View more on these topics

Investor blames FCA for losses after mini-bond firm collapse

Portfolio-Performance-Investment-UK-Bonds-700x450.jpgA complainant who says the FCA’s investigation into mini bond provider London Capital & Finance unnecessarily caused its inevitable collapse has had their review into the case quashed.

The complainant alleges the FCA’s moves against LC&F caused the loss of their investment in mini-bonds with the now-collapsed provider.

A total 11,500 investors lost £237m after LC&F fell into default in January.

This came a month after the regulator issued it with an order to take down promotional material of the bonds, ruling they were “misleading, not fair, and unclear.”

The complainant says LC&F should have continued to operate and the FCA launched its official investigation in the knowledge that the probe would cause the provider’s collapse.

Instead, the regulator should have worked with LC&F to resolve its problems, the investor complainant says.

The FCA argues it deferred its review of the complainant’s February claims as its own investigation of LC&F was still active.

The regulator says: “We are generally only able to begin investigating a complaint after any ongoing action is finished.”

FCA to be investigated over supervision of failed mini-bond firm

In a final report, Complaints Commissioner Anthony Townsend says the regulator is within its rights to defer the complaint until it has concluded its own investigation into the mini-bond provider.

Townsend says the FCA sent “considerable information” to the complainant regarding its actions to secure LC&F’s assets.

The FCA also sent its public communications as to why the provider was under investigation, including a link to its supervisory notice on the issue.

Townsend says: “Although I am not in a position to make a judgement about the FCA’s actions in this particular matter, it is not unusual in cases of this nature for the regulator to have to make difficult decisions about how to protect the interests of both existing and future clients of a firm.

“Those interests may not be the same.

“I recognise that what you are seeking is a declaration that the FCA’s actions have caused your losses, but I am afraid that question will have to wait until your complaint is considered when the deferral ends.”

FSCS apologises for misleading clients of collpased mini-bond firm

Townsend confirmed the FCA’s initial decision to defer the complaint would be upheld.

The FCA has also agreed to the recommendation to review the complaint every six months.

Townsend says: “It is unfortunate that that some investigations take a considerable period to conclude and for that reason, I consider that the FCA should undertake to review the federal of your complaint every six months so that they can begin to deal with it at the earliest opportunity.”

The collapse of LC&F has garnered significant interest in the effectiveness of rules to protect retail investors.

In response to this, the FCA confirmed last month that it would commission an investigation into its own supervision of the case to confirm whether existing regulation of mini-bonds do protect investors adequately.


Kelly Prior: What’s your fixed income outlook?

What does the outlook for fixed income look like for the rest of the year? It was a sobering start to the year for fixed income, and we observed a more divided set of opinions than we have seen for a long time. Aside from the brief wobble in the last week in December, which […]

Profile: There’s no silver bullet to boost gender diversity on boards

Broadstone chief commercial officer on achieving a better gender balance on the boards of financial services firms Just a few months into her role as chief commercial officer at pensions and employee benefits adviser Broadstone, Natasha Glasgow is learning fast. With a direct-to-consumer background focusing on customer experience, setting up back-office systems and working in […]


Tim Sargisson: Bad practice needs calling out more than ever

Speaking at the recent Money Marketing Interactive conference, FCA co-director of life insurance and financial advice supervision Debbie Gupta highlighted a major concern for the regulator, which is advisers’ failure to call out bad practice. As she pointed out: “We need a common understanding on both sides that we are in fact on the same […]

Insurance File Generic 480

Trust me, I’m a provider

By Craig Paterson, Underwriting and Claims Philosophy Manager, Royal London Hard-hitting headlines “Dying mother of two is refused life insurance payout.”1 “What a way to treat a dying man: Grandfather refused life insurance claim.”2 “A widow betrayed by a life insurance company.”3 With headlines like these, it’s no wonder some consumers don’t trust providers. Trust […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 3 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. “A complainant who says the FCA’s investigation into mini bond provider London Capital & Finance unnecessarily caused its inevitable collapse has had their review into the case quashed.”

    The review has been deferred, not quashed… though that is the likely outcome of any suggestion of fault on the part of the FCA!

    • Julian Stevens 8th May 2019 at 2:57 pm

      Given that the FCA has been allowed to choose the body that will be investigating its own failings, that seems the most probable outcome.

  2. David Bennett 8th May 2019 at 8:30 pm

    Not clear in what way the FCA could have ‘worked with’ LC&F which would not have put additional investors at risk.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm