View more on these topics

Equal rites

This year is likely to see a rise in discrimination claims after some interesting developments in this area of the law.

Last month, I looked at the crucial distinction between employed and self-employed status and the perils of getting it wrong, such as unexpected tribunal claims or tax demands. Provided you get the facts straight, however, it is often fairly easy to get it right.

In contrast, discrimination law is a field which has very wide application indeed. Race and sex discrimination laws have been in force for over 30 years but the number of claims is still increasing. There have been a host of recent additions to the law, such as discrimination on the grounds of religion, belief, sexual orientation and age.

Discrimination law covers anyone who is personally contracted to undertake work, including independent contracts, and not just those who come under the strict terms of an employment relationship in the narrow sense that we might expect.

It also applies to a wide circle of possibilities. It can occur before employment, for example, in advertisements or at interview stage, during the period of engagement, whether at work or away from the office, and even after employment has come to an end, such as in the provision of references.

There are no length of service requirements, unlike for unfair dismissal where the employee has to be employed for a year to claim. Unlike the cap on compensation awards for unfair dismissal, redress is unlimited.

A significant feature of discrimination law is that it is not only the employer who can pick up the tab for a discrimination complaint but the individual who is accused of discrimination can find themselves being sued personally. This is probably the most under-appreciated aspect of discrimination law.

If a discriminatory act occurs in the course of employment, an employer can find itself responsible for acts of which it was unaware, unless it has done everything that is reasonable to prevent discrimination occurring in the first place. How many text messages or emails are being sent from your workplace of which you are completely unaware? Have staff been told what is and what is not acceptable behaviour?

The Sex Discrimination Act has been amended to make employers liable for discrimination perpetrated by third parties, such as clients and contractors, unless they did all they reasonably could to prevent discrimination happening. This amendment will have effect from April this year.

Obvious examples of spreading this awareness are providing staff with training, having proper equal opportunities policies in place and making sure they are implemented properly. You should also make sure that visitors abide by your rules.

I could not tell you the number of times I have heard people say there is a policy about this somewhere on their hard drive but they are not sure where and have never even opened the document. Even those at the senior end of the firm or, worse, the HR department, may be guilty of this.

There is now a new breed of discrimination called associative discrimination following on from an opinion put forward by the Advocate General although this is subject to confirmation by the European Court of Justice.

In a case that was heard towards the end of 2006, a secretary at a law firm (ironically, lawyers are seeing their own practices getting sued on a rapidly increasing basis) sued her employer over its attitude to her need for time off to care for her disabled son. She complained that the firm was not receptive to her requests for time off, often rather unexpectedly, to deal with problems involving her child.

The question was, while she was not herself disabled within the ambit of the legislation, could she claim that she was being discriminated against because of her disabled child? The indication from Europe is that the answer is yes.

Acts of unintended discrimination can often take place by email banter. Remember that all aspects of conduct are relevant for the purposes of discrimination law. Discrimination is in the eye of the beholder. In other words, it must be looked at from the complainant’s perspective, which can result in ill-advised texts or emails becoming discriminatory.

Any conduct that takes place more than once, and which causes anxiety or distress, can result in a protection from harassment complaint which can be brought up to six years after the event took place.

Clearly, an element of common sense and discretion is needed by all concerned but it is worthwhile for everybody to increase their levels of self-awareness in this complex and costly area.

James Tait is an associate at solicitor Shakespeare Putsman


Woodbridge warns of hidden danger in structured pricing

Chelsea Financial Services adviser Matthew Woodbridge is warning advisers to be aware of the effect of intra-day strike prices on structured products during volatile markets.Woodbridge says not all advisers are aware that the performance of structured products is often based on intra-day pricing rather than the closing price of an index or stocks.He says this […]

Dancing on Isa

Market turbulence has added an extra degree of difficulty for advisers and investors who have been looking at last-minute Isa deals.

Positive moves

It is a cause of some delight when there is some light in all the doom and gloom. In Scotland, they are forecasting a 14 per cent rise in house prices so the crisis is not being felt so acutely as in other parts of the UK.


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm