View more on these topics

Drawdown rawbacks

There could be a nasty shock in store for people taking income drawdown.

Many IFAs recommend drawdown for clients at retirement as a flexible method of providing an income and keeping control of the capital. But it is important to be aware of one potential problem that could happen without a little foresight.

The amount of income taken under a drawdown arrangement is limited both in the minimum that can be taken and the maximum, with the limits set by the Government Actuary. Under current rules, an annuity must be purchased with the remaining fund at 75.

By opting for the minimum income, the value of the pension fund will be used up less quickly than if the maximum income is taken. This means there will be a greater pot to buy an annuity at 75 or to pass to beneficiaries on death before this age.

When a person who has implemented drawdown dies before reaching 75, the remaining fund passes to the beneficiaries, less a tax charge of 35 per cent. However, there is also a potential inheritance tax charge on the remaining fund.

When a person dies, it is the duty of his or her legal personal representative to administer and distribute the personal estate. Before they can do this, they have to complete Inland Revenue forms, which include questions about pension arrangements. This is how the Capital Taxes Office finds out about these arrangements and cases where inheritance tax may be due.

Last year, the ABI and the CTO finally agreed guidelines on the IHT position on personal pension income withdrawal. One part says a claim for IHTwill not be made where the pension arrangement is a genuine pension arrangement, made and operated to provide retirement benefits.

Outside this, a claim could arise if there is evidence that decisions were made or action taken deliberately to increase somebody else&#39s estate rather than to make provision for the individual&#39s retirement.

Most typically, this would be where a member was in ill health when the decision was made and acted on. “Ill health” in this context means terminally ill or in such ill health as to be uninsurable.

As a rule of thumb, if somebody made a decision or took action and lived for two years, then he is deemed to have been in good health at the relevant time. But this is not the case if, when the decision or action was taken, he knew he was in serious ill health and got lucky and lived for two years.

Given these circumstances, the beneficiaries of anybody who sets up an income drawdown arrangement based on the minimum income level, in the knowledge that they may die within two years, could be liable to an IHT charge. By taking the minimum income, the amount payable to the beneficiaries would be maximised and could be seen as deliberately increasing the beneficiaries&#39 estate.

Charles Mullins, the Edinburgh-based partner of independent financial adviser The Pensions Partnership, finds the whole thing farcical. “If an individual takes the minimum income option when he knows he is terminally ill, he could be seen to be avoiding tax,” he says. “Also, if the income is varied between the maximum and minimum limits, the Inland Revenue sees this as a means of avoiding tax.”

Scottish Equitable pensions development director Stewart Ritchie points out these conclusions came after “years and years” of discussions and believes they are logical extensions of other IHT rules.

He says: “The way it has ended up is to project into the pension drawdown arena the principles that the CTO has been using for death taxes for donkey&#39s years,” he says, adding he has no particular view if they are fair or unfair.

But it appears the chances of the beneficiariesof an individual being charged with IHT in these circumstances are fairly unlikely. ABI pensions manager Bridget Moss says: “The good news is that, although these rules are in place, there are likely to be very few cases where there will be problems with IHT. It is only likely to occur in restricted circumstances where it is benefiting the spouse on the death of the policyholder.”

Despite the problems that could occur if the CTO feels there is an IHT case to answer, there are steps that can be taken to make sure there is no tax liability. Mullins says: “If a client is terminally ill and wants to set up income drawdown – because this is the best way of passing the estate to beneficiaries – we recommend that the maximum income is drawn.”

Ritchie says: “Anybody who has got an inheritance tax problem should address the issue while they are in good health.”

If an income drawdown scheme is set up, it is possible that checks will be made by the CTO to make sure there are no underlying reasons for setting up the arrangement. According to Mullins, the Revenue made checks once his client had died.

“The arrangement was investigated,” he says. “But, because the client was taking maximum income, there were no problems.”

Before setting up an income drawdown scheme, customers and their IFAs should make sure they have looked at all the alternatives to provide an income. “If the only alternative to income drawdown is to buy an annuity, the income drawdown route could be the lesser of two evils as far as the estate is concerned,” says Ritchie.

But Ritchie adds that, if anybody is going ahead with income drawdown, they should make sure all the reasons for doing so are well documented. “It is essential that people put in writing the reasons they are doing it,” he says.

Mullins has an alter-native way of using a pension fund to provide an income as well as preserving the remaining value of the fund. “An alternative is to use phased retirement, with only a small proportion of the fund in income drawdown” he says. “This will have the effect of protecting the assets in the tax-free proportion of the fund.”


The survival of the fittest

Stakeholder will bring planning to the fore ahead of just flogging plansSpotting the winners in the stakeholder pension market isa matter of careful analysis.The Welfare Reform and Pensions Act in 1999 laid out the basic framework for stakeholder pensions. During 1999, the Government issued a series of consultation papers on detailed aspects. Regulatory Update 64, […]

Pacific rim comes under the investment microscope from Premier Asset Management

The Pacific rim is coming under the investment microscope from Premier Asset Management.The new Premier Pacific income fund is an investment trust composed of three specific pools of investment. The first will invest in the Pacific basin excluding Japan stocks and shares, the second will invest in global corporate and Government fixed interest bonds and […]

FSA finally set to alter compliance attitude

The way the FSA conducts its hated compliance visits could change as a result of a new consultation process which will look at the approach to supervision.FSA head of training David Jackman revealed to Money Marketing it is planning a high-level consultation on supervision towards the end of August.Spokeswoman Jackie Blyth says it will look […]

Finance flummoxes 75% of the public

Nearly a third of adults regret buying a particular financial product because they had not taken proper advice, according to Mintel research.The Education and Advice in Financial Services survey also reveals almost three-quarters of adults are confused over financial products due to lack of education.One in 10 of the 1,635people questioned have visited the Citizen&#39s […]

How QE is distorting the gilt market

By Mike Riddell The moves in gilts in August were truly exceptional. Volatility in the gilt market (based off 10-year gilt futures) has soared to close to the highest levels seen this millennium, on a par with the eurozone debt crisis of 2011/12 and behind only the global financial crisis of 2008/09. The first distortion […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm