View more on these topics

FCA hits back at Govt interference claims

Tracey McDermott FCA 700x450.jpg

The FCA has dismissed claims its independence from Government has been compromised and defends its approach to the scrapped review into banking culture.

Both the regulator and Government have come under fire following the decision to close the inquiry into bank culture in favour of dealing with firms individually.

But at a Treasury committee meeting today, FCA chairman John Griffith-Jones flatly denied claims the regulator was lent on to drop the probe.

When asked by chairman Andrew Tyrie whether independence had been compromised or if specific decisions had been called into question he said: “The answer is no to both. In general I don’t feel pressure and certainly on specific operational decisions – particulary enforcement – clearly not.”

Griffith-Jones and acting chief executive Tracey McDermott also defended the handling around the communication of the decision to close the inquiry.

In December 2014 the Davis Review criticised the response to a botched media briefing that sent insurers’ share prices tumbling.

But McDermott said the decision to drop the review was not market sensitive.

She said: “There was nothing secret about the decision to drop the review. We communicated with the banks, with our panels and with one of your colleagues [Mark Garnier MP], the Banking Standards Board, British Bankers Association, there was nothing secret about it it was simply an operational decision.”

She added: “I do not believe there is any market sensitivity that the review is being scrapped. I don’t think there’s been any market reaction. In terms of public interest, clearly because of the amount of attention to this over the last couple of weeks it would be difficult to say there was not a public interest. That’s why we will need to consider whether or not wecommunicate differently.”

McDermott stressed dropping the inquiry did not mean the regulator was changing its approach to improving banking culture.

Griffith-Jones added chief executive terms should be increased from three to five years. Former chief executive Martin Wheatley was ousted by the Chancellor at end of his term in September last year.

Griffith-Jones admitted morale was down at the regulator following Wheatley’s departure. An independent review into the FCA board published last week said staff were affected by public criticism.



Osborne hands FCA duty to cap ‘excessive’ exit fees

Chancellor George Osborne has told the FCA to cap “excessive” pension exit fees. Speaking in the House of Commons, Osborne said while the pension freedoms had been welcomed by savers, the Government remains concerned that roughly 700,000 people face early exit penalties if they move their savings. Osborne said: “The Government isn’t prepared to stand […]

FCA logo glass 2 620x430

Independent review warns of Govt influence on FCA

An independent review of the FCA board has warned the FCA board’s powers are “limited” and questions the regulator’s independence from government. The report follows claims the regulator dropped a review into banking culture after the Bank of England intervened. In its report, commissioned last summer and published yesterday, Boardroom Review Limited says: “Although constituted […]


‘Rudderless’: Lack of leadership breeds uncertainty at the FCA

Fears are rising that the FCA has been left “rudderless” by a protracted search for new leadership as the regulator runs out of time to finalise its 2016/17 plans. Chancellor George Osborne revealed last week, six months after he announced Martin Wheatley’s contract would not be renewed, that acting chief executive Tracey McDermott would not seek […]


FCA investigates copycat Pension Wise website

A fake Pension Wise website that purports to be a subsidiary of auto-enrolment provider The People’s Pension is being looked into by the Treasury and FCA. – which uses the Tripadviser owl logo – claims to be a Qrops and Sipp provider but also contains detailed information about the Government’s guidance service Pension Wise […]


Case study: administration — managing group life schemes

Our client leads the global market in high-tech electronics manufacturing and digital media. The trustees of the company’s final salary pension scheme insure death-in-service lump sum and dependants’ pension death benefits for active employees, as well as dependants’ pension benefits for deferred members (those who have left service).


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 5 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Methinks they dost protest too much….

    And anyway, no regulator should be totally independent of the government. It’s because the government has allowed the FCA and all its predecessors free rein, i.e. an open licence to do whatever the hell it wants (which it clearly has), that the industry’s in such a tangle and those of lesser means are unable to access advice at a price they can afford. Next thing we know, the FCA will be trying to persuade us that the FAMR was its idea and nothing to with the Treasury.

  2. So George hasn’t just told the FCA to deal with exit fees on pensions? Sounds like interference to me folk!

  3. Yeah Right…..!!! Who does she think she’s kidding? Not Mr Wheatley I’ll bet.

  4. The fact that the FCA is facing a parliamentary debate of no confidence is in itself extraordinary.

    Yesterday’s appearance in front of the TSC was very grim. Libertatem was mentioned for its expertise. The issues the FCA faces all emanate from the same place. Its lack of accountability.

    We all have bosses. They may be our customers, shareholders, boards etc.,

    The FCA reports to no one officially but is heavily influenced by the Treasury who pretend that they have no influence and take no responsibility for their actions.

    This allows the banks to influence the Treasury who influences the FCA. This is why there is a de-facto 2 tier system

    This debate is great news. Expect FCA Chairman to resign before this debate. Libertatem was instrumental in the questioning of the FCA yesterday and will be ensuing the maximum attendance and handing out ammunition to MPs.

    I need Advisers who have good contacts with their MPs to contact me now

    Advisers need to know that this is proof positive that well designed representation works. Libertatem is having an effect and needs advisers’ support. Stop telling me it doesn’t work – if we unite we will win a better system for our clients and ourselves

    Join us Fund us

  5. There are two very important words in this whole debate, Governance & Influence

    It is absolutely right the treasury should be governing the FCA, however, as we are abundantly clear the is a huge amount of influence forced on the FCA by the treasury, and there is the issue, and its wrong !

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers. Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm