View more on these topics

Fee feedback

The industry must engage in discussion on fees and costs

Each year, the FSA publishes both fees policy and actual fees consultation papers. The consultation on fees policy is published in the latter half of the year and typically considers the policy theory behind fees. This paper was published in October.

The consultation on the FSA’s plan and budget and the costs to firms typically comes out in February.

The FSA’s latest consultation acknowledges Aifa’s work relating to fees, including agreement that risk-based cost allocation does indeed hold merit. The paper also acknowl-edges the need for the FSA to be more transparent in its approach and this is welcome.

However, the broad thrust of the FSA’s argument at present is that while Aifa’s ideas may hold merit, the current direct cost allocation method works well, is trans-parent and minimises cross-subsidy, at this point I am concerned that the FSA has consulted on and provided evidence which I feel is directly to the contrary.

The consultation proposes merging the A12 and A13 fee classes and adding a new “client money and assets” fee class to those with such exposure. The concern that Aifa has with the proposals is that we are not comparing two like for like businesses.

First, of the 100,000 or so advisers within the two fee blocks, less than half fall into the IFA/stockbroking scope. This seems like a very broad group, considering the FSA believes that cross-subsidisation is undesirable.

Second, the FSA is adamant that it also bills back the cost of regulation to those firms that create the work. This is the underlying principle of a direct-cost allocation. Direct-cost allocation only works if you accurately allocate costs.

The FSA is explicit that this must include a minimisation of cross-subsidy. But if you took the cost of the FSA and divided it among all fee-payers equally, IFAs would be subsidising Basel III while Lloyds members would be subsidising the RDR.

This is where I have a fund-amental problem with the FSA’s current fees consul-tation. The FSA insists that the cost of regulation is currently being directly billed back to firms. Firms in A12 currently pay an additional risk prem-ium because they are holding clients’ money. However, this cost is less than for firms in A13. Therefore, the cost of regulating these two groups must be different if the FSA is doing as it states and charging firms according to the cost of regulating them.

The alternative, of course, is that the FSA does not curr-ently allocate the cost of regul-ation to these classes accurately.

Assuming that the FSA does believe costs are correctly allocated to fee blocks, the only conclusion we are left with is that the FSA wants to introduce an element of cross-subsidisation within the new combined A12/13 class.

It is time for the FSA and then the Consumer Protection and Markets Authority engage the wider industry in a discussion on how costs are allocated. I simply do not believe that risk-based fees are “too difficult” for a regulator of 3,500 people.

Andrew Strange is director of policy at Aifa


Matrix hires Gartmore’s Angus Woolhouse as chief executive

Angus Woolhouse, the former head of institutional business at Gartmore, has taken over the role of chief executive officer at Matrix Asset Management. Woolhouse will oversee a product range, which includes funds of funds, hedge funds, Ucits funds, cash funds, private equity, venture capital trusts and specialised finance. Matrix’s client base ranges from institutions through […]

Moneygate plans MBO

Moneygate Group has confirmed that it has secured new funding in a bid to buy out investment partners, MGT Capital Investments. Moneygate says it has strengthened its position after MGT underwent a restructuring programme that has seen the firm take on new investment and make some changes to its US board. Moneygate CEO Lee Hartley […]


Hoban defends “democratic deficit” between Parliament and FSA

Treasury financial secretary Mark Hoban (pictured) has defended the “democratic deficit” that exists between Parliament and the FSA. At a Treasury select committee today, committee member and Labour MP George Mudie asked Hoban whether he is worried with the suggestion that the regulator ignores Parliament and the financial services industry on regulatory issues. Mudie referenced […]

Aegon boosts lifetime income plan

Aegon has made enhancements to its unit-linked guarantee product, Aegon Secure Lifetime Income, including a guaranteed minimum annual increase of 3.25 per cent to the income base for new customers. New ASLI customers who are not yet taking income will receive the annual boost regardless of the underlying investment performance. Aegon says, in addition, the […]

How to use wills to protect your clients’ wishes

March was Free Wills Month! Free Wills Month brings together a group of well-respected charities to offer members of the public aged 55 and over the opportunity to have their simple wills written or updated free of charge by using participating solicitors in selected locations around England and Wales. Research by the Law Society* highlighted that only 64 […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm