View more on these topics

Draw a real picture of drawdown

As usual, Lorna Bourke has done little to further the cause of sophisticated financial journalism with her latest article on income drawdown.

While I agree with her that advising on drawdown should become a special activity, her assessment of the market and the reason why clients use the schemes is entirely wrong. In addition, her pathetic example illustrates only the type of client who should not take a drawdown contract.

Since the introduction of drawdown, I have made my position clear both to product providers and the PIA – this type of advice should be a specially regulated activity.

Drawdown advice cannot generally be considered on its own merits but requires an holistic financial planning approach based on the client&#39s long-term income and capital requirements. This requires a strong working knowledge of personal taxation, investment planning and pensions.

Once the most appropriate course of action is identified, the adviser must be in a position to provide a regular investment monitoring and financial advisory service to the client as these types of scheme inevitably require ongoing investment, pension and tax advice.

For this reason, I believe the minimum requirement would be AFPC including G60 if the adviser is to prove overall competence. In addition, some form of investment monitoring software such as Hindsight or Micropal would be needed.

So far as the types of client taking up these plans are concerned, overall pension income is not always the main motivational factor. Ms Bourke&#39s one-dimensional assessment of client objectives is, I am afraid, all too common among those who have no experience of providing financial advice.

Most clients want to retain control of their capital and enjoy the flexibility that a phased/Sipp/drawdown product offers.

Many clients are only semi-retired or are starting a new career which requires an initial income or capital boost from their pensions. Most have additional capital or other sources of retirement income. Few are idiots or dupes. All understand the risk associated with drawdown and require value for money from their adviser.

Advice of the standard and quality required for this type of product is no simple matter, however, and does not come cheap. Ms Bourke and her compatriates have to realise that there is no such thing as a free lunch and the standards of advice they call for will not be delivered on the cheap.

As the director of a company that offers advice in this market, I can assure Ms Bourke that, although the average case may not cost 5 per cent to advise on, it does cost more than 1 per cent. In addition, there is an ongoing cost associated with the additional monitoring which amounts to 0.5 per cent.

Our advisers are remunerated by salary only, with no sales bonus. Our clients can choose either a fee or commission-based route. Those clients who do opt to take advantage of these plans understand the costs and why they are levied. They are also significantly more sophisticated than Ms Bourke gives them credit for.

While I understand that Ms Bourke&#39s brief is to be contentious and to raise awareness, she should also try to gain a better understanding of her subject. I unfortunately cannot afford to be blase with regards to facts and figures as my clients rely on qualitative research and information. If only the same could be said for some financial journalists.

Andrew Moore


Berkeley Jacobs,





Commercial Union and Guardian Royal Exchange saw their share prices dip after the worst UK floods in 50 years. CU&#39s share price closed down by 15p to 1265p, with GRE&#39s share price falling by7.75p to 432.25p on Tuesday. Estimates of the cost of the floods to the insurance industry range from £400m to £1.2bn.

It&#39s all grow for &#3998

1998 is set to be a record year for life and pension companies but the hectic pace of growth seen in 1997 is going to slow, according to a Money Marketing survey of the biggest companies operating in the IFA market. Growth is forecast to be around 7-8 per cent in 1998 following a startling […]

Chapman takes helm at Permanent

Income-protection specialist Permanent Insurance is promoting sales and marketing manager Andrew Chapman to managing director. Chapman, 39, formally takes over from Patrick Harris-Deans on January 1. Harris-Deans will continue in his role as managing director of Medical Sickness.

DSS misses point on stakeholder pensions

The 64 questions in the recent DSS consultation document on stakeholder pensions range from the general to the very detailed. For example: “What would be the most appropriate way of establishing stakeholder pension schemes so as to provide security for members and effective mechanisms for ensuring that schemes are run in the interests of members […]

Brexit Commentary from Natixis Global Asset Management

By David F Lafferty, CFA, SVP – Chief Market Strategist Thursday’s historic Leave vote in the UK will have both immediate and long-term consequences for the global economy and financial markets. The initial flight-to-quality reaction across asset classes has been exacerbated by the market’s misplaced confidence in a Remain victory leading up to the vote. Stock markets […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


    Leave a comment


    Why register with Money Marketing ?

    Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

    News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
    Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

    Money Marketing Events
    Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

    Research and insight
    Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

    Have your say
    Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

    Register now

    Having problems?

    Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

    Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm