View more on these topics

FCA ‘misdirected’ over Sipp cash margin probe

FCA logo new 2 620x430

FCA plans to force Sipp firms to include the margin they earn on cash accounts as charges are “misdirected”, say firms.

Last week the FCA gave the Sipp industry six months to include the interest retained on cash accounts in projections, effect of charges tables and reduction-in-yield measures.

In September, Money Marketing revealed how the tens of millions providers earn a year from margins on cash was the only thing keeping some firms in business.

But Dentons technical services director Martin Tilley says: “The FCA’s interest in the Sipp trail interest is warranted but misdirected.

“The consultation looks at any trail being a ‘charge’ and the FCA’s focus is on charges. Whereas in fact what the consumer needs to know is what return the default cash account is going to pay.”

Tilley says labelling the margin taken as a charge risks misleading customers because firms may retain more because they have negotiated better rates than other providers.

A director at one of the largest providers – who wished to remain anonymous – agrees including margin as a charge would not help customers.

He says: “This only makes illustrations more complex for providers, adviser and customers. There’s a wider question that needs to be answered – are current illustrations even appropriate comparisons for complex products like Sipps?”

But Liberty Sipp sales and marketing director Matthew Rankine says: “For too long, too many Sipp providers have been quietly pocketing the interest earned on their clients’ money – and burying the practice in the fee schedule.”



MM leader: The stealth margin grab by Sipp providers

For Sipp providers, while all eyes have been on the looming changes to capital adequacy rules, another storm has been quietly brewing. Sipp providers negotiate the rates paid on cash held within the wrapper and then offer an interest rate to clients. However there is not always a clear line of sight between what deals […]


End of the line for the Sipp cash gravy train

Rapidly disappearing returns on cash could end up costing the Sipp industry hundreds of millions of pounds and see up to half of bespoke providers closing. Firms are already under pressure from the new capital adequacy regime, falling new business, cuts to higher earners’ annual allowance and the possibility the tax relief system will be […]


Sipp firms split over insistent clients

The Sipp market is split over how to deal with so-called insistent clients who want to transfer out of defined benefit schemes. Despite FCA guidance published in June, advisers and providers remain concerned over the potential for future claims on pension transfers. According to data collected by the regulator as part of the Treasury’s probe […]

Martin Tilley 200

Martin Tilley: What happens when the Sipp lifeboats are full?

The FCA’s third thematic review of Sipp operators and the increase in the benchmark for capital adequacy requirements have reduced the appetite and ability for some in the marketplace to continue in the long-term. The introduction of the tapering annual allowance from April next year is also likely to have an impact on new contributions […]

The FCA’s five fixes for retirement information

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has started to change the way that people will be told about their pension options. In a recent market study paper, they lay out their final proposals on the information that should be delivered to people approaching retirement and how it should look and feel. During 2015, there will be […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment