View more on these topics

Fast track

An increased focus on fund management charges could see the UK follow in the footsteps of the US, which has seen a surge in low-cost trackers. Gregor Watt reports

The past few years have seen a switch away from the age- old debate about differing performance between active and passive investing to concerns about the difference in costs.

The retail distribution review and its focus on the total cost to the client and, by extension, on the cost of the whole investment process, including that of advice, have been predicted to drive a sharp increase in the use of low-cost investment strategies, ranging from more use of traditional tracker funds, to the rise of exchange traded funds and the launch of a new breed of passive-plus funds, from managers such as JP Morgan Asset Management and Schroders.

In addition, we have seen the launch of several fund managers who put cost – and its impact on investment returns – at the centre of their marketing strategy. Terry Smith’s new investment management business Fundsmith is making a considerable effort to push the low-cost message, as is SCM Private, run by former New Star chief investment officer Alan Miller.

In January, Miller and co-founder of SCM Private Gina Miller established the True and Fair campaign to highlight the use of opaque charging structures.

They have since been engaged in a skirmish with the Investment Management Association over transparency of charges and the excessive level of charges once issues such as dealing costs are factored in. The campaign is now pushing for an online comparison service to help consumers compare the full costs of different funds.

The FSA has also got in on the act. In March, FSA head of investments policy Peter Smith raised the issue of why fund management fees are so high and said this was something the regulator is keeping an eye on.

Smith says: “In what is allegedly a competitive industry, the UK fund market, how is it that the average cost of funds has risen over the years rather than fallen? That is something we are going to be thinking about.”

Although the FSA has no powers to intervene in individual commercial decisions regarding management costs, the IMA has found itself repeatedly having to defend both the level of charges levied by fund managers and their transparency.

The argument has some way to run but it seems the attention on the cost of fund management is having an impact on the selection of investment funds.

Defaqto recently launched a guide to choosing between active and passive funds and the company says it expects to see an increase in the use of passives.

Senior consultant Adrian Gaspar says: “Passive investing has certainly been a theme that has gained momentum in the UK. Passive investing in retail funds in the UK has not gained as much traction as in the US. However, the RDR is likely to result in a level playing field in this regard.”

According to Alliance Trust Savings, the attention on costs had an impact on the top sellers on its platform in the run-up to the end of the tax year.

The company says four out of the top five best-selling funds across its Isa, Sipp and dealing accounts were passive funds. Most popular was the Vanguard FTSE UK equity index fund, followed by Legal & General UK index trust, the Vanguard FTSE developed world excluding UK equity index fund and the Vanguard US equity index fund. The last fund to round out the top five was the M&G strategic corporate bond fund, the only fund to have an annual management charge of more than 0.4 per cent.

Alliance Trust Savings marketing director Garry McLuckie says: “Clients and advisers obviously see the benefit of tracker funds as part of a balanced portfolio. With low AMCs, we expect the appetite for these funds to continue to grow strongly.”

The IMA retail sales figures for 2011 also show a sharp increase in sales of passive funds, with £1.9bn of fund inflows to tracker funds. But despite being the highest level of tracker fund sales since 2003, this was still just 8 per cent of all new retail fund sales for the year and, in total, tracker funds account for only 6.8 per cent of retail funds under management.

If the US example holds true, the UK has some ground to make up. According to Morningstar, consistent growth of sales of low-cost passive funds mean these now account for more than 14 per cent of the US retail investment market.


Investec puts fixed-income bond range on the defensive

Investec head of fixed income John Stopford has moved to a more defensive position across the £18.7bn fixed-income bond range as his expectations for global growth weaken. Stopford says the chances of improved global growth and additional monetary stimulus in the US and Europe are fading. He says: “We have been reducing risk as we […]

McGee returns to Intelliflo for provider and client role

Intelliflo has appointed Kieran McGee to the new role of provider and client consultant. McGee will be responsible for working with providers and on existing integrations with third parties. He returns to Intelliflo after two years with Focus, where he was product manager. Intelliflo head of account management Neil Andrews says: “We are very pleased […]

Connaught Ucis investors miss interest payments

Connaught Asset Management has contacted investors in one of its funds to notify them they will not receive their latest interest payments on time. On March 7, Connaught, which is not regulated by the FSA, decided to suspend income fund series one while it commissioned a review into the true value of the fund and […]

GBST UK head Wilkinson takes director role at IFDS

GBST Wealth Management head of UK business Ian Wilkinson is joining technology firm International Financial Data Services as director of platform technology. Wilkinson has been with wrap technology provider GBST since March 2007. GBST provides the technology behind the Novia, AJ Bell, JP Morgan and Aegon Retirement Choices platforms. GBST chief executive Rob DeDominicis says: […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm