View more on these topics

EU financial services regulation under the microscope

Wealth Management Association deputy chief executive John Barrass assesses the implications of the Treasury’s ‘balance of competences’ review.

After May’s European elections, we’re currently experiencing a hiatus in our day-to-day dealings with Brussels. The EU Parliament may have approved Jean Claude Juncker’s nomination to head up the EU Commission, but it is not until late August that we will see any progress on which commissioners are going to be assigned which portfolios.

Most MEPs, like UK politicians, are now on their summer holidays – even the Council is in recess. However, even while Brussels and Strasbourg have quiet periods, the relationship between the UK and Europe continues to come under the regulatory microscope.

The latest comes from HM Treasury and the much-anticipated Balance of Competences review, this time on financial services and the free movement of capital.

Given the huge regulatory changes in recent years – including the likes of Mifid, CRD IV, PRIIPs, AIFMD and CSDR – and the significant impact they have had, not only on the City of London, but on firms across the UK, what does the latest review tell us about retail financial services?

First and foremost, and something we tend to agree with at the WMA, is the fact that the single market provides significant benefits to the UK consumer. Bigger markets do provide new and exciting opportunities for the ordinary retail investor.

Opportunity for growth and enhancing our prosperity is something we all should welcome. The issue we have is when harmonising the rules for these markets not only complicates such opportunities, but in fact prevents them from happening in the first place.

When EU policymakers and regulators create new legislation, understanding of unique differences are not always apparent, particularly when it comes to the UK retail financial services model.

A point that we continue to stress is the fact that retail markets remain inherently local. The EU may have evolved so that wholesale institutions have established branches or subsidiaries in other EU nations, but the fact is, our sector simply doesn’t work like this.

Not only are the UK and Irish retail markets different to what we define as the European bancassurance model, but in practice it is extremely unlikely that an Italian investor in Milan would deal with a wealth manager in Manchester.

Not that they can’t, but it is simply a fact that they don’t and are highly unlikely to. Retail consumers tend to purchase financial services from local advisers and long-established firms. We simply cannot have ‘one-size-fits-all’ legislation in this area because the investment cultures differ to widely between different member states.

Another issue highlighted by the paper is the pace of change. As I mentioned earlier, there are several pieces of legislation that have and will fundamentally alter the retail financial services landscape.

We need to ensure that all member states appropriately implement these rules in the first place, rather than making new proposals to cover for poor implementation. It will take several years to see this impact. However, we will only know what this is, and where further work may be necessary to augment, revise or reduce the level and type of regulation achieved, by careful monitoring over a period of time.

If this means that no future policies are devised over the next Parliament then so be it. It is much better to get things right the first time around, as opposed to spending valuable legislative time making up for earlier mistakes.

There will no doubt be a difference of opinion between in the wealth management sector compared to say the banking and wholesale market. We operate differently and the way we interact with our clients is different too, but that is not to say the EU cannot differentiate between diverse markets when devising laws.

There are many areas in EU law that work in this way, particularly around consumer protection. However, there are areas that simply do not.

The Balance of Competences is an important paper in assessing Britain’s relationship with the EU and will hopefully be on the reading list for many of our new MEPs on their summer holidays.

John Barrass is the deputy chief executive of the Wealth Management Association   



US banks prepare for UK exit from EU

US banks are drawing up plans to move some of their London-based activities to Ireland over concerns the UK is drifting apart from the EU. The Financial Times reports that according to people familiar with Bank of America, Citigroup and Morgan Stanley, Ireland is considered a favourable location should they need to move some of […]


Which? calls for national savings strategy

Which? is calling on the Government, employers and the financial services industry to develop a national strategy to boost savings levels. In a new report, the consumer group says just 41 per cent of people have savings equal to 3 months essential expenditure – the figure recommended by Government. It also found 24 per cent […]


FSCS declares 28 firms in default

The FSCS has declared 24 investment firms and 4 life and pensions firms in default.  A firm is declared in default when the FSCS believes it cannot pay claims for compensation. 20Twenty, a firm forced to fold last year after losing a £2.6m FOS claim, has been included on the list.  The FSCS list also […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm