View more on these topics

Emma Simon: Are star managers starting to lose their shine?

The rise in DIY investing will mean more investors having to undertake their own research and this could see star managers lose some of their attraction.


Are star fund managers starting to lose their allure? You might not think so, given the number of column inches devoted to Neil Woodford’s decision to quit Invesco Perpetual and launch a new equity income fund with Oakley Capital.

But I wonder whether more seismic market movements might be dimming their lights within the investment firmament?

One of the consequences of the RDR has been a new wave of DIY investors. I think there is already clear evidence that far more ordinary consumers – the so-called mass affluent – are starting to take control of their own Isa and Sipp portfolios.

Many of these are happy picking which funds or ETFs to invest in. This will hopefully lead to more people undertaking their own research about the fundamentals of investment, and having a greater understanding of where their money is going. This does not mean these decisions will always pay off – there will still be “bubbles” and those investing in funds that turn out to be stinkers. But I think this process will mean there is less of a reliance on “star names”.

I think this is reflected in the way investment issues are now covered – by the press and even in the information investment houses put out themselves. Today one of the key issues is cost: whether it is fund management charges or platform fees. (And star fund managers are rarely cheap). There is also more emphasis on risk, and how investors can manage this by building a balanced portfolio.

This is in stark contrast to a decade ago, where much of the coverage on investment markets – and Peps and Isas in particular – focused around the cult of the star manager. 

Then there were countless profiles of such luminaries as Neil Woodford, Anthony Bolton, William Littlewood, Brian Ashford-Russell, Roger Guy, Bill Mott and so on. There were articles trying to identify “the next big name” as well as the inevitable think piece explaining why a key star manager had spectacularly under-performed over a particular period. The answer, if I remember rightly, was usually that they had bought the wrong stocks. Alhough this was invariably couched in more complex explanations involving “cyclical readjustments”, “alpha co-efficient” and “favoured more of a bottom-up approach”.

I don’t mean to sound trite. There is a serious point in this. For starters, if you look along that list of names, it occurs to me that most of these managers did not have similar success when they moved on to other funds or companies. This may have undermined the notion that there are champion stock pickers out there who can beat the odds. 

More recently other names have come to the fore, but I don’t think many have quite the reputation of these former big beasts.

And as those excuses show, even the best fund managers cannot beat the market all of the time. Now, I know there will be a number of you now muttering as you read this: “Well of course they bloody can’t. What on earth do you expect!”

But I think, in the past, many investors did expect this. Or at the very least expected them to beat the market the vast majority of the time. A month or two off the boil was probably tolerated, a year or more most definitely not.

Does this undermine the role of advisers? I don’t think so. Fewer may need advice on which fund to pick for this year’s Isa. But people will still need help with the nuts and bolts of financial planning. 

And the star fund manager is unlikely to burn out completely. Many of these DIY investors will no doubt build core holdings of low-cost passive funds.

The star fund manager may be relegated to a satellite position for more daring investors, where they will hopefully defy gravity for a few years at least, helping boost overall returns.

Emma Simon is a freelance journalist



Cofunds eyes adding protection to its platform

Cofunds is looking at launching protection products onto the platform in a move which could see the creation of an investment-linked protection range. The company says it is considering a number of options to add protection on the platform, which could include investment-linked protection or a wider range of protection products. A spokeswoman says: “We are […]


Nic Cicutti: Heading towards the next financial scandal

When I first ventured into the world of personal pensions I was a naive 30-something journalist – a condition some readers might feel has not changed greatly, despite my advancing years. Be that as it may, our profession is meant to consist of cynical swine. Moreover, by the time I started paying into my first […]


Countrywide chief Grenville Turner to step down

Countrywide chief executive Granville Turner is to step down this year and will become non-executive chairman when a replacement is found. The move, announced as the property group posted its 2013 results this morning, will see interim chairman David Watson become deputy chairman and senior independent director. The board is also looking for two more […]


Standard Life expected to warn of cost of independent Scotland

Standard Life has been tipped to say an independent Scotland would threaten its business when it announces its annual results next week. A report in The Telegraph says the insurer and asset manager is concerned that an independent Scotland would be a particular risk for its £97bn pensions business if it were to lose the […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. Star Managers have nothing to do with “Investing” – Random Walk theory is still alive and well. Star Managers appeal to that market segment of investors that see value in having an “expert” manage their funds. It is purely a psychological issue. Most people know deep down that you can’t really expect to beat “The Market” but some will themselves to believe that research ( tea leaf reading) and an expert mean that they will do what they know can’t be done. The ability to believe what you want to believe allows us to sleep at night knowing that we are right and the other fellow is wrong. There will always be a market for high priced star mangers and there will always be DIY investors.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm