View more on these topics

FCA levels playing field for investment trusts with Mifid II decision


The Association of Investment Companies has welcomed the FCA’s decision not to consider investment company shares to be automatically “complex” under Mifid II.

The AIC says the suggestion that investment trusts should fall under this definition had put them at a competitive disadvantage to other investment products.

Retail investors in complex products must be assessed for “knowledge and understanding” by distributing firms if they are buying them without advice.

But the FCA says: “Our view of the Mifid II provisions on complex and non-complex financial instruments is that, as in Mifid, Non-Ucits Retail Schemes and investment trusts are neither automatically non-complex nor automatically complex.

Its view was published in its consultation paper on Mifid II – its third on the directive – which was printed on Thursday.

The consultation document says: “They need to be assessed against the criteria in the Mifid II delegated regulation. When firms apply these criteria, they should adopt a cautious approach if there is any doubt as to whether a financial instrument is non-complex.”

Ordinary shares of investment companies are currently not considered complex.

The AIC says defining investment company shares as automatically complex risked “disrupting the market” and did not favour competition.

AIC chief executive Ian Sayers says: “This is a very welcome announcement by the FCA. The AIC has consistently argued that the view that investment company shares should be treated as ‘automatically complex’ was incorrect legally, as well as wrong in principle.

“Allowing products to be tested consistently against common criteria creates a level playing field and will mean that virtually all investment company shares will continue to be treated as non-complex.  We will continue to work with the FCA to ensure that this position is adopted after the consultation.”



FCA plans to tighten investment research payments under Mifid II

The FCA has proposed to ban independent advisers and portfolio managers from accepting payments from third party firms on investment research. According to the third FCA Mifid II consultation paper, published today, only certain research products such as commentary on market moves or company results may be exempt as “minor” and “non-monetary.” Mifid II will […]


European Commission U-turns on Mifid II unbundling rules

The European Commission has U-turned on rules around unbundling research and trading costs under Mifid II regulation, according to reports. A document from the European Commission has proposed more relaxed rules around commission sharing agreements, which were previously going to be banned in favour of full unbundling of costs, reports Reuters. European regulators had previously […]


Tisa: Asset managers unaware of Mifid II impact

The implementation of Mifid II could result in “unintended consequences” by reducing investment and provider choice for consumers, says the Tax Incentivised Savings Association. Tisa, the not-for-profit membership association, warns that many asset managers, distributors, wealth managers, life and pensions companies, and firms for whom D2C is important are unaware of the implications of Mifid II. In […]


Nic Cicutti: Tragedy of Govt’s new advice definition

What is regulated financial advice? If you believe the Treasury, the definition of advice should be restricted “so that consumers only receive ‘regulated advice’ when they are offered a personal recommendation for a specific product.” Last week it issued a consultation document proposing to amend the wording of what constitutes regulated advice to align it […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment