View more on these topics

Friends not trying to hide changes

Response letter to Peter Rutherford & Co technical manager Mike Gordon

I have received your letter dated May 2 which appeared in Money Marketing

last week.

You claim that Friends Prov-ident is using the proposed demutualisation

“to hide a change in the membership rules” and that such a change “cannot

be in the interests of members”. We firmly reject both these claims.

We have not in any way hidden the proposal to extend membership. The

circular is open, transparent and explicit in this regard and I would refer

you to a key paragraph in the two-page summary on pages three and four of

the circular.

The paragraph headed Eligibility on page four refers clearly and in plain

words to the extension of membership as an integral part of the proposal

and quantifies the impact of this element of the proposal by informing our

members that such an extension will reduce the demutualisation benefits of

the existing holders of “eligible with-profits policies” by approximately

4.7 per cent.

I am disappointed that your letter makes no mention of this clear

disclosure and seeks to imply that it is apparent only to those who have

“taken the time to read the small print in your 88-page members&#39 circular”.

The proposal to extend membership is also covered in paragraph seven on

pages 14 to 16 of the circular, where the reasons are set out why the board

felt it was fair and reason-able to extend membership to those

policyholders whose membership had ceased through no fault of their own

after the announcement on May 4, 2000. While you seem to dismiss its

importance, the independent actuary (at paragraph 5.4 on page 49 of the

circular) regards the proposed extension of membership as being “in line

with good practice” (it has happened in a number of earlier

demutual-isations) and supports this element of the proposal, stating that

in his view the “resulting dilution…. is acceptable”. You will,

therefore, understand that I cannot accept that the proposal to extend

membership has been hidden in any way.

You claim we are being undemocratic as to the voting process by including

the proposal to extend membership rights within the proposal to

demutualise. We reject any suggestion that we are being undemocratic. The

board has had to consider many issues to arrive at a proposal which it

believes to be fair. In doing so, the board has applied a consistent set of


The alternative policy of a series of separate resolutions on the

individual issues could extend to many aspects of the scheme and would not

only be impracticable but would result in a much lengthier and more complex

process. Furthermore, such an approach could result in a conditional

approval which would be unworkable.

You also raised the issue of the extent of benefits to matured or “well

advanced” policies. The general allocation of shares is based on growth in

asset share of the policy. Those policies that have been in force longest

have contributed most to the growth of Friends and are being rewarded


The timescale for voting is entirely in line with leading practice and the

demutual-isation process is not in any way being “rushed through”.

David Newbigging


Friends Provident,



Hargreaves Lansdown offers online share dealing

Hargreaves Lansdown is launching an online trading platform which allows private investors to trade stocks in real time. Investors can place orders at any time, with orders placed outside market hours executed when the stockmarket next opens.Hargreaves Lansdown head of internet stockbroking David Rawlings says: “While we cannot provide our clients with an actual seat […]


What&#39s wrong with independent financial advice? Nothing with theprinciple, of course, but we never seem to be far away from the next whineabout persecution or the rising costs of being in business. Should wereally be surprised? After all, is the sector not suffering from somefairly fundamental structural flaws? An ageing demographic, coupled with a pitiful […]

Esure to launch motor insurance line

Halifax&#39s Esure insurance subsidiary is launching its motor insurance line with the opening of a Glasgow office employing 400 new staff.Esure, headed by Direct Line founder Peter Wood, will launch its telephone based motor insurance sales service in September, with an internet sales platform to go live in the last quarter of 2001.Executive chairman Peter […]

Prudential&#39s flexible annuity

Tuesday, 15 May 2001.Prudential Annuities – Flexible Lifetime AnnuityType: With-profits and unit-linked annuity.Minimum investment: £100,000.Minimum age: 50.Income frequency: Monthly, quarterly, half yearly or annually. Payable in advance or in arrears.Charges: Initial 3 per cent, annual 0.8-1.225 per cent.Options: None.Commission: Initial 2 per cent, renewal 0.25 per cent.Tel: 0845 6060630.Broker Panel:-Peter Quinton – Managing director, The […]


What employers should expect over the next five years

A major feature of our articles is looking into the Jelf Employee Benefits crystal ball to predict changes and trends that may influence the short and medium term shape of UK employee benefits.  By flagging such changes early we aim to provide our followers with the tools to make sensible and informed decisions on their benefits offerings.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm