon as 2006 – barely two years

from when the FSA takes over from the MCCB.

Mortgage lenders have recently flagged their alarm that flexible mortgages

– which can save borrowers thousands of pounds – may be regulated out of

existence by the EU.

“Execution-only” brokers are facing genuine extinction of their business if

the recent directive from the EU is not substantially amended – and the

signs are it will not be.

Aifa&#39s Paul Smee quite reasonably acclaims his success in dissuading the

FSA to continue its defined-payment system plan.

However, Mr Smee was given a couple of extra aces to his hand when, within

weeks of the original idea, a proposed directive from Europe announced that

intermediaries could be both independent and paid through commission.

The FSA would have known at once that its idea was dead in the water. It

has backed down with good grace but also with good reason.

By the same token, it was a pointless exercise for IFAs to complain to the

FSA about the proposal for depolarisation.

Quite simply, the concept does not exist in Europe and the FSA had to move

the rules here towards those of a single market. It had a duty to the EU to

scrap polarisation and it is duly doing so.

Ron Sandler&#39s proposals for a simplified range of financial products which

could be bought without advice, which were warmly welcomed by the FSA, are

already under threat from the European authorities, as Sandler himself

recently acknowledged.

As I see the situation, they are unlikely to be allowed to be brought to

market as Mr Sandler has intended.

To understand this conflict, one must appreciate the relative

sophistication of the UK market and its investing public compared with

markets in many other European countries, particularly those just about to

join the EU.

In many of these countries, there is little public experience of investment

equities, pension funding, flexible mortgages, buy to let, life insurance,


Yet these people will need to be given the same protection as every other

citizen in an EU state, including Britain.

And so, when IFAs want to consider future regulation of their business,

they should look to Brussels rather than Canary Wharf. The FSA has a very

limited lifespan, unless it moves towards being a local monitoring branch

for the EU. Its own rules are already subject to EU legislation and, as

that legislation is increased, codified and drafted towards the

pan-European market, so its own influence will wane.

The political ramifications of EU powers are beyond the scope of this

letter but the intriguing point for Euro-sceptic IFAs (such as I) is that

many of the new rules will tend to favour advised transactions rather than

caveat emptor purchases of financial products. The IFA is likely to prosper

from future laws.

While I do believe that Messrs Davies, Sandler and others are keen to widen

the actively buying market rather than what is currently mainly an

adviser-led market, I think they will largely be frustrated by EU

legislation that seeks to protect savers and borrowers from themselves.

We will shortly be regulated from a centralised Brussels authority.

Democratic and in touch? Unlikely. Good for IFA business? Quite probably.

Galling for those individuals in regulation who like to consider themselves

as important men? Most definitely.

Chris Petrie

Christopher Charles Financial Services,

Ecton, Northampton


IFAs&#39 compensation levy looks set to be £800,000

The IFA sector can expect to pay a levy of about £800,000 towardsFinancial Services Compensation Scheme costs in the 2003/2004 financialyear, equating to roughly the same amount paid last year.The FSCS will have a budget of £12.4m to cover its fixed costs and ifcompensation costs are similar to this year – £43.5m – excludingpension misselling […]

L&G rolls out equity release product to all IFAs

Legal & General is now marketing its equity release mortgage to all IFAs, as the lender sees the product as a growth market for 2003.The product, that had formerly only been marketed to a limited number of IFAs, has a fixed interest rate of 7.3 per cent for the life of the mortgage.L&G director of […]

Burns-Anderson to help advisers exploit loan opportunities

Burns-Anderson is introducing two new services, B-A Mortgage Services andB-A Protect, aimed at its IFA and mortgage adviser members.B-A Mortgage Services is a mortgage club with a panel of 16 providers and arange of ancillary support services for brokers.B-A Protect is a GISCregulated service consisting of a panel of providersof products associated with mortgages such […]

Warnings of backlash on multi-manager fees

Fund-of-funds providers could face resistance from investors if theycontinue to hit them with costly and obscure charges in falling stockmarketconditions, IFAs claim.Research conducted for Money Marketing reveals that third-party fundmanager fees and attributable expenses continue to raise total expenseratios for many multi-managers to between 2.5 and 3 per cent a year.The worst offender is Artemis, […]

Neptune Global Income: Is Japan the best dividend market in the world?

By George Boyd-Bowman, Fund Manager at Neptune The Neptune Global Income Fund seeks exposure to the very best – and often overlooked – income opportunities from across the world. Unconstrained by benchmarks, the fund currently has 24 per cent invested in Japan, differentiating the high conviction portfolio from many of its peers. Watch Neptune Fund […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm