View more on these topics

Find the right mix

Helen Pow asks if it is time for investors to move away from diversifying their portfolios

As one of the stars of the UK stockmarket, Invesco Perpetual top-performing income and high income fund manager Neil Woodford’s sometimes radical opinions count.

The latest? In a recent Sunday Times interview, Woodford criticised the common investing philosophy of “diversifying” a portfolio. But other UK fund managers are opposed to writing-off the method.

Woodford believes most asset classes in the UK have become closely correlated and are getting increasingly expensive, particularly property, which he claims is overvalued. People investing into every asset class simply because diversification is the done thing are being overcautious and will see poor returns, he says.

Instead, Woodford recommends investors look for cheaper and more traditional funds which are not dependant on the economic cycle. He says they should steer clear of commodities, which he claims are not investments because they do not deliver dividends, and property funds.

Axa Investment Office senior manager Colin Nelson says diversification depends on the type of investor – it is not for everyone but for many it is an effective method of investing. He says risk-adverse people are happy to diversify their portfolio because it limits volatility. But he understands why people chasing the top-performing funds may be unimpressed by the recent performance of some assets classes, and therefore less keen to buy into them all.

He says: “Diversification is about reducing volatility, combined with an increased outright potential for return. Yes, it reduces those highs, but the lows will also not be so low. It is good for the individual who is more risk adverse. If you are looking for performance you have to be prepared to take a risk.”

Fidelity Multi-Manager managing director Simon Ellis says despite the fact markets have become more correlated you cannot write-off diversification.

He states that, historically, people actively shifted between different developed markets such as Japan, Europe and the UK, but during the past few years those markets have become increasingly correlated. Ellis wonders whether this correlation is a temporary phenomenon or a permanent phenomenon. He says: “I agree it is more expensive than it was two years ago but that is not to say there is no value in there. There are pockets of value in every single asset class.”

Barings Asset Management chief investment officer Michael Hughes agrees that it has become harder to achieve diversification in developed equity markets. He says: “With equity markets being highly correlated it is more difficult to find diversification but there are other ways of getting diversification.”

Hughes suggests moving into global markets is an alternative to traditional diversification.

He states: “UK-based investors traditionally put most equity in UK markets but there is an argument saying it would be a better way of approaching risk by going for global equity. It might make more sense having half in global and half in UK equity.”

Different manager skills and different investor styles also contribute to diversification according to Hughes.

Nelson agrees the style of investor and the level of expertise they plug into are important points to consider.

He says: “There is place for diversification both within and across assets.”

Nelson says, in equity funds investors can choose from large cap, mid cap and small cap and in terms of property, investors can diversify between geographical regions such as the UK, Europe and Asia.

F&C Multi-Manager fund manager Tom Caddick agrees that diversification for the sake of diversification is rubbish.

He says: “Diversification purely for diversification’s sake is not a good thing. There needs to be a reason to buy an asset other than diversification.”

He suggests investors should choose funds depending on their investment timeframe and the value of the asset.

Ellis agrees, and says rather than simply choosing a fund that is cheap now or will be in the next six months Fidelity takes a longer-term view of the value of an asset class. According to Ellis, choosing a fund based on price and perceived value is not a good idea. He says: “Neil’s recognised expertise is first class but I do not think diversification is something people should avoid. It is down to the timescale and finding decent value between them, but to write-off an asset class because it is too expensive is too general.”

Caddick says that while Woodford is wary of investing in property, F&C believes it can still deliver lucrative returns.

He says: “In the long term we are positive on commercial property. It brings with it strong and diversified income streams and means for capital growth and upward potential for rental review. We are not expecting the same returns as the past few years but through income streams there is the potential for income growth and capital growth at around or above inflation and still high returns.”

So it seems many fund managers believe diversification is still a useful tool. Even if some asset classes are underperforming, the comfort and peace of mind of having your finger in many pots is still attractive to investors



Will you keep selling Asps despite the Government’s warning that they will get rid of them if advisers sell them to all suitable clients rather than just those with religious objections to annuities? John Reynolds, Strategic Financial Advice Yes “It’s important to make all the options available to clients.” Eugene Goodwill, Eugene Goodwill IFA Yes […]

Out with a bang

So farewell then, Gerrard. As you read this I will have moved on to whatever pastures await me in my semi-retirement. I say semi because I know what tasks might be found for me at home if I do not profess to a continuing interest in the investment world.

Kiddie quits Barings to join ABN AMRO

Baring Asset Management head of equities David Kiddie has resigned from the group to become chief investment officer equities at ABN AMRO Asset Management.He will be replaced by head of global equities Tim Scholefield who joined recently from SWIP where he headed up international equities.Kiddie is expected to join the group early in 2007.He replaces […]

First State to offer Indian subcontinent fund onshore

First State is set to commence the offer period for the First State Indian subcontinent fund on November 1.The fund will be a sub fund of the First State ICVC (UK registered Oeic) and will be managed by First State senior portfolio manager, Asia Pacific ex-Japan equities, Vijay Tohani.The fund is an extension of the […]


What employers should expect over the next five years

A major feature of our articles is looking into the Jelf Employee Benefits crystal ball to predict changes and trends that may influence the short and medium term shape of UK employee benefits.  By flagging such changes early we aim to provide our followers with the tools to make sensible and informed decisions on their benefits offerings.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm