View more on these topics

Fragile future

There is danger lurking on the horizon for fund management as EU finance ministers discuss the future of collective investment. In advance of the new Ucits (undertakings for collective investment in transferable securities) agreement, which could be reached next month – and amid low general industry awareness – what is the current state of play?

Fund management could face a major shake-up if a proposed EU directive gets the go-ahead. The Ucits directive is the framework under which fund managers can market and sell their products in other EU countries.

Originally agreed in 1985, it provides, in effect, passports for certain investment products. As the EU has set itself the goal of establishing an integrated financial market by 2005, this directive is to be amended. The first amendment, extending asset range, has been welcomed in the UK. The second raft of amendments, however, has been met with consternation.

Political agreement was reached on the first proposal at a meeting of Ecofin, the council of European finance ministers, last October. The second is still under discussion and the Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brown is understood to have opposed it at the last meeting. It is possible that agreement could be reached when Ecofin next meets on March 12.

The controversial second proposal, opposed by Autif, contains a variety of measures.

Some are uncontentious. Unit trust managers would, for instance, see restrictions on their activity eased and be allowed to carry out more work – discretionary portfolio management, for instance.

Then there is also a proposal for a harmonised and simplified prospectus. This would be a single marketing document from which a company would be able to sell across Europe and which would require no more than translation. This would be a web-friendly measure in line with the amendment&#39s aim of meeting ongoing developments in e-commerce.

Now for the proposals that Autif feels would put UK fund managers at a disadvantage. Corporate funds, Oeics and Sicavs (their French counterparts), will have passports across Europe whereas contractual investment funds will not. So countries would potentially be able to acquire UK investors with no cost base in this country.

In two major markets, Germany and Italy, retail investment is contractual rather than corporate, which means that the UK will not be able to reciprocate.

Autif senior international policy adviser Julie Patterson says: “The passport will be discriminatory in effect and create distortions in the market.” She does not see it as contributing to a single market, and thinks it a retrograde step.

The second contentious measure relates to capital adequacy. The current proposal would require investment companies to keep the equivalent of 13 weeks of fixed overheads in reserve or an as yet unagreed percentage of funds under management.

Patterson believes that this measure would unduly affect the UK, which has a preponderance of smaller companies. Whereas the UK and France have a diverse sector with small, medium and large investment companies, the rest of Europe is dominated by the large banking groups, which have a lot of capital.

Patterson is also unhappy that no analysis has been done to back this measure, and she disagrees with the assertion that the total of funds under management would, on its own, provide a proper assessment of risk.

The third disputed measure relates to delegation. In the UK a large amount of delegation takes place, be it asset management or marketing that is farmed out. But some countries are very opposed to delegation – Germany in particular. They would retain the power to refuse it whereas it would continue to be allowed in the UK.

The proposals that have already been agreed and welcomed by Autif extend the range of assets that a fund can invest in and still be passportable. In addition to the equities and bonds which are currently allowed, fund managers will be able to invest in derivatives, deposits, funds of funds and mixed funds. Property, venture capital, master-feeder or geared and hedge funds will still be excluded.

This has been broadly welcomed as putting things on a more equal footing. One overall possible effect of the new directive, according to LeggMason product director Brett Greatex, would be a further stimulation for trusts to convert into Oeics.

As the range of assets is extended so are the investment limits, but this would still be broadly in line with current UK regulations.

With the greater range of assets, a new limit of exposure to a single group rather than stock is introduced. For equity and debt, this limit will be 10 per cent, with an overall limit of 20 per cent to any particular group.

Patterson believes this will not be a problem for UK fund managers, other than as an extra compliance cost.

UK products would become more passportable. But when taken together with the negative impact of the second proposal, Autif is urging the Government to withdraw from the directive unless significant alterations are agreed.


Merrill Lynch Investment Managers launches CGT software

Merrill Lynch Investment Managers is launching a software package designed to process capital gains tax calculations.The software models the tax effect of any transaction before it is made and produces a full UK capital gains tax report, summarising all investment transactions and the rate of taper relief applicable to each transaction. It will also provide […]

Black and white in grey areas

The general election is almost certain to follow this Budget within a couple of months. Every political party is now targeting the grey vote as crucial to its election prospects. Take these two points together and you have the potential for this Budget to be the most interesting from a pension viewpoint for many years. […]

Pink leaps into market with new parachute mortgage

Pink Home Loans is bailing into the adverse credit market with its parachute mortgage.The mortgage is aimed at people who are looking to buy a home but who either have a history of bad credit, or who have a number of county court judgements (CCJs) against them.The mortgages rate is based around the London interbank […]

Stakeholder can give IFAs introduction

Scottish Equitable is urging IFAs to use stakeholder as a foot in the door to talk to company directors and executives about pension provision. It says it could give IFAs the opportunity to cross-sell executive pensions or SSASs. ScotEq is producing a director&#39s pack with marketing literature, a tax reference guide, sales aids, technical support […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm