View more on these topics

Field slams Govt disarray on FSA

Prime Minister Tony Blair’s calculated attack on the FSA shows the Government lacks a coherent strategy on the regulator, claims Tory Shadow Financial Secretary to the Treasury Mark Field.

The MP for London and Westminster says Blair’s stinging speech to the Institute for Public Policy Research in May – in which he acknowledged the damaging effect the FSA is widely perceived as having on efficient businesses – contrasts with Chancellor Gordon Brown’s view of the FSA as “a beacon of regulation”.

Field says the Government needs to decide what it thinks about the FSA rather than playing to a particular crowd.

“Blair is the ultimate political chameleon but what does he deliver? It is all right to say these things and claim to be on the side of the small businessman but New Labour has always been the party of corporatist Britain,” he says.

Field says the incident shows that Blair’s spin doctors and focus groups told him what people think about the FSA and he went along with it in a speech but he has done nothing to show how the situation can be rectified.

Field and Tory Shadow Chancellor George Osborne hope to meet with FSA chairman Sir Callum McCarthy in the autumn to discuss their vision for the regulator.

Field – who was appointed as Shadow Financial Secretary in May – says he has been getting a growing number of complaints from City prof- essionals about the effectiveness of the FSA and the regulatory burden placed on small businesses.

He says: “You need to have regulation that protects the consumer but it also needs to be flexible enough to allow for innovation and new products. Time and again from small businesses, I have been hearing that FSA regulation is overbearing.”

He claims that his experience as a small businessman, running a headhunting firm in the City, has given him ins- ide knowledge of the head-aches caused by heavy-han- ded regulation.

He wants a new remit for the FSA that puts competition and competitiveness at its heart, backed up by a lighter-touch regulatory framework, especially when working with high-net-worth individuals.

Pensions is another area troubling Field. He believes the forthcoming Turner report will be a damp squib, not because it will not say anything interest- ing but because Gordon Brown is unlikely to endorse any radicial moves.

Unlike Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary Malcolm Rifkind, Field believes compulsion cannot be ruled out. He says: “As a libertarian, I am instinctively against compulsion but if it is found that the only other option is higher taxes – a worse form of compulsion – then peoplemay have to accept it.”

He says recent reports on contracting out from the FSA and Which?, showing the losses that some investors have endured, are yet another example of mistakes made in pension policy and the need for a radical solution.

Field says the current pension system is reminiscent of a pyramid sales scam with people paying into a system which is unsustainable.

He says: “One of the biggest scams is the idea you are paying for yourself. Today’s youngsters are paying for today’s pensioners but, when their time comes, they will not get the benefit. There are too many people currently retired who have not put anything like enough money into the system, yet are reaping the benefits.”


The trust belt

Our panel of industry experts analyse the uses of offshore trusts in depth

Cowan joins board of Paymentshield

John Cowan is joining the board of mortgage and protection club Paymentshield as non-executive director. Cowan, who was formerly managing director of Pivotal, the National Australia Bank group’s intermediary consultancy business, is joined on the board by former HBOS gen- eral insurance chief executive Howard Posner, who becomes a non-executive director, and First Direct chief […]

Lack of Sipp competence

Innocence is bliss, or so we are told. A Greek friend of mine, who believes that life is more straightforward than it really is reacted to his divorced friends plight by taking direct action with no regard for the reality of the situation. This is similar to many who will invest in Sipps for the first time as soon as midnight strikes on April 5 next year.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm