View more on these topics

Ebenezer Scrooge

Entering the office of London-based IFA Scrooge & Marley, you find co-founder Ebenezer Scrooge sitting at his tall desk, quill in hand, reconciling commission payments.

Scrooge, on first impression, looks every bit the general public&#39s impression of a miser. But a closer examination of his life story reveals that it is the regulator which has made him this way. Harried over the misselling of pensions he never missold, accused of misselling split-caps even though he was only following guidelines from the FSA website – a life of regulatory harassment has given him the worn profile of a man who over the years has paid too much in compensation and professional indemnity cover.

Scrooge&#39s reputation precedes him. Branded a tight-fisted old boy, a squeezing, wrenching, grasping, scraping, clutching, covetous old sinner, he got that way protecting his clients&#39 interests and it has hardened his soul. It is said that no client ever stopped him in the street with gladsome looks to say: “My dear Scrooge, how are you?” No low-income earners implored him to bestow a trifle of free advice. No network salesmen inquired how fared his compliance.

It is also said that Scrooge liked it that way. It had some advantages as Tep providers walked past old Scrooge without trying to foist a policy on him or his clients.

But Scrooge explains how he has now changed. “I did get a reputation for being a penny-pincher in the old days. It all grew out of me trying to save money for my clients.

“They loved me to be tight with their money and I got meaner and meaner and meaner. My tightness became so well known that in two years I received job offers off every major network and even the regulator. But all that changed last night. It was a revelation, I tell you. There I was minding my own business when I was visited by three spectres. Well, you can just imagine my surprise. Would you believe it, they warned me to change my ways or I would end up in hell.”

Childless Scrooge&#39s first apparition came in the form of his old business partner, Jacob Marley, taken from the world seven years ago after receiving a huge misselling bill.

“That old codger Marley was just standing there at the end of my bed. He started off a good adviser but became a salesman for Zebedee Advisory Network, hardening his craft and graft, so no matter how tightly the widows would hang on to those pound notes, he would always make a sale,” recounts Scrooge. “But his ghost was a terrible sight and he described to me his own living hell where to this day he is perpetually finding out he has sold Inverness Asset Management split-caps,” he shudders.

Marley then told the quivering Scrooge that he would receive visitations from three spirits. “Without their visits, you cannot hope to shun the path I tread,” Marley explained.

Scrooge is clearly agitated when he relates waking in bed to find a ghoulish Sir Howard Davies at the bottom of the bed, saying that he was the ghost of Christmas past. Davies, dressed as Wee Willie Winkie, took him on a nightmarish journey through the office from hell – a scary place where exams were scorned, nobody had enough investment knowledge and the temptation of selling that endowment life policy to the single man proved just too great.

Having petrified Scrooge with the terrors of the regulatory framework, the bedshirted ghoul disappeared in the direction of the London School of Economics.

“I was beginning to think I would never get another decent night&#39s sleep when I was woken again. But this visitation was a more pleasant experience altogether,” a dreamy-eyed Scrooge recounts. “I was taken through space by a representative of a life company, the ghost of Christmas present, who took me to an office with a huge pile of £50 notes stacked on a desk, with a card on top saying: &#39Let me invest in you.&#39”

Scrooge cannot disguise his unadulterated delight when describing his final encounter. “I woke to find my bedroom filled with a golden light and at the end of the bed stood a golden bull. I was surprised to learn that this was the ghost of Christmas future. Having climbed on to his back, he took me to a place where the FTSE stood at 8,000, bars and restaurants had taken over the premises of failed bancassurers, PI cover cost £50 a year and the FSA had given a clear definition of misselling.”

This series of ghostly appearances had a profound effect on Scrooge. Traumatised by the regulatory burden and personal exposure risk, he has given up his lifelong labour of love that was advice for an easier path.

“I thought, there is a better way, I just need to get involved in changing things. No more &#39Bah, humbugging&#39, I want a quiet life and a civil service pension,” he explains.

Fortunately for Scrooge, an opportunity has appeared down at Canary Wharf and, beating off stiff competition from within the FSA, he takes up his new role as head of the regulator next October. Scrooge is looking forward to winding down. “It has got to be easier than being an IFA,”he says.

Lives: Cheapside, alone.

Born: December 25, 1810, Rochester, Kent.

Career: 1830 to date. Partner at Scrooge & Marley, a member of the Misers network.

Career ambition: No great expectations other than a career hat-trick of head of the FSA, director of the LSE and governor of the Bank of England

Life ambition: To sell out for more than Ken Davy

Likes: Coins, notes (all denominations), cheques, gold.

Dislikes: Spending.

Peers say: “He&#39s always first out of the taxi and last in the pub.”

Car: “I don&#39t need one, Shanks&#39 pony is good enough for me.”


A pig of a year

The big news of 2002 came early on with the January publication of CP121 outlining the FSA&#39s plans for depolarisation and the defined-payment system.The PI nightmare started in February, with prem-iums rocketing over endowment misselling fears.In February, we reported that Misys was set to outsource some comp-liance processing to India, a move that was “exclusively” […]

Adair Turner to lead independent commission on compulsion

The Government is establishing an independent pensions commission to look at issues surrounding compulsion chaired by former CBI director general Adair Turner. The move has been attacked by opposition MPs and IFAs who claim it is trying to bury the issue. The extent of the commission&#39s remit will be to make recommendations to ministers although […]

Zurich confirms a thousand jobs to go in UK by end of 2003

Zurich Financial Services has confirmed that it is to shed 1,000 jobs from its life business in the UK by the end of next year. It says 250 jobs have already gone, most through compulsory redundancies. Another 750 will go next year, mostly in IT and customer services, and although the company says it plans […]

Govt hopes for Sandler-style plans are slammed

The Government is pinning its hopes on Sandler-style pensions distributed through high-street banks and State-sponsored phone and web advice services to increase pension provision among low and middle earners.But IFAs and providers have slammed the proposals, saying pensions will not be sold as long as there is a rigid commission cap on Sandler&#39s suite of […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm