View more on these topics

FCA crowdfunding ‘loophole’ exposed

A regulatory loophole has emerged which could allow retail investors to circumvent FCA rules requiring crowdfunding investors to be classed as sophisticated. 

The FCA’s final rules on crowdfunding, published last week, stated investment-based crowdfunding can only be promoted to sophisticated or high net worth investors, retail clients who are advised or non-advised clients who are investing only 10 per cent or less of their net investible assets.

But when an investor “self-certifies” themselves as sophisticated, they have to meet only one of the four following criteria: that they have been a member of a network or syndicate of business angels for at least six months; they have made more than one investment in an unlisted company; they are working or have worked in private equity or SME finance or they are, or have been, a director of a company with an annual turnover of at least £1m.

In theory, retail investors making two £50 crowdfunding investments can self-certify as sophisticated when they come to invest again. 

Using one crowdfunding platform, Money Marketing sister title Fundweb found that registering with a platform, passing a suitability quiz, entering bank details and completing an investment can be done in as little as four minutes.

An FCA spokesman says: “The 10 per cent rule means inexperienced investors will have to limit how much they can invest, making clear the risks involved.

 “If an investor gains sufficient experience, they can self-certify as sophisticated and, to do so, will be acknowledging they understand and accept the risks.”

Chelsea Financial Services managing director Darius McDermott says: “This looks like a loophole. If the FCA’s intention was for unsophisticated investors not to have too much exposure then the regulator should look at this.”


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There are 4 comments at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Next they’ll be making everyone who buys a lottery ticket sign a disclaimer! After all they could lose all the money they invest in that?

  2. Before long I assume the FCA will ban investment which has any element of risk which isn’t insured.

    We will all only be allowed to purchase products which are written as insurance policies, in order to mitigate risk, and will have fixed sums to be returned at maturity. Because these fixed sums will be low to allow the insurance company to guarantee them there will also be a mechanism where some of the profits which accrue from the investments can be allocated to investors, allowing them to participate in the profits of the fund.

    I wonder whether that could work – sounds like a regulators dream.

  3. Good idea John, they could also include a special clause that would protect the insurance company if the markets took a dramatic unexpected downturn?

  4. Am I allowed to lend my brother £25? – its all so confusing.

Leave a comment