French manager calls out ‘cheeky’ rivals over Mifid II research rules

Carmignac managing director Didier Saint-Georges

French asset manager Carmignac has called for more clarification on the new research costs rules under Mifid II as it claims rival firms have wrongly stated what the directive means for their business.

Speaking to Money Marketing after an event in Paris, Carmignac managing director Didier Saint-Georges referred to asset managers as “cheeky” in their language when explaining their approach to the new rules on research costs required by Mifid II.

Under the Mifid II legislation, which came into force this month, asset managers need to disclose how much they pay brokers for investment research separately from trading costs. Firms have to declare whether they pass these costs to their clients or pay out of their own pockets for it.

In September the €56bn (£50bn) Paris-based asset manager announced it was passing the cost of research to clients once the European regulation would come into force in January, contrary to most of its European and global rivals.

Will advisers be able to afford research after Mifid II?

Saint-Georges says: “There is a lot of confusion about this subject. I am hearing a number of asset managers saying they will absorb costs, but the reality is that Mifid II impacts what asset managers can do with their mandates, it doesn’t impact the mutual funds.

“Asset managers have been cheeky about [Mifid II]. They forget that when they say Mifid II clients, what they [should say] is mandates, so very often those asset managers have very few mandates and theoretically they will continue to charge the cost for all their mutual funds and only absorb for the mandates because that is the rule.”

Saint-Georges believes fixed income and passive fund managers are “a bit over the top” when they say they will pay for research themselves, as they are supposedly in less need of research compared to active managers.

He adds: “I count on media to clarify this positioning as when I hear the market saying [asset managers] will absorb the costs I don’t think that is true.”

Yet Saint-Georges couldn’t say if the decision to continue charging investors for research has been reflected in material changes in fund fees for Carmignac.

He says: “What we said [we will not absorb the research costs] we said that we are very transparent and won’t change anything. Many asset managers are not ready yet, we were ready ahead of Mifid II and were giving that information ahead of the requirement and we said all along that there is no reason to change right now with our providers that we consider very important.”

Carmignac has seen €400m inflows over 2017 helped by their bond funds.


Providers review adviser marketing amid Mifid II inducements confusion

Providers are reviewing their marketing packages to advisers at conferences and on websites amid concerns they will fall foul of new inducement rules under Mifid II. Mifid II, which came into force on 3 January, brought in more stringent rules around “non-monetary benefits” from providers to advisers. The rules have been translated into the FCA conduct of […]

Compliance tip: Key changes to comply with Mifid II

The Insurance Distribution Directive, General Data Protection Regulation and Mifid II all impact how firms interact with clients, leading to necessary changes to client agreements. Here we consider the main alterations that will need to have been made to comply with Mifid II. It has always been necessary to describe the service to be received […]


Transact readying for float in March

Transact parent IntegraFin Holdings is applying to list on the main market of the London Stock Exchange with the float expected to take place in March. IntegraFin today confirmed its intention to go ahead with an initial public offering. Shares in the company will be offered to UK institutional investors. Those “elsewhere outside the United […]

Pension - thumbnail

David Cameron appoints former adviser to Tony Blair as new pensions minister

Following a cabinet reshuffle in light of last week’s general election, David Cameron has announced that Ros Altmann will be replacing Steve Webb as pensions minister. As the industry works with one of the largest reforms to the sector in almost a century, the former adviser to Tony Blair has been tasked with ensuring that the pensions revolution does not stray off track.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment