View more on these topics

First consumer research: Clients remaining loyal to advisers post-RDR

NMG Consulting examines consumer attitudes to the RDR and finds more investors likely to consider advice.


Research suggests consumers continue to believe in the benefits of using a financial adviser post-RDR, with many investors more likely to consider advice than they were previously.

NMG Consulting has carried out the first wave of its new Investor Census, which monitors consumer attitudes to the RDR and the impact the reforms are having on consumer behaviour. It has based its analysis on online interviews conducted in April with 1,000 mass market and high net worth investors holding at least £10,000 in investable assets. The sample includes roughly the same amount of advised clients and non-advised consumers.


NMG explained the requirements under the RDR of adviser fees and higher qualifications, then asked consumers whether they would use an adviser in future.

Of the 523 respondents who had an adviser, 98 per cent said they would continue to receive advice. Of the 201 who had stopped using an adviser, 68 per cent said they would now move to advice, while of the 280 who had never seen an adviser 46 per cent said they would move to advice.

The research shows 80 per cent of those who would continue to use an adviser in future and 86 per cent of those who would move to advice believed it was crucial for their adviser to be independent. Advisers that came recommended or held chartered status were also important criteria for consumers in choosing their adviser, but to a lesser extent.

The majority of consumers, both advised and non-advised, felt the key parts of the advice process worth paying for were a recommendations report and implementation.

When it comes to paying for advice, 47 per cent of those who plan to move to advice and 35 per cent who plan to continue getting advice would be most likely to pay the adviser direct. A further 17 per cent of prospective clients would have the adviser charge deducted from the investment, compared to 37 per cent of advised clients.

NMG analysed its findings and categorised consumers’ attitudes to paying for advice into four groups: dedicated direct users, who would arrange all future investment products without advice; advised clients who would also use other channels; consumers who do not have an adviser currently and would use several channels to buy investments; and dedicated advice users.

Based on its sample, direct users account for 20 per cent of consumers, 38 per are advised “multi-channel” clients, 28 per cent are currently non-advised multi-channel users, and 11 per cent are dedicated adviser users. The remaining 3 per cent are not planning to take out financial products in future.

The research shows 71 per cent of dedicated advice users are confident advisers are acting in their best interests. Perhaps worryingly, 39 per cent of dedicated advice users say they have a good understanding of the cost of financial advice, but NMG says this may improve over time as disclosure around costs improves.

The research also suggests advisers may face an uphill struggle if they believe prospective clients will willingly relinquish all control over their investments.


Some 88 per cent of non-advised multi-channel clients said they would always do their own internet research before seeing an adviser, and 77 per cent said they would only see an adviser for complex products and handle other investments by themselves.

Attain Wealth Management managing director Gordon Crothers says: “If clients have been stung in the past by a previous adviser, they do not have the confidence to trust an adviser completely. Hopefully an understanding of what the RDR changes mean will reignite consumers’ interest in dealing with advisers.”

Clearwater Financial Planning managing director Duncan Carter says: “Those who seek out advice do so because they need it or they value it. There is still mistrust of advisers, and we would be naïve to think otherwise. There will always be a group of people that do not seek advice, which may be down to trust, cost or general inertia. I think it will take a while for the public to get their head around the fact that advice is not solely about pushing products.”

Investment Quorum chief executive Lee Robertson says: “It used to be the case that we as advisers knew everything, and the public knew nothing. It is right that people challenge their advisers, just as they would challenge their doctors or their accountants.

“For those that are confident enough to self-direct, I wish them every luck. But there will be those who want the extra assistance, the confidence of working with someone who knows their way around the market, who understands the complexities of tax planning. As we go forward I expect there will be more of a “pick and mix” approach, where self-directed investors come to an adviser for complex planning or an issue they are less familiar with. What the RDR has delivered is a way for investors to become more engaged and involved with the advice process.”



CPI inflation increases to 2.7% in May

The consumer prices index grew by 2.7 per cent over the year to May, up from 2.4 per cent in April. The biggest increase came from transport, notably motor and air travel, and clothing, while the largest price drops came from food. The inflation rate has returned to the levels seen between October 2012 and […]


Government sets sights on radical collective DC move

Pensions minister Steve Webb is set to propose radical plans for collective DC pension schemes with the aim of better sharing risk across members. Speaking to the Financial Times, Webb said collective private pension schemes, which combine pension funds of “big, household name” firms, could provide better returns for retirees. A central aim of collective […]

PwC: Companies making ‘little progress’ in boosting DB funding

Companies are making “little progress” towards cutting the financial burden of defined benefit pension schemes, analysis from PricewaterhouseCoopers suggests. The PwC ‘pensions support index’, which monitors the overall level of support provided by FTSE 350 firms with DB schemes, currently stands at 70 out of 100. PwC says this is only one point higher than […]

Royal London to launch D2C proposition

Royal London is launching a non-advised direct-to-consumer proposition that will offer simple savings and protection products.  The proposition will launch in the second half of 2014 under the Royal London brand. The firm says the move will create 70 new jobs. It will be delivered through telephone and online services. All products at launch will be manufactured […]

Survey cover

EEF/Jelf Employee Benefits Sickness Absence Survey 2015

EEF stated in its 2015 EEF Manifesto that the UK’s growth prospects depend on people being fit, working and productive. Keeping people in work and helping people return to work is very important for the manufacturing sector. It means boosting productivity by getting people back into work as early as is possible, as well as fostering workplace cultures and environments that proactively manage individuals’ health conditions so that all can benefit from lower sickness absence outcomes.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 11 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Further evidence that the doomsayers were wrong.

    RDR killed the banks. IFA firms have adapted well and can thrive. Restricted advice was a red herring, most small firms have stood up to commercial vested interests and continued to be independent.

    As ever, IFAs have proven adaptable.

  2. “Passengers still loyal to lifeboats after iceberg accident” SS Titanic

  3. I know what my clients are telling me and actually, that’s all that matters…But it is not good!

  4. @ Anon 08:43

    Spot on you are so right. Previous research going back years and often relied on by the regulator merely looked at those who never took advice – and were never likely to. No wonder they got the results they were looking for.

    Those who engage do value what we do and are overwhelmingly loyal. In the current financial mess it is hardly surprising that more will now seek us out. There is a correlation between the numbers seeking advice, low interest rates and high taxation.

    We are not merely any port in a storm; we are the ONLY port in the storm.

    What Garry Heath is on about I have no idea – I never was any good and cryptic crosswords.

  5. I wonder if this is from, the same people that gave us the infamous ‘Australian Survey’ or the one that FSA ‘proved’ commission bias ??

    We’ll see won’t we – the proof in the pudding and all that.

    RDR directly reduced the advice/savings/pensions gaps there’s a thought !

    Don’t hold your breath

  6. And what about the 1/3 that have stopped using advice ?

    The move to advisors is easily explained by the fact they there is no bank based alternative.

    Lies damned lies and statistics !

    What about the 50 odd % who don’t use advice.

    The IFA who moves to take the middle ground and stops getting up themselves with their HNW clients will clean up !!!

  7. Soren Lorenson 21st June 2013 at 9:52 am

    Let’s not get too excited.

    We’re only six months in. Many clients will have had little or no contact with their adviser who will still be being paid by trail commission.

    For the majority of clients, to date, little has changed.

  8. Well I can only speak for myself, and our clients have remained loyal and we have begun moving them to advisor charging, and so far no real problems, we’ve just explained what the changes are about and why we have to do them.

    All those people that tried to frighten me last year clearly didn’t tell our clients! Nor the new ones we have taken on in 2013.

    And I have literally no idea what Derek Gair is on about when he talks about the “pensions gap”…the last 6 months have seen more people join a pension scheme than any 6 month period in history, a trend that will continue as auto-enrolment covers all companies within the next 3 years or so. What can he mean?

  9. @ IFA

    I wasn’t aware RDR and AE were linked !

  10. @ Anon 12:44

    In many ways, they are. AE kills the argument put forward by RDR refusniks that the new rules will prevent pensions being arranged.

    It’s hard to claim RDR is creating a “savings gap” when millions of people are joining a pension scheme for the first time in their lives.

    Fortuitous for the F(S)CA? Maybe, but it’s true all the same.

  11. Could someone go tell Nic Cicutti who is still churning messages about regaining trust.
    Well Nic here is a clear message from our clients: We never lost their confidence!

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and thought leadership.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm