View more on these topics

Duty is in the eye of the beholder

Some months ago, Hargreaves Lansdown decided not to offer with-profits bonds and Prudential UK chief executive Mark Wood is reported to have described this as a “dereliction of duty” in Money Marketing&#39s recent round table on with-profits.

I found it an astonishing attack. It is the adviser&#39s job to advise on suitable products. Many IFAs and investors have been let down badly by with-profits over the last few years and consider it to be no longer viable. IFAs have no duty to sell life offices&#39 old-fashioned products. Their duty is to clients.

One of the most discussed issues among IFAs today is how to get clients out of these products in the face of punitive market value adjusters.

It is not that with-profits has not performed historically but most IFAs have no confidence that it will do so in future. This is not based on sentiment, it is based on economics. Reserves built up often over 100 or 200 years have been consistently run down in the scramble for new business and the final nail in the coffin was probably the introduction of the with-profits bond contract in the late 1980s.

The problem is that with-profits is opaque and there is often a substantial conflict of interest between the actuaries and management, who represent the shareholders, and the policyholders who are the main beneficiaries. This point was picked up by Sandler, who recommended eradicating this conflict of interest in any replacement product design.

Smoothing may have worked for investors when reserves were huge and markets riding high but those reserves are largely gone and the only certainty is that providers stricken by fallen equity markets, orphan asset stripping, over-ambitious payouts and the pressure of realistic accounting will use smoothing to rebuild those reserves and they can only do that by not paying out.

Smoothing can only work against today&#39s investors and that alone must make IFAs think twice about with-profits. But there is a deeper problem. Increasingly, regulators are concerned that clients should understand the risks they take with any investment decision.

Endowment misselling claims have been all about this. Investors bought low-cost endowments to get cheaper mortgages. At that time, no one in the retail market thought of investment risk in association with endowments. Today, IFAs and their clients are more sophisticated. In an increasingly litigious world, IFAs simply cannot afford not to understand an investor&#39s attitude to risk.

But it is impossible to assess with-profits risk due to the opacity and discretionary nature of these investments. Even more concerning is that investment risk is driven not by the needs of policyholders but the needs of life offices exercised at the discretion of actuaries.

We have recently seen many with-profits funds move away from equities into fixed interest at or near the bottom of the equity market and at a time when the fixed-interest market is high. Many investors will be unaware that the investment risk they are taking has changed dramatically. I do not think anyone would claim this was a smart move on behalf of investors – it was driven only by the needs of providers as reserves were depleted. Realistic accounting will encourage this trait.

I know what I would call a “dereliction of duty”. It is life offices encouraging clients to invest in something which is opaque, where there is a massive potential conflict of interest between the decision makers and investors and where asset allocation has been driven by the needs of the decision makers. Try explaining that to the thousands of investors who have lost out on terminal bonuses or who want to move out of with-profits but face penal MVAs set by the actuaries.

You cannot take the risk out of investing but you can provide simple, transparent products allowing IFAs to create appropriate portfolios based on investors&#39 attitude to risk.

Brett Williams is managing director of Selestia


Star Japan manager to leave Framlington

Star Japan fund manager David Mitchinson is to leave Framlington to join J P Morgan Fleming in a shock departure. Mitchinson, 27, is manager of the highly successful Framlington Japan fund. It has been the number one fund in the Japan sector, with IFAs saying not only has it topped the performance tables, but has […]

BBB claims VAT bills will see IFAs quit networks

IFAs looking for more protection from VAT bills, escalating regulation and astronomic professional indemnity insurance will jump ship from networks to nationals, says Berkeley Berry Birch. BBB chief executive (network division) Richard Howells believes the VAT issue could be the last straw for many small IFAs who could find their networks passing on the cost […]

&#39Complaints charge for consumers needs act of Parliament&#39

The Financial Ombudsman Service is very unlikely to charge consumers for lodging complaints because such a policy change would require an act of Parliament, the Money Marketing IFA round table heard last week. FSA managing director David Kenmir said that while he understood IFA concerns at the way that consumers are encouraged to complain, he […]

Davy dismissive of FSA &#39plot&#39 to oust small IFAs

DBS and SimplyBiz founder Ken Davy has hit out at Scottish Widows&#39 claim that the FSA is using the professional indemnity insurance crisis to push IFAs into consolidation. Widows chief executive Archie Kane told Money Marketing last week that he believes the FSA is pushing IFAs towards consolidation by increasing the regulatory burden and through […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm