View more on these topics

Alistair Cunningham: Drilling down into capacity for loss

Assessing clients’ capacity for loss requires a different conversation to risk tolerance but advisers’ views on digging deeper will vary.

Risk profiling questionnaires have significant issues and we use them as part of a far broader discussion of the investment risk someone is willing and able to take.

Capacity for loss is a related but different conversation. I do not profess to be an expert, but I strongly believe that it is our role as an adviser to express our views on how a client might be able to withstand market shocks, or otherwise, and how they can prepare themselves accordingly. 

This view is certainly not universally held.

There are those who believe capacity for loss is a fictional construct. As markets will only fall temporarily, they believe that to invest in anything other than 100 per cent equities is a disservice to clients and that they need to be “behaviour managed” through the irrationality of falling markets.

The problem with this opinion, in my view, is that it does not take into account the extremes of market reduction and that this could also impact at a time when a client is drawing from their capital. 

Alistair Cunningham: Mortality assumptions remain a sticking point for planners

A £4,000 output from a £100,000 fund may be prudent – but if the fund is £50,000 due to a 50 per cent downturn, then the markets need to more than double (117 per cent growth) in order to return the fund back to £100,000.

There is limited value in client input too, particularly in some of the potential responses to “what would you do if the market fell by xx per cent?”. This is usually a risk tolerance question and may not tell us anything about the financial implications of capacity for loss. If the answer is emotional (“I’d not be able to sleep”, “I’d cash in”, “I’d buy more” etc) then this might adjust the risk score for obvious reasons but it tells us nothing about capacity for loss unless the answer is financial (“take fewer holidays”, “borrow some off a relative”, “cash in my premium bonds”, “starve” etc). 

But these are general fact-finding questions and can come from good cashflow planning.

Modelling a financial crisis on a cashflow plan can be counter-intuitive. I suspect the reason that some individuals are compelled by the “hold more equities” approach is they make a long-term financial plan look rosier – it’s not surprising if you are using a deterministic approach where the effect of equities, over the longer term, is to increase your anticipated returns.

Alistair Cunningham: Where are all the good conferences and events?

Stochastic modelling may go further to show the uncertainty of these returns, but both systems rely on the fallacy that investment returns are normally distributed. 

In reality, the “long tail” outlier events may be more common. Attempts to tweak a deterministic model to be more pessimistic by simply using bottom quartile returns, for example, do not fairly represent what might happen. So, if we think a 25 per cent downturn is very unlikely, what are the actions we would take if this happened and what can we do to improve resilience? 

Clearly the individual willing to take fewer holidays might need to do little but other individuals may need cash buffers, partial annuitisation, insurance or similar.

The problem now is that markets may well be irrational but in an overly positive direction and investors have a greater feeling of security than the reality. 

When there is an inevitable correction, if the only feasible plan is to sell in order to survive, the next downturn would be a lot worse than the last.

Alistair Cunningham is director of Wingate Financial Planning



Quilter Investors chief: ‘We are not here to sell funds based on performance’

Quilter Investors chief executive on designing funds advisers want rather than giving the hard sell Anyone who thinks rebranding is marketing speak for simply changing a company’s name, think again. As Quilter Investors chief executive Paul Simpson will testify, there is much more to it. Not only does it entail strategic and marketing decisions – […]

Platform costs

How low can platform costs go?

Will technology drive fees below 10 basis points? Downward pressure on fees and charges has been affecting all corners of the retail investment market, with experts now questioning exactly how low pricing can go when it comes to adviser platforms. However, finding efficiencies must be balanced with the ability to run a viable business, as […]


Thousands duped out of pension savings by rogue advisers

Rogue advisers have caused savers to lose hundreds of thousands of pounds after being abandoned to a “Wild West” of pension rules, according to a Sunday Times report. Its report shows how some advisers have exploited the outdated laws and loopholes to lure unassuming investors into high-risk products, leaving them unprotected when dodgy bets have gone […]


Legal and General IM takes on Unilever over corporate strategy

Legal and General Investment Management has stepped up its activist position over Unilever, declaring its intention to vote against the consumer goods giant’s plans to consolidator the firm overseas. LGIM says it has taken the “unusual” step by announcing its decision well ahead of Unilever’s general meeting next month due to “significant client enquiries”. Unilever […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm